Does the principle of patient autonomy apply here

Assignment Help Operation Management
Reference no: EM131272022

The case is that of a 35 year old white, single, female who was found on her bed stuporous and moaning by her father and mother with whom she lives. There was a note in the room written by her explaining that she had carefully considered her life and what was happening to her and that she wanted to die. There was evidence in the bathroom that she had most likely taken three bottles of different pills including barbiturates. The family immediately called the paramedics and the patient was taken to the nearby hospital emergency room. The physician was presented with the note and the bottles and since the patient was not fully unconscious began to insert a nasogastric tube to aspirate the contents of the stomach. As he was attempting to get the tube down, the patient became briefly more responsive and cried out that she didn't want the tube, she didn't want any treatment and that she wanted to be left alone and allowed to die. She moaned that she had left a note which said she wanted to die and she meant it. The family arrived in the next few minutes and informed the physician that she had not seemed depressed to them and she had never seen a psychiatrist but the medications were prescribed by her general physician. When told about what she had requested of the physician, the family urged that the doctor continue treatment.

What should he do next? The physician realized that if she had consumed the pills in the bottles she would most likely not survive without medical treatment and yet it seemed clear that she did not want any treatment.

The issue is whether the doctor must follow the request of the patient and stop treatment and allow her to die.

Please address the following questions:

1) Does the principle of patient autonomy apply here?

2) Can the physician perform a treatment against the consent of the patient?

3) What is the responsibility of the ER physician in this matter?

4) Must the physician be required to participate in completing an attempted suicide?

Reference no: EM131272022

Questions Cloud

What are the different types of payer organizations : We will begin discussing chapter and delve deeper into managed care organizations. What are the different types of payer organizations? Are there pros and cons of each?
Identify some strategies : Identify some strategies that will promote success in graduate school/graduate students. What can graduate level students do to maximize their learning and education to prepare for their future career, as well as increase their likelihood of success ..
Within ethics-democracy and professionalism : Within ethics, democracy, and professionalism, there are three core answers that are important to an ethical public manager? Please list and define the values and virtues of each.
The study of logic enables us to communicate effectively : Advertisements often rely on spoken or written statements that portray their product in a good light.The purpose of an ad is to persuade us to buy the product. "The study of logic enables us to communicate effectively, make more convincing arguments,..
Does the principle of patient autonomy apply here : The case is that of a 35 year old white, single, female who was found on her bed stuporous and moaning by her father and mother with whom she lives. There was a note in the room written by her explaining that she had carefully considered her life and..
Phase of evaluating alternatives in decision-making process : Explain the importance of emotional intelligence? Explain why you should aim to be both a specialist and a generalist in your future career? Differentiate between the various management levels in an organization? Discuss the phase of evaluating alter..
Differentiate in various management levels in organization : Explain why you should aim to be both a specialist and a generalist in your future career. Differentiate between the various management levels in an organization. Give an example of a current societal trend and how it might affect a specific business..
Explain the importance of emotional intelligence : Identify four reasons that managers have trouble delegating. Describe how a gantt chart and a PERT chart are similar, and how they are diffrent? Explain the importance of emotional intelligence. Write an essay on mission and strategic vision. Give an..
Against tort reform with focus on why organizations leave : Evaluate arguments for and against tort reform with a focus on why organizations leave the United States to avoid large tort damage awards. Use academic or legitimate news sources, such as The New York Times, the Los Angeles Times, The Washington Pos..

Reviews

Write a Review

Operation Management Questions & Answers

  Process of strategy formulation-implementation

How might the process of strategy formulation, implementation, and evaluation differ for (a) large businesses, (b) small businesses, (c) not-for-profit organizations, and (d) global businesses?

  Research the impact of global shipping

Research the impact of global shipping and receiving at ports around the world

  Briefly describe the developing selection program

Identify and briefly describe the constraints involved in developing a selection program and other factor affecting work performances.

  Remaking the industrial economy

Please give a short answer for each point based on the article - “Remaking the industrial economy,” McKinsey Quarterly, Feb 2014. What is the problem identified by the authors and why is it important? What is the circular “regenerative” model describ..

  Case study - mcdonald corporation

This case discusses McDonald's Corporation and the situation it faced in 2001. After many years of double?digit growth in sales and net revenue, the company's sales grew only 1.12 percent and net revenue dropped 17.2 percent from 2000 to 2001.

  Discuss slowpoke drivers-high-speed-sensible-speed drivers

Suppose you want to write a paper on different kinds of drivers. You think you can discuss slowpoke drivers, high-speed drivers, and sensible-speed drivers. You feel you have the most details about high-speed drivers. Should you start with that type ..

  Explain the database specialist or the business manager

Identify the data problems that must be resolved as you determine the system of record for each of the attributes in the proposed data warehouse. Who should make those decisions, the database specialist or the business manager leading this data w..

  Dictum of management theory

It has long been a dictum of management theory that leaders must adapt their behavior to fit the specifics of a situation. Discuss whether transformational leadership is appropriate for all occasions. In which situations might it not be effective and..

  Policy of protectionism have on organizations and products

One of the big issues in this year's Presidential election is the idea of keeping jobs here in America rather than companies using cheaper labor overseas. Many countries employ protectionism and this position can impact strategic plans of organizatio..

  Case study surface bargaining

In the Carrell, Heavrin textbook, at page 251, review “Case Study 1 Surface Bargaining.” After reading the case study, explain whether the company was bargaining in good faith, and which company proposal was the most important in determining the “in ..

  Use the five-step decision-making process discussed

Use the five-step decision-making process discussed in Chapter 1 of Ethics in Information Technology (book) to analyze the following situations and recommend a course of action. You have been asked by the manager of software development to lead a sma..

  Discuss why process improvement methodology

Discuss why process improvement methodology is important for all managers to be aware of and utilize? Provide examples of how this directly impacts healthcare agencies.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd