Evaluate the statistical arguments, Advanced Statistics

Evaluate the following statistical arguments. Begin by identifying the sample, population, and the property which is being investigated. Do these arguments sound acceptable? Would more information be required?

(i) From the NRL's annual report, we learn that all of the sixteen ongoing clubs selected for spot audits last year had financial irregularities sufficient to qualify the auditor's report.

Wherever they shone the light - and they shone it in four clubs - they found trouble. Not one decent effort. Clearly the league clubs just aren't complying with their affiliation requirements concerning financial probity.

(ii) Research has shown that Australians feel strongly about the importance of increasing funding for essential services such as hospitals, schools, and banks in rural areas. A telephone survey of 2,000 households was conducted, to gauge people's opinions about the importance of ensuring better funding for rural communities. To ensure that the interests of both urban and rural communities were represented, half of those surveyed were in rural areas, and half in urban areas. It was found that over 70% of those surveyed believed that providing adequate funding for these services was very important. In an election year, this is something the Government should be thinking about very closely. The views of 70% of Australians cannot be ignored.

(iii) A newspaper report] Computer theft is not a great problem in Australian offices, according to a recent survey. Only 39% of middle managers questioned agreed that computer theft would be the most likely cause of future unplanned expenditure on information technology. By contrast, 57% of managers in New Zealand, 41% of managers in the United Kingdom, and 55% of managers in Canada agreed with the question.

(iv) In 1872 Francis Galton conducted a study into the efficacy of prayer. The main argument of his study was as follows.

Many thousands of prayers are offered each day for the long life and good health of the monarch and the royal family, whether they be prayers in church, bedside prayers of children, or even the prayer contained in the national anthem. Moreover, praying for the health of the royal family is a longstanding tradition in the United Kingdom. If prayers can be efficacious, then surely at least some of these prayers will have been efficacious, and so one would expect to find the lives of members of the royal family longer than the lives of other people.

So Galton collected data from the death notices of leading newspapers on the average age at death of men who had reached the age of thirty, and whose deaths fell between 1758 and 1843 (deaths by accident and violence excluded). Members of the royal family (97 men) had an average age at death of 64.04, compared to 69.49 for clergymen (945 men sampled), 68.14 for lawyers (294 sampled), 67.31 for doctors and surgeons (244 sampled), 67.31 for aristocrats (1179 sampled), 70.22 for gentry (1632 sampled), 68.74 for merchants (513 sampled), 68.40 for naval officers (366 sampled), and 67.07 for army officers (569 sampled). Hence Galton concluded that members of the royal family did not tend to live longer than other people, and so that prayer is not efficacious.

Posted Date: 2/25/2013 12:33:47 AM | Location : United States







Related Discussions:- Evaluate the statistical arguments, Assignment Help, Ask Question on Evaluate the statistical arguments, Get Answer, Expert's Help, Evaluate the statistical arguments Discussions

Write discussion on Evaluate the statistical arguments
Your posts are moderated
Related Questions
Categorical variable : A variable which provides the appropriate label of observation after the allocation to one of the several possible categories, for instance, the respiratory

Median absolute deviation (MAD) : It is the very robust estimator of the scale given by the following equation   or, in other words we can say that, the median of the absolute

Play-the-winner rule is a process sometimes considered in the clinical trials in which the response to treatment is positive (a success) or negative (a failure). One of two treatm

Orthogonal is a term which occurs in several regions of the statistics with different meanings in each case. Most commonly the encountered in the relation to two variables or t

Multi dimensional unfolding is the form of multidimensional scaling applicable to both the rectangular proximity matrices where the rows and columns refer to the different sets of

How has quantitative analysis changed the current scenario in the management world today?

Bartlett's test for variances : A test for equality of the variances of the number (k)of the populations. The test statistic can be given as follows   where s square is an

This term is sometimes used for the data collected in those longitudinal studies in which more than the single response variable is recorded for each subject on each occasion. For

Over dispersion is the phenomenon which occurs when empirical variance in the data exceeds the nominal variance under some supposed model. Most often encountered when the modeling

Bartlett decomposition : The expression for the random matrix A which has a Wishart distribution as the product of the triangular matrix and the transpose of it. Letting each of x