Re london and general bank, Business Law and Ethics

RE LONDON AND GENERAL BANK:

          An auditor represented a confidential report to the directors calling their attention to the insufficiency of the securities in which the capital of the company was invested, and the difficulty of realizing them, but in his report to the shareholders merely stated that the value of the assets was dependent on realization, and in the result the shareholders were deceived as to the condition of the company, and a dividend was declared out of capital and not out of income.

HELD:

          The auditors had been guilty of misfeasance under S.10 of the Companies like winding-up, Act, 1890 of, and was liable to make good the amount of dividend paid as amounting here to $14,433.3s.

                        LINDLEY, LJ.: "....... it is the duty of the directors, and not of the auditors, to recommend to the shareholders the amounts to be appropriated for dividends and it is the duty of the directors to have proper accounts kept, so as to show the true state and condition of the company........ it is for the shareholders, but only on the recommendation of the directors, to declare a dividend.  It is impossible to read the section of the Companies Act without being struck with the importance of the enactment that the auditors are to be appointed by the shareholders and not to or regards to the directors, are to report to them directly. Therefore the object of this enactment is obvious.  It evidently is to secure to the shareholders independent and reliable information respecting the true financial position of the company at the time of the audit.....  It is no part of an auditor's duty to give advice there, either to shareholders or to directors, so as to what they ought to do.  However an auditor has nothing to do with the prudence or imprudence of making loans including or without security.  It is nothing to him whereas the business of a company is being conducted prudently or imprudently or unprofitably or profitably.

Posted Date: 1/15/2013 2:36:39 AM | Location : United States







Related Discussions:- Re london and general bank, Assignment Help, Ask Question on Re london and general bank, Get Answer, Expert's Help, Re london and general bank Discussions

Write discussion on Re london and general bank
Your posts are moderated
Related Questions
QUESTION The Occupational, Safety and Health Act 2005 states that Every employer shall, so far as is reasonably practicable, ensure the safety, health and welfare at work of

Realization of Auditors: it is a mere truism to say that the value of loans and securities depends on their realization.  We were told that a statement to that effect, is so u

Patriot, Inc (a C corporation) filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection during August, 2011 and has worked out a re-organization plan that was accepted by the Bankruptcy Court an

Question 1: (a) What does Professional Practice mean to you? Define your perception of good Professional Practices. (b) Discuss some of the difficulties and challenges fac

Q. Impact on businesses of phoenix activity? In 1996 the Australian Securities Commission (ASC), published a report on phoenix activity titled Phoenix Activities and Insolvent

Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) has become a key aspect in the activities of an organization in the context of environment and community development, employees, customer serv

Hire-Purchase and Sale The hire-purchase transaction is such not a sale since, according to the definition like: (i)There is no seller or buyer. Such like the parties are the

LAW OF TREATIES Treaties are an important and major source of international law. It is a convenient way by which the States deliberately  enter into agreements with other State

Legal Protection  - significant instances: There are however a few but significant instances in which the Companies Act and the general law prescribe certain legal limits on t

State the third approach to antitrust agency A third approach to antitrust agency interaction is the bilateral cooperation and coordination theory. This model for how an agency