Property as control over access, Other Subject

Property as Control over Access

And so continues our search for the inner mystery of "property". Let us look back and see how far we have got since we started. There is no real likelihood that we have arrived at our destination, for the quest for the essential nature of "property" has beguiled thinkers for many centuries. The essence of "property" is indeed elusive. That is why, in a sense, we have tried to catch the concept by surprise by asking not "What is property?" but rather "What is not property?" We have started from the other end of the earth- both geographically and conceptually-and we have deliberately come by the direction which seemed least probable. But along the way we may have discovered something of value. We may have discovered the irreducible conditions which underlie any claim of "property".

The classic common law criteria of "property" have tended to rest a twin emphasis onĀ  the assignability of the benefits inherent in a resource and on the relative permanence of those benefits if unassigned. Before a right can be admitted within the category of "property" it must, according to Lord Wilberforce in National Provincial Bank Ltd. v. Ainsworth, be "definable, identifiable by third parties, capable in its nature of assumption by third parties, and have some degree of permanence or stability". This preoccupation with assignability of benefit and enforceability of burden doubtless owes much to the fact that the formative phases of the common law concept of property coincided with a remarkable culture of bargain and exchange. Non-transferable rights or rights which failed on transfer were simply not "property". Within the crucible of transfer lawyers affected to demarcate rights of "property" from rights founded in contract and tort or, for that matter, from human rights and civil liberties. Only brief reflection is required in order to perceive the horrible circularity of such hallmarks of "property". If naively we ask which rights are proprietary, we are told that they are those rights which are assignable to and enforceable against third parties. When we then ask which rights these may be, we are told that they comprise, of course, the rights which are traditionally identified as "proprietary". "Property" is "property" because it is "property": property status and proprietary consequence confuse each other in a deadening embrace of cause and effect.

Posted Date: 2/21/2013 6:21:32 AM | Location : United States

Related Discussions:- Property as control over access, Assignment Help, Ask Question on Property as control over access, Get Answer, Expert's Help, Property as control over access Discussions

Write discussion on Property as control over access
Your posts are moderated
Related Questions
Question 1 What are the common traditional channels of communication? Describe the problems that can arise in such forms of communication Question 2 Explain the Unilinear Mod

chemical reactions taking place while testing basic radicals?

In no more than one typed page, provide a statement of your decision to lend or not lend to this company based on your interpretation of the company's short-term prospects (i.e., l

why was the lowell system bad for girls?

Contemporary Feminist Thought: Feminist theory is one of the major contemporary sociological theories, which analyzes the status of women and men in society with the purpose of us

I have a homeworks to be done from a safety textbook. All that needs to be done is to read the chapter and answer the questions at the end of the book usually 20 questions per chap

i need to write a negative message here is the case: You''re one of the owners of a small human resources temp agency: A-1 Accounting Personnel. You and a fellow graduate of Bost

Question: (i) State the relationship and differences between social care and counselling. (ii) Critically analyse the two different social care counselling and the areas i

Question 1 The 12th dynasty brought Egypt to the pinnacle of its power. Discuss Question 2 Discuss ancient Egyptian belief in the afterlife Question 3 Discuss th