Mischief rule, Business Law and Ethics

Mischief rule:

"Four things are to be considered and discussed:;

(i) First is 'what was the common law earlier than the making of the Act?'

(ii) is 'what was the mischief and defect for that the common law did not offer'

(iii) is 'what remedy has Parliament appointed resolved to cure the disease?'

(iv) and  forth is 'what is the true reason for the remedy?'  Judges shall.... make such construction as shall suppress the advance and the remedy".

However a statute will only be construed in signify with this rule whether its construction in accordance relates to the literal rule would fail to suppress or the mischief or punish.  There an example like a case of SMITH v HUGHES whether it was held that a prostitute who attracted the consideration of passers from a balcony window above the street had solicited in a street within Section 1(1) of the English Street Offences Act, 1959.  Therefore the judge stated as follows: as;

"I approach the issue through considering like as what is the mischief aimed at through this Act.  Everybody knows that this was an Act intended to clean up the streets then to enable people to walk along the streets without being molested or solicited through common prostitutes".

However viewed into way that the actual place from whether a prostitute attracted the attention of somebody walking in the street did not matter as well as she will be deemed to have solicited in the street.

Posted Date: 1/16/2013 2:55:55 AM | Location : United States







Related Discussions:- Mischief rule, Assignment Help, Ask Question on Mischief rule, Get Answer, Expert's Help, Mischief rule Discussions

Write discussion on Mischief rule
Your posts are moderated
Related Questions
Two very important resolutions which had a great impact on description of terrorism UNSC has also declared incitement as an offence. The interpretation of terrorism formulated

Question 1 "CSR can play a key role in contributing to sustainable development while enhancing Europe's innovative potential and competitiveness" Critically analyse the link be

Explain the International law International law is the body which governs State actions and its effective implementation within the States depends on the way in which States tr

Hypothetical case example: Allison is an 18 year old female student is the first year of an undergraduate university degree. She shares a double room in the university dorm wit

Question 1: Should the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council be maintained at the summit of the hierarchy of our judicial system? Critically discuss on the above. Ques

What forces the policy maker to obey the law When law directs a policy maker to carryout policy, what forces the policy maker to obey the law? When there is no restriction from

Special Courts However in addition to the courts dealt into paragraphs as 2.1 - 2.7 above, there exist in England a number of other institutions that are called "courts" or "t

QUESTION 1 S.38(2) and S.38(3) of the Employment Relations Act require that an employee should be given the "opportunity to answer the charge" before the employer decides to te

State the Definition of equilibrium The approach of equilibrium refinements aims at strengthening the definition of equilibrium itself in order to purge others out as possible

Duties of the Principal - Agency Law However the duties of the principal for the agent are like: Remuneration Whether to pay the agreed commission where it becomes du