Effect of ultra vires transaction, Business Law and Ethics

Effect of Ultra Vires Transaction:

 An ultra vires transaction with a company may result in:

a) a transfer of specific property to the company, or

b) money being lent to the company.

The remedies available against the company will be as follows.

 Property Transferred

If specific property is transferred to a company pursuant to a transaction which, unknown to the transferor, is ultra vires the company, the ownership of the property is not transferred. The property remains the property of the transferor while the company only acquires possession of it. This is because an ultra vires transaction cannot constitute a "contract" which, pursuant to the Sale of Goods Act, s.3, is capable of vesting or transferring the ownership of the property in the transferee company. The transferor, on becoming aware of the legal position, would be entitled to trace his property and, on finding it, take possession of it. This remedy is known as "tracing".

The company has no right to retain the property and its attempt to do so would constitute the tort of detinue.

The other consequence of this rule is that, since there was no contract of sale, the transferor cannot sue the company for breach of contract, or the agreed price. The legal position in the converse situation is not clear. It is probable that the company cannot recover its property by tracing if the transferee is willing to pay the agreed price. However, the company might be able to recover it if the transferee has failed or refused to pay for it because to allow him to retain it after refusing to pay for it would constitute "unjust enrichment" which a court of equity is unlikely to condone.

Posted Date: 1/12/2013 2:37:14 AM | Location : United States







Related Discussions:- Effect of ultra vires transaction, Assignment Help, Ask Question on Effect of ultra vires transaction, Get Answer, Expert's Help, Effect of ultra vires transaction Discussions

Write discussion on Effect of ultra vires transaction
Your posts are moderated
Related Questions
Legislature-Executive Trade off Let us move a bit closer to the reality. In standard modes of policy optimization we assure that there is a single policy maker, who controls th

QUESTION 1 Domain names deliver the address of companies on the Internet and are equivalent to the business address in the physical world. As more and more companies utilize th

QUESTION 1 What are the duties of an Occupational, Safety and Health officer in an organization? QUESTION 2 Section 47 (1) of the Occupational, Safety and Health Act st

Pat Clark is the controller for Best Pharma, a publicly-held pharmaceuticals manufacturer in Wilmington, Delaware.  In early December 2011, Pat's boss, CEO Bernie Skilling, approac

Explain International law on sir creek issue The issue concerning Sir Creek is of great importance for both India and Pakistan. The dispute does not concern the division betwee

Judicial Control: Conversely the courts can declare any law made as subsidiary legislation to be invalid or unacceptable under the ultra vires doctrine. Thus the law may be de

There are three main categories of international humanitarian laws: 1) The Hague conventions 2) The Geneva conventions 3) The additional protocols

Country Strategy in harmonising national It is proposed that the OMC should enhance the role of such Country Strategy in harmonising national and EC aid programmes. The OMC wi

Main advantages - mergers and winding up: A scheme of arrangement under s.207 offers three main advantages: (a)     it can be used in circumstances to which s.210 and s.280

State Article 9 of air and outer space law Article 9 states that each contracting State may, for reasons of military necessity or public safety, restrict or prohibit uniformly