Purpose of the rule - statutory provisions, Business Law and Ethics

Purpose of the rule:

It has been stated by various English judges that without the rule in Foss v Harbottle

(i)            There would be futile actions.

 A court order made on an application by an aggrieved minority of members (such as the two members of the Victoria Park Co.) would be made redundant by a resolution passed later on at the company's meeting confirming or ratifying what the minority had complained of in court.

 (ii) There is a likelihood of multiplicity of suits if each and every shareholder were to institute proceedings without any co-ordination with the others.

 (iii) The principle of corporate personality enunciated in Salomon v Salomon and Co. Ltd would be undermined.  Since a company is a separate legal person it is the company that has suffered a wrong but not its members.

(iv) The principle of majority rule would be violated.

 The law views companies as democracies of the majority shareholders. On the other hand whereas the thing complained of is a thing which in substance the majority of the company are entitled to do, or whether something has been done irregularly that the majority of the company are entitled to do regularly, or whether something has been done illegally that the majority of the company are entitled to do legally, there can be no utilize in having litigation about it, the ultimate end of that is only like a meeting has to be recognized, and then ultimately the majority gets its wishes" (per Mellish, L.J. in MacDougall v Gardiner).

Posted Date: 1/15/2013 2:59:13 AM | Location : United States







Related Discussions:- Purpose of the rule - statutory provisions, Assignment Help, Ask Question on Purpose of the rule - statutory provisions, Get Answer, Expert's Help, Purpose of the rule - statutory provisions Discussions

Write discussion on Purpose of the rule - statutory provisions
Your posts are moderated
Related Questions
Usual procedure - shares of the minority: Hence the usual procedure is: (a)     first to dispose of possible objections by creditors by paying their debts or providing secu

Compensation for Loss of Office: (a) Section 192 makes it unlawful for a company to make a director any payment by way of compensation for loss of office, or  may as considera

Types of transaction - reconstructions: It will be seen that methods (a) and (b) relate to specific types of transaction.  They can only be used in those transactions.  The fl

Determine in detail about the money market Prior to the change in monetary policy both countries are assumed to be in equilibrium at point A in both of these diagrams. Only at

Select a manufacturing organization and find out the ethical issues of the organization in the following areas: Production: Marketing & sales: Human Resources & employee relatio

QUORUM: However a quorum is the minimum number of persons who must be present at a meeting in order that the meeting may validly transact the business for that it was convened

Estate Planning Case Study Rich and his wife, Ruby, heard that you are an expert in the field of Estate Planning as a result of the superior education you received at WPU.  The

Explain UNCTOC UNCTOC identified the concept of an organized crime. A crime is termed as an "Organized Crime" when people in different countries and/or of different national

Question 1: (a) Bob works as a machinist in XYZ Ltd where Mr Rony is the director. Bob gets injured whilst using the machine. Explain the action to be taken by Mr Rony in that

Methods of Public Issue: A company's authorised capital may be raised in one or the other of the following ways: a)      PLACING A 'placing' occurs if the company, inste