Propertiness of properly, Other Subject

Propertiness of Properly:

Perhaps the lasting significance of Victoria Park Racing lies in the fact that the conflict between the majority and minority views in this case throws up critical clues to the identification of the "propertiness" of property. True it is that much of the discussion in Victoria Park Racing was conducted obliquely in terms of the law of nuisance. But the central issue - so central that it lay largely unspoken - was whether the defendants had taken anything that might be regarded as the plaintiffs "property". (We must always be ready to hear the resonance of property in the dialogue of trespass and nuisance.)

There can be no doubt--and there was certainly none in the High Court--that in Victoria Park Racing the defendants had exploited a competitive commercial opportunity, in circumstances of no great credit to themselves, in order to profit from a market of horseracing enthusiasts who would otherwise have paid a lot of money to the plaintiff. In this sense the defendants had clearly taken something from the plaintiff but had they taken the plaintiffs property? Were the defendants guilty, as Dixon J. put it, of "misappropriating or abstracting something which the plaintiff has created and alone is entitled to turn to value"? In answering this question the majority and minority in the High Court were divided by fundamentally differing views of the phenomenon of "property"

The minority judges clearly believed that there had been a misappropriation. Rich J. spoke of each defendant as "appropriating ... part of the profitable enjoyment of the plaintiffs land to his own commercial ends...." In his view the conduct complained of had wrongfully diverted a "legitimate source of profit from [the plaintiff's] business into the pockets of the defendants". Evatt J.'s judgment echoed just as strongly the language of misappropriation. Evatt J. thought it "an extreme application of the English cases to say that because some overlooking is permissible, all overlooking is necessarily lawful". Here the overlooking engaged in by the defendants had enabled the broadcasting company "to reap where it had not sown". The defendants stood condemned of an unfair "appropriation" or "borrowing" of the plaintiff's investment of capital and labour. This had in turn enabled the listening public to "appropriate to themselves" the harvest of those who have sown.

Posted Date: 2/21/2013 6:19:53 AM | Location : United States







Related Discussions:- Propertiness of properly, Assignment Help, Ask Question on Propertiness of properly, Get Answer, Expert's Help, Propertiness of properly Discussions

Write discussion on Propertiness of properly
Your posts are moderated
Related Questions
With an aid of illustrative examples, analyse the distinguishing characteristics of a project.

History of Information Technology: In the year of 1960s and 1970s, the term information technology (IT) was a little known phrase which was used by those who worked in places such

DQ1 Explain the parts of a decision tree. What are some benefits of using decision trees? In what ways can decision trees be used for business decisions? Name some real-world examp

derivation of differential voltage gain for dual input unbalanced output

Problem 1: (a) Explain the term cognitive dissonance. (b) How can cognitive dissonance act as a powerful motivator? (c) How can the Attribution theory be used to motivate

Electronic Benefit Transfer Electronic Funds Transfer at Point of Sale (EFTPOS) is an Australian and New Zealand electronic processing system for credit cards, debit cards and

Hi i want to develop a smart home using Linux platform.I will be using UBUNTU .The aim and objective of this project is for the user to be able to control devices using Linux scrip

Variety of subjects: Roman painting provides an extensive variety of themes: animals, still life, and scenes from daily life, portraits, and some mythological subjects. Throughout

STRENGHTS AND WEAKNESS OF BEST PRACTISE MODELS OF HRM STRATEGY

QUESTION Read the text carefully and answer the following questions Psychology is a science which attempts to study behaviour and mental processes. At the beginning of the t