Realization of auditors, Business Law and Ethics

Realization of Auditors:

it is a mere truism to say that the value of loans and securities depends on their realization.  We were told that a statement to that effect, is so unusual in an auditor's certificate that the mere presence of those words was enough to excite suspicion.  But, as already stated, the duty of an auditor might infer from an unusual statement that something was seriously wrong, it with no means follows that ordinary people would have their suspicion aroused by a similar statement, whether as in this case, there its language expresses no more than any ordinary person would infer without.....the balance sheet and profit and loss account being true and correct in the sense that they were in accordance with the books.  But they were, nevertheless, entirely misleading, and misrepresented the real position of the company.  Under these circumstances I am compelled to hold that Mr. Theobald failed to discharge his duty to the shareholders...  Possibly he did not realize the extent of his duty to the shareholders as distinguished from the directors, and he unfortunately consented to leave the Chairman to explain the true state of the company to the shareholders instead of doing so himself. 

The fact, however, remains, and cannot be got over, that the balance sheet and certificate of February 1892 did not show the true position of the company at the end of 1891, and that this was owing to the omission by the auditor to lay before the shareholders the material information which he had obtained in the course of his employment as auditor of the company, and to which he called the attention of the directors....  Where did the money come from with which the dividends were paid?  The money came from cash at the bankers or in hand; but this cash could not be properly treated as profit, and the directors and auditors knew this perfectly well...."

Posted Date: 1/15/2013 2:40:02 AM | Location : United States







Related Discussions:- Realization of auditors, Assignment Help, Ask Question on Realization of auditors, Get Answer, Expert's Help, Realization of auditors Discussions

Write discussion on Realization of auditors
Your posts are moderated
Related Questions
Part A A director has a duty to exercise care, skill and diligence at common law and also a statutory duty of care and diligence under s180 (1) Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) in c

Right to sell - Terms used in Contract With S.14 (a) provides that there is an implied condition such seller has a right for sell the goods and, like in the case of an agreeme

Change of Name: A company's name may be changed voluntarily or compulsorily (a)   Voluntary Change A company's name may be changed voluntarily: i. Under s.2.1 if a sp

QUESTION 1 Discuss the legal relationship between a bank and its customer with reference to the responsibilities of the parties towards each other QUESTION 2 (a) Examin

Self-Confidence: Entrepreneurs are self-confident and tackle problems immediately with confidence and are persistent in the pursuit of their objectives. Most are at their best in

Determine in detail about the money market Prior to the change in monetary policy both countries are assumed to be in equilibrium at point A in both of these diagrams. Only at

Powers and Duties:  The powers and duties of the secretary depend on the size and nature of the company and the personal contractual arrangements that it makes with him. Howev

Capacity - Sales of goods Through S.4 (1) provides such capacity to buy and to sell is governed through the natural law concerning capacity for contract. Although where necess

Both Sudan and the US are signatories to the "New York Convention."  A Sudanese company has won its case in a Sudanese arbitration panel.  The U.S. company has declined to pay this

QUESTION 1 What are the scope and limitations of administrative law? Is the demarcation clear? What are the criteria by which you would decide on which side of the line a case