Inventor claims in adiabatic system - mechanics, Mechanical Engineering

Inventor claims in adiabatic system:

One inventor claims that 2 kg of air supplied to magic tube at 4 bar and 20°C and the two equal mass streams at 1 bar are produced, one at -20°C and other at 800C. The other inventor claims that it is also possible to produce equal mass streams, one at -40°C and the other at 40°C. Whose claim is correct and why? Consider that it is adiabatic system. (CP air 1.012 kJ/kg K)               

Sol: Given that:

Air supplied to magic tube = 2 kg

Inlet condition at magic tube = 4 bar, 20°C

Exit condition: Two equal mass streams, one at - 20°C and other at 80°C for inventor 1. One at - 40°C and other at 40°C for the inventor-II.

Assume that ambient condition 0°C i.e. = 0°C

125_Inventor claims in adiabatic system.png

Figure

This process is irreversible; the claim will be correct if the net entropy of the universe (system and surroundings) increases after the process.

Inventor I :

Total entropy at the inlet condition is

238_Inventor claims in adiabatic system1.png

S2 = 0.183

S2 = S1

S2  - S1 > 0

Hnne the claim of inventor is accepatable

For Inventor 2

S2  = 1. CP. ln (T1/T0) + 1. Cp  ln (T2/T0)

= 1 x 1.012ln[(- 40 + 273/273)] + 1 x 1.012ln[( 40 + 273)/273]

= - 0.0219KJ/K As              S2

S2  - S1 < 0

This violates the second law of thermodynamics. Therefore the claim of inventor is false. - ANS

 

Posted Date: 10/16/2012 6:58:10 AM | Location : United States







Related Discussions:- Inventor claims in adiabatic system - mechanics, Assignment Help, Ask Question on Inventor claims in adiabatic system - mechanics, Get Answer, Expert's Help, Inventor claims in adiabatic system - mechanics Discussions

Write discussion on Inventor claims in adiabatic system - mechanics
Your posts are moderated
Related Questions
Q. Examination requirements and acceptance criteria for weld? Examination requirements and acceptance criteria shall be in accordance with ASME Code, and the requirements of th

Merchants force diagram. State the assumptions made in development of such diagram.

Explain frequency reuse In the cellular concept, service area is separated into regions called cells and the available frequency is divided among these cells. Every cellular b


A solid shaft of diameter d is taken in power transmission. Because of modification of existing transmission system, it is needed to replace the solid shaft by a hollow shaft of th

How are the refrigerants classified? Describe the desirable property of a good refrigerant. Explain in brief the thermodynamics, safe and physical working property of an ideal r

The following items should be considered regarding the safe access and location of buildings: • The fire fighting pump house is usually located in a non-hazardous OSBL location

With the help of a neat diagram illustrate the working of Gasifier combined cycle power plant. Describe with the help of neat diagram the working of Pressurised water reactor nu

Q. Show Corrosion of BFW Pump? BFW pumps are in high-pressure high-temperature service and may be subject to cavitation and erosion-corrosion. Also overheating of these pumps i

Figure shows rough sketch of a selected representative critical part of a "Quick Coupler" (of an earth moving equipment) made with cast steel.  You need to perform FEA analysis to