Negligence in general, Auditing

Negligence in General

There is no case against auditors and this made it hard to be accurate as to where the auditor’s legal liability falls.  We require therefore referring to decided cased. Though even in countries there are in fact very few decided cases against the auditors. The vast majority of actions against auditors are completed out of court. This saves what could or else be very costly court costs.  It is also important to note that this saves dragging the professional firm's name via the courts and most probable via the newspapers. Firms are of course concerned to avoid such awful publicity.

It is though usually known that the auditor's liability falls beneath three specific headings:

(a) To his clients underneath contract law;
(b) To third parties beneath the law of tort;
(c) Civil and criminal liability beneath statute law

To his clients: 

The auditor is under responsibility to report to the members in common meetings on all accounts observed by him and lay before them. His contract is thus with the company as an entire and not with separate shareholders. The auditor can thus be accused of carelessness if:

(a) He fails to notice scam or error that he must reasonably have noticed;
(b) When he fails to obey with generally admitted auditing standards and practices.

Though, it is also usually held that for an auditor to suffer real financial loss, the following situation should be met.

  • He must be confirmed to have been neglectful;
  • The complainant should have suffered a loss;
  • The loss should be as a direct result of his reliance on the auditor's report and the auditor’s carelessness.


Hence when the auditor fails to detect a scam that is immaterial to the accounts and unless there are suspicious situations which he had observed or must reasonably have observed, it is unlikely that he will be held neglectful.

Even when the fraud was material to the accounts, he might still escape liability if detection could not reasonably have been attained by using normal audit process.  It should be admitted though this is a very dubious region of law.

The auditor has no responsibility to separate shareholders. A shareholder who makes an investment decision by relying on the auditor's report and suffers loss cannot claim under the law of contract. Only when the company as an entire has suffered, can the entire body of shareholders claim from the auditor.

Posted Date: 12/3/2012 5:00:54 AM | Location : United States

Related Discussions:- Negligence in general, Assignment Help, Ask Question on Negligence in general, Get Answer, Expert's Help, Negligence in general Discussions

Write discussion on Negligence in general
Your posts are moderated
Related Questions
what a group auditing and holding campanies in details with exmple propurly???

What is the role of the auditor, and what are the key duties the auditor must carry out? Role of the Auditor In modern commercial environmental it is desirable that bus

Qualities for Final Accounts The qualities needed of the final accounts: the final accounts must possess specified qualities and these are: a) Utilize of acceptable account

Problem: "If the auditor wishes to place reliance on internal control,he should ascertain and evaluate those controls and perform compliance tests on their operation" (a) De

Audit Approach The auditor: 1) Must get the cooperation of the client, as simply the client can authorise third parties that communicate along with the auditor. 2) Choos

Plz assist me with these questions The auditors for Weston University are conducting their audit for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2011. Specifically, the audit firm is now

Action if Management Refuses to Provide Representations If management refuses to provide a representation that the auditor considers essential, this constitutes a scope restric

Auditors Procedures After Stock Taking It is particularly a follow up exercise and it includes: 1) Checking the cut off along with the details of last numbers of stock move

Communication with Expert Whether the auditor intends to utilize the work of an expert then he must communicate along with the expert well in advance to confirm the terms of e