Distortion energy theory, Civil Engineering

Distortion energy theory:

Let us now consider the solid shown in Figure.

1091_States of stress - principal stresses.png

(a)        By inspection we may see that the solid is safe according to principal stress theory (σ1 < 260).

(b)        Maximum principal strain ε1 = 200/E -0.3 (-100/E) = 230/E < 260/E

∴          The solid is safe according to principal strain theory too.

 (c)       Maximum shear stress τmax  =200- (-100)/2 =150>130

∴          Shear stress theory predicts failure.

(d)        Total strain energy density is as follows :

u =  1/2E  [2002 + (- 100)2  - 2 × 0.3 ×200 (- 100)]

=31000/E >      2602/E

∴          The solid is safe according to strain energy theory.

(e)        Distortion energy density is as follows:

ud = 1/12G([200 - (- 100)]2 + 2002  + 1002 )

70000/6G >     2602/6G

∴  Distortion energy theory predicts failure.

If what is safe according to one theory is unsafe according to the other theory although what is safe according to the second theory is unsafe according to while another theory, you might wonder whether to consider the solid as safe or not. Or should the solid be safe according to all the theories? That will put a extremely severe condition for safety. Shall we select a theory which we like best? Certainly not, we have to search out which theory correctly represents the failure criteria and choose it. It has been found from experience in which the shear stress theory (known as Tresca's Theory) suits brittle materials, although, the distortion energy theory (known as Von Mises' Theory) is appropriate for ductile materials. So depending on the nature of the material, the designer could choose the appropriate theory.

You might also remember, that it is not sufficient to be merely safe (irrespective of the theory), but that there should be a enough margin of safety, defined through the Factor of Safety selected depending on the nature of the problem.

Posted Date: 1/30/2013 6:42:06 AM | Location : United States







Related Discussions:- Distortion energy theory, Assignment Help, Ask Question on Distortion energy theory, Get Answer, Expert's Help, Distortion energy theory Discussions

Write discussion on Distortion energy theory
Your posts are moderated
Related Questions
Some compound or metal vanishes under certain conditions is? Answer: Due to Super conductivity some compound or metal vanishes

Define Investigation Scour for Underwater Inspection of Bridge? Investigation Scour is probably the most critical item to be aware of when performing an underwater inspection o

what is the classification of lintel

#How to find the sieve analysis of 20mm aggregate?

Calculation of deformation For calculation of deformation at some stage before the total creep is reached,  it may be assumed that about half the total creep takes place  in  f

Q. Write short notes on the following : a) Points to be kept in mind while collecting water samples for testing from tap, stream & T/well separately. b) Where and why foot

Q.for ISMB200 having 6.70 m span simply supported so find out load carrying capacity.


Abrasion Test:   This test is carried out on stones used as aggregates for road construction. The test result shows the suitability of stones against   the grinding action u

Question While designing sewer pipes , why vitrified clay pipes commonly is used for pipe size less than 600mm still as precast concrete pipes with PVC lining is used for pipe