Exceptions to the rule in foss v harbottle, Business Law and Ethics

Exceptions to the rule in Foss v Harbottle:

 According to Professor Wedderburn, the so-called exceptions are essentially no exceptions at all.  They appear to be circumstances in that such there is no chance of confirmation by the majority and to which the rule is, therefore, inapplicable.

However, the exceptions were summarised by Jenkins, L.J. in Edwards v Halliwell (100) as follows-

1. Ultra vires and illegality

  "Where the act complained of is wholly ultra vires the company or association the rule has no application because there is no question of the transaction being confirmed by whichever majority," (per Jenkins, L.J.)

 2.  Special majorities

 The rule in Foss v Harbottle does not prevent an individual member from suing if the matter in respect of which he was suing was one which could be done or sanctioned, not through a simple majority of the members of the company or association (i.e. an ordinary resolution), but only by some special majority (i.e. a special resolution) which has not been obtained.

Posted Date: 1/15/2013 3:00:03 AM | Location : United States

Related Discussions:- Exceptions to the rule in foss v harbottle, Assignment Help, Ask Question on Exceptions to the rule in foss v harbottle, Get Answer, Expert's Help, Exceptions to the rule in foss v harbottle Discussions

Write discussion on Exceptions to the rule in foss v harbottle
Your posts are moderated
Related Questions
QUESTION (i) (a) What is the composition of the Public Service Commission?     (b) How are the commissioners appointed? (ii) (a) What is the composition of the Judicial a

QUESTION 1 Discuss the sources of the Mauritian law QUESTION 2 (a) Tom, Pim and Pam enter into a lease agreement. The agreement has already been signed by Pim and Pam.

Power to dispense with the word "Limited":                             Although s.5 provides that the last word of the name of a limited company must be "limited" this would n

Mr. Hellerstein is a professor at Tahoe Law School located in Tahoe California. He lives in Nevada and commutes to Tahoe Law School, which is only a 50-mile, commute one way.  Duri

Explain the term- Sustainability One of the major problems identified for international policy coordination is whether the agreed outcome is sustainable. As can be seen from th

Q. Show the Suggested actions to address phoenix activity? There have been a range of options identified by previous works on phoenix activity, such as the Cole Inquiry and Tre

UNSECURED ORDINARY DEBTS: A secured creditor obtains payment (to the extent that his security is adequate i.e. if it exceeds in value the amount owing to him) because he has a

an impartial jury must

State Article 2 of air and outer space law Article 2 states that for the purposes of this Convention the territory of a state shall be deemed to be the land areas and territori

Variation of class rights: It is only necessary to follow the variation of class rights procedure (and a dissenting minority can only apply to the court for cancellation)  if