Disadvantages of stare decisis , Business Law and Ethics

Disadvantages of Stare Decisis

Over-subtlety or Artificiality

However a judge is forced, but it were follow an earlier case that, his conscience may preclude him from following, he might be inclined for 'distinguish' the present case from the earlier case.  Thus this artificial 'distinguishing' sometimes creates artificial differences that make case law over-subtle for such.

Bulk and Complexity

Conversely so many cases are being decided everyday through courts all over the country, case law has become bulky and complex and it is suspicious if judges would really know whether a relevant earlier case had been decided to sure about, say some ten years ago.

Piece-meal

Hence rules of law are made in complete bits and pieces.

Posted Date: 1/21/2013 5:42:35 AM | Location : United States







Related Discussions:- Disadvantages of stare decisis , Assignment Help, Ask Question on Disadvantages of stare decisis , Get Answer, Expert's Help, Disadvantages of stare decisis Discussions

Write discussion on Disadvantages of stare decisis
Your posts are moderated
Related Questions
State the Definition of equilibrium The approach of equilibrium refinements aims at strengthening the definition of equilibrium itself in order to purge others out as possible

Determine the implications of the legislature Policy outcomes are the result of legislative bargaining. So policy becomes a compromise between the executive and the legislature

Negotiable Instruments A negotiable instrument cannot be described regards precision, although can be explained like a commercial document that represents money. Whether it pa

Loans to Directors: Section 191(1) renders unlawful any loan made by a company to a director of the company or its holding company. It is also unlawful for the company to guar

QUESTION 1 Why is the United States, which is a leader country in so many areas, so far behind in the provision of social welfare benefits? QUESTION 2 (a) Who uses private

QUESTION 1 Outline the history of Labour Laws in Mauritius QUESTION 2 a) In what circumstances can an employer raise the defence of abandonment of work? b) Section 1

CREDITORS' VOLUNTARY WINDING UP: If no declaration of solvency is made and delivered to the registrar, the liquidation process is a creditors' voluntary winding up even if i

Contributions of Equity Contributions of Equity as: Developed the so called maxims of equity and Provided additional remedies and Provided for the discovery of

State Article 19 and 20 of air and outer space law Article 19 refers to the registration or transfer of registration of aircraft in any contracting State shall be made in acc

What is the dispute resolving mechanism Obligation to follow a treaty between states arises only when it has been concluded in a written form. Moreover, a treaty must be in a