Purpose of the rule - statutory provisions, Business Law and Ethics

Purpose of the rule:

It has been stated by various English judges that without the rule in Foss v Harbottle

(i)            There would be futile actions.

 A court order made on an application by an aggrieved minority of members (such as the two members of the Victoria Park Co.) would be made redundant by a resolution passed later on at the company's meeting confirming or ratifying what the minority had complained of in court.

 (ii) There is a likelihood of multiplicity of suits if each and every shareholder were to institute proceedings without any co-ordination with the others.

 (iii) The principle of corporate personality enunciated in Salomon v Salomon and Co. Ltd would be undermined.  Since a company is a separate legal person it is the company that has suffered a wrong but not its members.

(iv) The principle of majority rule would be violated.

 The law views companies as democracies of the majority shareholders. On the other hand whereas the thing complained of is a thing which in substance the majority of the company are entitled to do, or whether something has been done irregularly that the majority of the company are entitled to do regularly, or whether something has been done illegally that the majority of the company are entitled to do legally, there can be no utilize in having litigation about it, the ultimate end of that is only like a meeting has to be recognized, and then ultimately the majority gets its wishes" (per Mellish, L.J. in MacDougall v Gardiner).

Posted Date: 1/15/2013 2:59:13 AM | Location : United States







Related Discussions:- Purpose of the rule - statutory provisions, Assignment Help, Ask Question on Purpose of the rule - statutory provisions, Get Answer, Expert's Help, Purpose of the rule - statutory provisions Discussions

Write discussion on Purpose of the rule - statutory provisions
Your posts are moderated
Related Questions
Terms used in Contract However there are certain terms may identify conditions and warranties like are implied into every contract covered through the Sale of Goods Act where

Enumerate the Working of coordination mechanism Take interesting case which will clarify the working of coordination mechanism better. If a member State in EMU, defaults on it

Legal Protection  - significant instances: There are however a few but significant instances in which the Companies Act and the general law prescribe certain legal limits on t

In 2004 the Corporations and Markets Advisory Committee proposed that assets and liabilities of companies be aggregated and creditors paid from a common pool which is commonly refe

Illustrate the example for Policy Convergence Suppose there are two candidates, with known positions, policy proposal p A and policy proposal p B , representing policy offers

Ratio Decidendi Conversely "ratio decidendi" of a case consists of the material facts of such case and the decision made through the judge on the basis of those facts.  So hen

Liability by Estoppel Anyone who presents himself or permits himself for be represented, further by words, conduct or writing as the partner about another person like  persons

Explain United Nations Commission on India and Pakistan One such resolution dated 20th  January 1948 created United Nations Commission on India and Pakistan (UNCIP), which was

Determine the term Uncertainty - Policy process We know that uncertainty is one of main influencing factor in policy process and especially in coordination of economic policies

Determine the primary criticism of the stages model The primary criticism of the stages model is that it tends to be front-loaded, which means, more attention is paid to policy