Exceptions to the rule in foss v harbottle, Business Law and Ethics

Exceptions to the rule in Foss v Harbottle:

 According to Professor Wedderburn, the so-called exceptions are essentially no exceptions at all.  They appear to be circumstances in that such there is no chance of confirmation by the majority and to which the rule is, therefore, inapplicable.

However, the exceptions were summarised by Jenkins, L.J. in Edwards v Halliwell (100) as follows-

1. Ultra vires and illegality

  "Where the act complained of is wholly ultra vires the company or association the rule has no application because there is no question of the transaction being confirmed by whichever majority," (per Jenkins, L.J.)

 2.  Special majorities

 The rule in Foss v Harbottle does not prevent an individual member from suing if the matter in respect of which he was suing was one which could be done or sanctioned, not through a simple majority of the members of the company or association (i.e. an ordinary resolution), but only by some special majority (i.e. a special resolution) which has not been obtained.

Posted Date: 1/15/2013 3:00:03 AM | Location : United States







Related Discussions:- Exceptions to the rule in foss v harbottle, Assignment Help, Ask Question on Exceptions to the rule in foss v harbottle, Get Answer, Expert's Help, Exceptions to the rule in foss v harbottle Discussions

Write discussion on Exceptions to the rule in foss v harbottle
Your posts are moderated
Related Questions
State in brief aboput the Monetary Effects Besides real income effects there will also be monetary effects if nations seek to intervene in foreign exchange markets which govern

Explain the Law of the Sea Convention 1982 The Law of the Sea Convention 1982 did not create a new area of law, as laws governing the sea date back to the dawn of maritime his

Question 1: Constructive dismissal is inherently different from dismissal in the sense that it is the employee who necessarily takes the initiative in considering the contract

Jack has operated a house building business as a sole trader for a number of years. Now, his accountant has recommended that he should consider registering as a company in order to

QUESTION 1 (a) Compare and contrast the different rules and features governing the burden and standard of proof in both civil and criminal cases (b) The art of advocacy is n

Determine the term miscoordination - Policy Formation A problem known as miscoordination in Policy Formation may also emerge and it may be either vertical or horizontal. Let us

Acceptance - Negotiable Instruments Meaning The word "acceptance" such used in relation to bills of exchange like has a special meaning also. Acceptance of a bill of ex

Main advantages - mergers and winding up: A scheme of arrangement under s.207 offers three main advantages: (a)     it can be used in circumstances to which s.210 and s.280

Contents and Form of Accounts - Accounts and audit: By s.149(1), every balance sheet shall give a true and fair view of the state of affairs of the company as at the end of it

QUESTION 1 What are the consequences of a unilateral modification of a contract of employment of indeterminate duration by an employer? QUESTION 2 (a) In what circumsta