Evaluation of dictionaries, Humanities

Evaluation of Dictionaries

In this section, we will touch upon some evaluation criteria which are useful for you in assessing the value of any dictionary you intend to acquire either for your personal use or for the reference collection of a library.

The advancement in lexicography as science in the last few decades has resulted in the publication of a number of new dictionaries. At the same time, the old ones, have often been revised, updated and brought out as new editions with more accurate information and in a new form or format. It is not possible for the librarian to purchase all the available dictionaries. At the same time one cannot expect any dictionary to be perfect. Dr. Johnson rightly observed while comparing dictionaries with watches that "the worst is better than none and the best cannot be accurate and self-sufficient. Language undergoes change continuously as new words are added and old ones become obsolete. Thus, the librarian has to examine the dictionary carefully before addition to the collections. He has to evaluate the value both in terms of money and contents.

The criteria on the basis of which dictionaries are evaluated-

  1. Authority 
  2. Scope or purpose 
  3. Word arrangement and word treatment 
  4. Format 
  5. Special features

 

Posted Date: 10/31/2012 7:34:41 AM | Location : United States







Related Discussions:- Evaluation of dictionaries, Assignment Help, Ask Question on Evaluation of dictionaries, Get Answer, Expert's Help, Evaluation of dictionaries Discussions

Write discussion on Evaluation of dictionaries
Your posts are moderated
Related Questions
Reference bibliographies The subject bibliographies which are mostly used for reference fall into this category. These bibliographies are considered to be exhaustive bibliogra

can you tell me what is the definition of sociocultural exchange ?

DATA ELEMENTS   In catalogue entries we not only provide for access points to meet the variety of user needs to find a document but also information about the document. The inf

NON CONVENTIONAL INDEXING MODEL - CITATION INDEXING Another unique indexing model was developed by Eugene Garfield in early 1960's. The model is non conventional in the sense

Government Publications All the government publications are referred to as the government sources of information. A government publication is that which is issued at governmen

HEADING   The Heading is the essence of a catalogue entry. It is the main 'access point for document. For a document, we decide first the heading under which the description ca

Thesauri and Subject Headings List   Both thesauri and subject headings lists are vocabulary control devices, but they are used in different situations. The essential character

Pre-literate Japanese Culture Jomon ( 11-3 rd century BCE.) Comes from the word "rope-patterns." Much of pottery from this period included rope patterns. Not very polished/s

Different Types of Dictionaries Though dictionaries are defined as reference books consisting of words and phrases, they cover almost every field of interest. We have a wide

Catalogue Codes   When we prepare a catalogue for a library collection, we follow a set of principles and rules to prepare the entries and to arrange and file them. Sets of rul