Market value-transfer pricing methods, Managerial Accounting

Market value

There is universal agreement that in competitive markets a market value based transfer price should achieve optimal results. In this circumstance, it can be expected that:

1) The autonomy of the division is not undermined because markets determine the value of outputs, not centralized departments or divisional costs. Market prices would be seen to be objective and fair to all. The aim of creating an organizational structure where each division operates as an organization in its own right can be achieved. Ideally, suppliers should be permitted to sell to external customers and receivers should be allowed to buy from external producers.

2) Managers' performance reflects their ability to compete with external companies in a free market. This may be a fair indication of the manager's ability and potential to perform at higher levels within the organization and thus forms a fair basis for promotion and salary decisions;

3) From 2, it can be expected that the transfer pricing mechanism will be neutral in motivating managers to perform in accordance with organizational goals; that is, the transfer pricing mechanism will not be biased in any manner other than that created by market forces. Performance measurement schemes can thus be established to motivate managers to act in a goal congruent manner;

4) Reliable decisions would arise at divisional level. For instance, in a joint product situation, products, which should be sold at the split-off point would not be processed further since the post split-off processing division would show a loss based on the transfer price.

Unfortunately, two problems illustrate that market based prices may not be able to achieve these aims in all circumstances. The first problem arises because transfer pricing situations are not simply selling situations. The supplying division, for instance, does not have to incur the costs of selling normally associated with selling to external customers. The receiving division may be in a position to influence quality and delivery because it is in the interests of both divisions that the company as a whole prospers. It is sometimes desirable to adjust the market price to reflect such factors, with a commensurate loss in the objectivity which market prices can bring. The second problem is more fundamental; there may simply not be a perfect market in operation. A vertically integrated company, for instance, may not possess a market for its intermediary products. In this case, there is no market from which to establish market values. Other market imperfections would produce bias which would work to the benefit of either the supplying or the receiving division.

Posted Date: 12/8/2012 5:19:56 AM | Location : United States







Related Discussions:- Market value-transfer pricing methods, Assignment Help, Ask Question on Market value-transfer pricing methods, Get Answer, Expert's Help, Market value-transfer pricing methods Discussions

Write discussion on Market value-transfer pricing methods
Your posts are moderated
Related Questions
Determine the Zero bases budgeting According to Leonard mere According to Leonard mere,  ZBB is a technique which complements and links the existing planning budgeting and revi

M/s ABC has an existing sales of Rs.50 lakhs and permits a credit period of 30 days to its customers.  The firm cost of capital is 10% and the ratio of variable cost to sales is 85

Describe the impact of different types of standards on motivations and specifically,the likely effect on motivation of adopting the labor standard recommended?

Budgetary control According to CIMA the establishment of budgets relating the responsibilities of executive to the requirement of a policy and the continuous comparison of achi

Account analysis (Inspection of accounts) method: This method requires that departmental managers and the accountant inspect each item of expenditure within the accounts for s

Hornsby Manufacturing has four categories of overheads. The four categories and the expected overhead costs for each category for next year are as follows:   Maintenance  $140,000

Elements of cost: 1. Material: the substance from which the product is made is known as material it may be in a raw or a manufactured state. It can be direct as well as indir

#questioExercise 3-12 Computing Predetermined Overhead Rates and Job Costs [LO1, LO2, LO3, LO7] Kody Corporation uses a job-order costing system with a plantwide overhead rate base

case study on payroll system

Illustration of Standard error of estimate The production manager of XYZ Company is concerned about the apparent fluctuation in efficiency and wants to determine how labour cos