Use of shares of the minority, Business Law and Ethics

Use of shares of the minority:

X, Y and Z held 4,500, 4,500 and 1,000 one pound shares respectively, of Company B.  They were the only shareholders and  X and Y were the directors.  X and Y wished to eliminate Z.  S.210 however is not available to individuals.  So X and Y formed a new company (Company A) in which they were the only two shareholders.  Company A then offered to acquire all the shares of Company B.  X and Y accepted the offer but Z did not.  Company A served notice on Z that it has secured 90 per cent acceptance (the shares of X and Y) and intended to acquire Z's 1,000 shares under s.210.  Z applied to court.

Held:

Company A was a sham since (lifting the veil of incorporation) it was merely the majority shareholders (X and Y) in Company B seeking to expropriate the shares of the minority (Z). S.210 could not be used in these circumstances.  Z's objections were upheld.

 The alternative to acquisition under s.210 (in a take-over bid) is a scheme of arrangement under s.207.  The choice may be determined by comparative costs (see paragraphs 8.3.7(c) and 8.3.8).  Stamp duty is payable (at the two per cent ad valorem rate) on transfers of shares of Company B in a transaction to which s.210 applies.  It can be avoided under s.207.  But under s.210 procedure there is usually no expense of court proceeds as few minority shareholders persist in their objections to the point of making application to the court (at some expense to themselves).

 On the other hand if there is uncertainty about obtaining 90 per cent acceptance and a scheme of arrangement is not excessive in costs it is an easier route to the intended result.  It is particularly useful when Company A is seeking to acquire those shares of a partly-owned subsidiary (Company B) which it does not own.  In such cases some minority shareholders of B may be indifferent or passively opposed; Company A cannot count on their acceptances (to achieve 90 per cent) but reckons that they cannot or will not deny it a three quarters majority at a meeting.  There is often a delicate balance of conflicting risks and considerations in choosing between s.207 and s.210 in such situations.

Posted Date: 1/15/2013 4:32:32 AM | Location : United States







Related Discussions:- Use of shares of the minority, Assignment Help, Ask Question on Use of shares of the minority, Get Answer, Expert's Help, Use of shares of the minority Discussions

Write discussion on Use of shares of the minority
Your posts are moderated
Related Questions
I. Sammy has been under continuous employment with World Entertainment Ltd for 5 years. Last Friday Sammy was called to the Director's Office and verbally informed that h

State the legal consequences of an wrongful act Article 28, 30 and 31 state the legal consequences of an internationally wrongful act. They are as follows:- Article 28: Lega

Provisional Contracts - Law of Contract However occasionally an agreement may be illustrated through the parties thereto as being as "a provisional agreement" until a legally

Lifting the Veil of Incorporation: The legal rule that a registered company is at law a different person altogether from the subscribers to the memorandum of association and o

Describe the function and structure of IAEA The function and structure of IAEA is defined in IAEA statute. IAEA has three main bodies: Board of Governors, General Conference a

What is the neighbour rule? Duty of care: There is a duty of care by anyone to other where this can be reasonably foreseen which one’s action may injure another (negligen

Purchase of Shares - Voidable Contracts However an infant who applies to is allotted, a company's shares becomes a member to the company under S.28 (2) for the Companies Act f


Types of Precedents There a precedent may be as; A binding precedent here judge must tag along whereas he approves of it or not. Hence it is excludes his judicial discr

Determine the term - Fixed Exchange Rates With a fixed exchange rate adjustment toward long run equilibrium occurs via monetary effects. This effect is shown in Figure 9.1. At