Traditional case brief, Business Law and Ethics

The  defendants, while sympathetic, may believe that the ultimate responsibility of a child's safety and welfare belongs to the parent themselves. To the extent that the parents were aware the child was attending a party where alcohol was served, it was the parent's duties (Ryan's parents) to educate  their child about the dangers of alcohol consumption and drinking and driving.

From a social perspective, perhaps, each of them  should be  liable to some degree, especially where  there is  an adult knowingly violating the teenage drinking law. There should have been a social obligation for these parents to abide by the law, even if not out of personal concern for the minor children.

Moral convictions might weight against  the defendants.   It would seem that just a common sense notion of human decency and caring for children should have compelled the defendants to be more concerned about a young person drinking and driving.

In your traditional case brief, you will not have this section.  So, don't be confused or alarmed if you are unfamiliar with having this section in your case brief assignments.  For my courses, I ask students to include this section for several reasons, the most important of which is that it is an exercise in critical thinking.

An essential aspect to critical thinking is being able to evaluate the same set of facts from different and diverse perspectives.  This is a key skill in legal analysis, as you are tasked to think about the legal issues from not only your own or your client's perspective, but from that of opposing sides as well.  This is necessary so that you understand both the strengths and weaknesses of a case.  Moreover, it is a crucial aspect of demonstrating objectivity within the law.  As sometimes no matter how passionate you and/or the client might be about a particular matter, if the law does not support the position, then you have to be able to see and explain that.  The only way that you get to this understanding is being able to evaluate, articulate, and argue various perspectives.   It is often very easy for us to argue and support our own opinions and beliefs.   It is  much more challenging task to understand and articulate those opinions and beliefs to which we are opposed and/or unaware.

In this section, you don't have to believe it.  The task here is for you to be able to at least see the other  possible  perspectives,  understand the legitimate arguments that might be made from those  perspectives, and articulate those perspectives with the intellectual integrity  and vigor they merit.

Posted Date: 2/26/2013 4:41:35 AM | Location : United States







Related Discussions:- Traditional case brief, Assignment Help, Ask Question on Traditional case brief, Get Answer, Expert's Help, Traditional case brief Discussions

Write discussion on Traditional case brief
Your posts are moderated
Related Questions
What is International Civil Aviation Organization The Chicago Convention on International Civil Aviation 1944 governs and regulates the laws of air space and outer space. Furth

Question 1: (a) Who is a director of a company and describe how he may be appointed. (b) What are the duties owed by directors under the Companies Act 2001? Question 2

Ben sold clothes at a market stall on weekends for a number of years. Two years ago business was very poor and Ben was forced to cease trading. Ben sold all of his remaining stock

Define the term - Credibility and Reputation Nature and characteristic of the environment in which a policy has been chosen has a number of important implications. As we have a

steeple analysis about setting up a buisiness

Redemption of Shares: Section 60 (1) empowers a company limited by shares to issue preference shares that are, or may be at the option of the company are to be liable, to be r

Question 1: (a) Explain the concept of Salomon Principle and critically analyse its importance in company Law. (b) Discuss why and in what circumstances the court will pierc

LEGISLATIVE OR PARLIAMENTARY CONTROL: (i)         Parliamentary approval and (ii)        Ministerial approval and (iii)       Publication into the England Gazette and

Define the Strategic Voting and Policy Process Now we take up an important issue with respect to policy process. In standard models, where a single vote is taken directly as re

Irene walked into a store carrying a bottle of soda she had purchased a few days earlier. While in the store, she opened the bottle of soda and was drinking it while she