Mischief rule, Business Law and Ethics

Mischief rule:

"Four things are to be considered and discussed:;

(i) First is 'what was the common law earlier than the making of the Act?'

(ii) is 'what was the mischief and defect for that the common law did not offer'

(iii) is 'what remedy has Parliament appointed resolved to cure the disease?'

(iv) and  forth is 'what is the true reason for the remedy?'  Judges shall.... make such construction as shall suppress the advance and the remedy".

However a statute will only be construed in signify with this rule whether its construction in accordance relates to the literal rule would fail to suppress or the mischief or punish.  There an example like a case of SMITH v HUGHES whether it was held that a prostitute who attracted the consideration of passers from a balcony window above the street had solicited in a street within Section 1(1) of the English Street Offences Act, 1959.  Therefore the judge stated as follows: as;

"I approach the issue through considering like as what is the mischief aimed at through this Act.  Everybody knows that this was an Act intended to clean up the streets then to enable people to walk along the streets without being molested or solicited through common prostitutes".

However viewed into way that the actual place from whether a prostitute attracted the attention of somebody walking in the street did not matter as well as she will be deemed to have solicited in the street.

Posted Date: 1/16/2013 2:55:55 AM | Location : United States







Related Discussions:- Mischief rule, Assignment Help, Ask Question on Mischief rule, Get Answer, Expert's Help, Mischief rule Discussions

Write discussion on Mischief rule
Your posts are moderated
Related Questions
QUESTION Gerald is aggrieved of the decision of the Minister of Public Infrastructure to build a high way bypass through his housing estate. Gerald has been advised to apply

Rights of Guarantor Against the Debtor Therefore the guarantor's rights alongside the debtor are: like; (a) Before the payment has been made, whereas to compel the debtor t

QUESTION 1 (a) According to Thomas Dye "Public Policy is whatever governments choose to do or not to do". How far do you agree? (b) Explain clearly how the first important s

Determine the focal point for coordination The focal point for coordination is point C, which is the unique symmetrical Pareto efficient outcome. Compared to this outcome the N

Significance of Registration:           S.389 provides that "no company or association or may partnership consisting of more than twenty persons shall be formed... except it i

Explain the term - Legislature - Legislature Trade off These interactions can be found in the literature of public choice and political science, and concerns to the coalition f

Order of application of assets: The order of application of assets is therefore as follows: (a) secured creditors who have fixed charges are entitled to be paid out of thei

Nature of a Company: There is no precise legal definition of "a company". This is due to historical reasons which are too lengthy to be narrated in this text. Suffice it to sa

Liability of Retiring Partner Whether unless there is a special agreement for the contrary like a retiring partner can be held liable no more in respect of debts incurred prev

Negotiable Instruments A negotiable instrument cannot be described regards precision, although can be explained like a commercial document that represents money. Whether it pa