Characters response meets the challenge of argument

Assignment Help Humanities
Reference no: EM13891167


Read the following dialogues. In each one, the first character gives an argument and the second character responds to it. Find those cases in which the second character's response meets the challenge of argument and indicate that it does and explain how. Find those cases in which the second character's response does not meet this challenge and indicate that it does not. Then reconstruct the arguemnt so that it does meet the challenge. In each case, explain the basis for your answer. Assess each dialogue for the ARG.

Submit your paper in essay format: intro, assessments and reconstructions, conclusion.

1. Jim: A mediator should be completely neutral between the two parties in a dispute. If he or she is on the side of either party, the process will be unfair to the other party. In addition, the disadvantaged party will probably detect the lack of neutrality and then the mediation won't work. Neutrality is probably the most essential of all qualities for a mediator to have. And because the United States is the world's only superpower, it will never be perceived as neutral. The idea that the United States can go in and mediate in the conflict between Israelis and Palestinians is completely stupid!

Roger: I don't think so. It's the one country capable of bringing pressure on both sides, and that's the most fundamental thing.

2. Steve: I would never let myself be hypnotized by anyone, for any reason. Peter: Why not?

Steve: Too much is at stake. I just don't trust anyone that much. When you let somebody hypnotize you, they are getting right inside your mind, and they have a lot of potential to control you. Hypnosis is dangerous because it opens your mind to too much outside influence.

Peter: I can see what you mean but I don't know; hypnosis helped me a lot when I was quitting smoking. I used it once for dental work too, and it was great.

3. Nicholas: Legislation compelling children to wear helmets when they are riding their bikes is really a good thing. The latest statistics from the Canadian Institute for Health Information show that hospitalizations due to cycling-related injuries decreased by 12.5 percent between 1997 and '98 and 2001 and '02, and during the same period, head injuries decreased by 26 percent. Helmet laws really work.

Kaitlyn: That's great news. But I wonder whether these declines are actually the result of the legislation. I mean, it could be that people are cycling less, or that public education campaigns about helmets are helping more than the actual legislation.

Note: The evidence described by Nicholas was publicized in the Globe and Mail for March 26, 2003.

Verified Expert

Reference no: EM13891167

How does that module conceptually relate to second module

SOC 420:What module did you find the most interesting in terms of class concepts, and why?How does that module conceptually relate to the second module you read?How do both m

Does it trace the history of the issue adequately

Backgrounders are in-depth information pieces. As the name implies, they provide background information for anyone wishing it-reporters, ad copywriters, speechwriters, and ed

What does the term the dark ages mean

What does the term the Dark Ages mean and In what ways were the Dark Ages dark - In what ways was this society inadvertently preparing to emerge in modernity through the pre

Monopoly became americas best selling game in 1935

Why do you think Monopoly became America's best-selling game in 1935 during the Great Depression?- Discuss the characteristics of the game and how it reflects the reality of

What are the differences

Courts commonly order children to be given life-saving treatment, even against their own wishes and the wishes of their parents. Courts seldom order adults to be treated aga

Discuss about the applications use in personality testing

you will take on the role of a psychologist who was recently assigned two new clients. You will examine psychological assessment information presented in two different forma

The social movement of time and place

This week we're reading across disciplines: history, philosophy, music, art, Europe, America, Asia...welcome to the Humanities. Hence our discussion will focus on influences

Explain the importance of situating a societys cultural

Explain how key social, cultural, and artistic contributions contribute to historical changes - Explain the importance of situating a society's cultural and artistic expressio


Write a Review

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd