Use of shares of the minority, Business Law and Ethics

Use of shares of the minority:

X, Y and Z held 4,500, 4,500 and 1,000 one pound shares respectively, of Company B.  They were the only shareholders and  X and Y were the directors.  X and Y wished to eliminate Z.  S.210 however is not available to individuals.  So X and Y formed a new company (Company A) in which they were the only two shareholders.  Company A then offered to acquire all the shares of Company B.  X and Y accepted the offer but Z did not.  Company A served notice on Z that it has secured 90 per cent acceptance (the shares of X and Y) and intended to acquire Z's 1,000 shares under s.210.  Z applied to court.

Held:

Company A was a sham since (lifting the veil of incorporation) it was merely the majority shareholders (X and Y) in Company B seeking to expropriate the shares of the minority (Z). S.210 could not be used in these circumstances.  Z's objections were upheld.

 The alternative to acquisition under s.210 (in a take-over bid) is a scheme of arrangement under s.207.  The choice may be determined by comparative costs (see paragraphs 8.3.7(c) and 8.3.8).  Stamp duty is payable (at the two per cent ad valorem rate) on transfers of shares of Company B in a transaction to which s.210 applies.  It can be avoided under s.207.  But under s.210 procedure there is usually no expense of court proceeds as few minority shareholders persist in their objections to the point of making application to the court (at some expense to themselves).

 On the other hand if there is uncertainty about obtaining 90 per cent acceptance and a scheme of arrangement is not excessive in costs it is an easier route to the intended result.  It is particularly useful when Company A is seeking to acquire those shares of a partly-owned subsidiary (Company B) which it does not own.  In such cases some minority shareholders of B may be indifferent or passively opposed; Company A cannot count on their acceptances (to achieve 90 per cent) but reckons that they cannot or will not deny it a three quarters majority at a meeting.  There is often a delicate balance of conflicting risks and considerations in choosing between s.207 and s.210 in such situations.

Posted Date: 1/15/2013 4:32:32 AM | Location : United States







Related Discussions:- Use of shares of the minority, Assignment Help, Ask Question on Use of shares of the minority, Get Answer, Expert's Help, Use of shares of the minority Discussions

Write discussion on Use of shares of the minority
Your posts are moderated
Related Questions
Corgi was the breeder of prize-winning pedigree dogs that often sold for very high prices. Reynolds, a wealthy businessman who had recently retired, decided to purchase one of thes

Question 1: Explain in full details the various negotiation tactics and the ethical criteria that you, as a negotiator, may use to achieve your projected goals and bring positi

Question 1: List out and explain the elements necessary for the formation of a contract. Question 2: What are the advantages and disadvantages of choosing a company ov

Domicile of Dependence Moreover this is the domicile a person acquires by virtue of legal dependency. Hence it is determined through the domicile of the other person. Howev

Explain the modes of  acquiring territory There are certain modes of  acquiring territory. Before 1948, there were a  lot  of  territories available and mostly areas were unkno

QUESTION 1 (a) By referring to the features documentary credits, explain how such an instrument can enhance and facilitate business activities (b) Discuss the applicability

Determine about the Mundell-Fleming model The basic two country Mundell-Fleming model assumes that both countries are small. It is this assumption that we modify and assume in

Hire-Purchase Law A person who wants to buy goods through does not have the like "money consideration" prescribed through the Sale of Goods Act like their price may enter in a

Statutory report - meetings and resolutions: Contents of the statutory report.  Section 130(3) provides that the statutory report shall be certified by not less than two direc

Q. Evaluate nature of phoenix activity? The literature on phoenix activity and the stakeholders consulted in this project emphasised that phoenix activity has evolved significa