Comparing the interpretations of jj saunders
Course:- Humanities
Reference No.:- EM13141621

Assignment Help
Expertsmind Rated 4.9 / 5 based on 47215 reviews.
Review Site
Assignment Help >> Humanities

Choose two or three scholarly historical monographs offering different interpretations of the same or a related topic. Discuss the ways in which the interpretations of the historians concerned reflect differences in 
The evidence used. 
Perspective of the individual historian (e.g. national, ideological/ political, religious, gender, etc.). 

What argument is the author making? Moreover, do the two monographs each offer a different interpretation of the same issue?

The task is asking you to compare two different interpretations of a similar topic and explain why the authors reached these different conclusions. 

I would perhaps suggest comparing the interpretations of JJ Saunders (The History of the Mongrel Conquests, 1971) with the interpretations of Leo De Hartog (in either the book you've identified or Russia and the Mongol Yoke, 1996) with regards to the nature of and/or the significance of the Mongol conquests. Do these authors see the nature of the mongol conquests/invasions to be different? Ie. more or less oppressive/violent? Do they draw different interpretations of the long-term implications of these conquests? 

You should also ask yourself, why did these authors draw these different conclusions? What were their books trying to achieve? What evidence did they use and how?

Put your comment

Ask Question & Get Answers from Experts
Browse some more (Humanities) Materials
What is a stakeholder? Why is their role important in the advocacy process?What is the relationship between politics and advocacy?Do community needs assessments always lead to
Describe the creators. Are the creators male or female, and of what significance is gender? Describe what they created, including the steps or cycles of creation. Also, incl
Write the answer " why I am a good candidate for this position". - Some additional information is that I am fluent in Spanish and English, I had been in Latin America, and o
What are some leadership responsibilities of the police in preparing a community for the possibility of a terrorist attack? How would police carry out their duties?
Choose a social problem, and explain how the sociological imagination, as defined by C. Wright Mills, can be used to understand the causes and consequences of that problem.
Analyze your primary conflict management style.- What makes you think this is your primary style?- Describe a pseudo conflict that you and your Partner have experienced.
Linda and her eight year old son are regularly beaten and insulted by her husband. Linda is financially dependent on her husband and is too scared to protest or to complain
The focus of the capstone project is to solve a contemporary social and criminal justice issue through the application of information from a variety of related fields, whic