Evaluate eds analysis

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM132184371


In this assignment you will complete a paper on the following situation:

Ed Draycutt is the engineering manager of Airway Technologies, a firm that makes computer systems for air traffic control installations at airports. He has proposed a new device the success of which depends on two separate events. First the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) must adopt a recent proposal for a new procedural approach to handling in flight calls from planes experiencing emergencies.

Everyone thinks the probability of the FAA accepting the new method is at least 98%, but it will take a year to happen. If the new approach is adopted, radio makers will have to respond within another year with one of two possible changes in their technology. These can simply be called A and B. The A response is far more likely, also having a probability of about 98%. Ed's device works with the A system and is a stroke of engineering genius. If the A system becomes the industry standard and Airway has Ed's product, it will make a fortune before anyone else can market a similar device.

On the other hand if the A system isn't adopted, Airway will lose whatever it's put into the new device's development.

Developing Ed's device will cost about $20 million, which is a very substantial investment for a small company like Airway. In fact, a loss of $20 million would put the firm in danger of failing.

Ed just presented his idea to the executive committee as a capital budgeting project with a $20 million investment and a huge NPV and IRR reflecting the adoption of the A system.

Everyone on the committee is very excited. You're the CFO and are a lot less excited. You asked Ed how he reflected the admittedly remote possibility that the A system would never be put in place. Ed, obviously proud of his business sophistication, said he'd taken care of that with a statistical calculation.

He said adoption of the A system required the occurrence of two events each of which has a 98% probability. The probability of both happening is (.98x.98=.96) 96%. He therefore reduced all of his cash inflow estimates by 4%. He maintains this correctly accounts for risk in the project.

In this assignment you will:
1. Evaluate Ed's analysis. Does Ed have the right expected NPV? What's wrong with his analysis?
2. Suggest an approach that will give a more insightful result.
3. Discuss why the firm might consider passing on the proposal in spite of the tremendous NPV and IRR Ed has calculated?
4. Evaluative if Ed's case be might be helped by a real option. If so, what kind? How would it help?

Part 2

Even with a 4% probability of failure, the investment of $20 million is extremely high for a small corporation like Airway. Ed should explain in detail the process as to how he arrived at the expected NPV and IRR values and should also disclose the fact that the failure of the project can adversely affect business operations. He should clearly inform the management about the potential risks associated with the project and the consequences that the organization may have to face as a result of the failure.

Part 3)

One of the reasons the firm might consider passing on the proposal is the substantial amount of investment in the project. The management of the company may not wish make an investment of such a magnitude. Secondly, the methodology used by Ed (in the calculation of expected NPV and IRR) may not appear to be correct to the management. Thirdly, the 4% probability of the failure of the project (subject to disclosure by Ed) may appear to be very high as it can cause the company to shut down its operations completely.

Part 4)

In the given case, the failure of the project is contigent to non-acceptance/installation of the system (that is 4%). Ed can suggest the use of an abandonment option. The project can be completely abandoned if it appears during the first year that the system will not be installed/accepted by the industry. This may result in loss of some of the development costs that might get incurred on the system, but may not cause a severe disruption in business operations.

Reference no: EM132184371

Determine the flow in the great snake river

The confluence of the Red River and 5 Mile Creek forms the Great Snake River. At the confluence, the Red River has a flow rate of 540ft3/s, while 5 Mile Creek has a flow rate

Describe ethical considerations within the evaluation stage

Explain what factors could prevent your policy objective(s) from being implemented. Explain what factors you feel could contribute to your policy meeting its objective(s). Def

Organizational behavior class

I have a case study for my organizational behavior class. It suppose to be 2000 words answer. I have the case in a book which I can scan and send, however the answer needs to

What arguments based on the fourth amendment

What arguments based on the Fourth Amendment to the United States Constitution should Deft make in support of this motion - what arguments should the prosecutor make in opposi

Which specialty area interests you the most and why

Using both the assigned readings and additional research, respond to the following: Which specialty area interests you the most? Why? According to the specialty area, what kno

Should alternative to descriptive epidemiology be considered

Do you agree or disagree with this statement? Give reasons for your answer. Should alternatives to descriptive epidemiology be considered? Why? Support your answer with exam

Blogs or web logs provide

Blogs" or web logs provide an easy way for people to post opinions on any subject - including work-related issues or individuals. Some businesses have established their own bl

Memory capacity and speed processing-pathological condition

Can someone help me understand the comparison between the declines in working memory capacity and speed of processing with a pathological condition like anterograde amnesia



12/19/2018 1:11:50 AM

This assignment DEALS WITH HAVING AN ANALYSIS ON The Capital Budgeting techniques and ensuring that such methods are not self-sufficient and requires methods like sensitivity analysis and real method analysis. Hence, to complete this assignment an overall knowledge about the whole financial strategic management subject is required. Whatever I asked for is answered. This is quite complex assignment of statistics and they really did it very well. Each and every graph was explained in detailed.


12/3/2018 4:05:26 AM

I and my friend would ask you for 2 writing paper works, by using same questions/ work. The attach file also provide the short answer which I did not know how to rewrite to be 7-8 pages, so need your help. Hope you help me to do this. The format should be: -Use a minimum of 8 credible sources that are cited within the essay. -Include proper citation of any graphs or figures that you do not create yourself. -Be formatted according to the 6th edition APA form and style.

Write a Review

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd