Critique of cost-benefit studies, Microeconomics

Critique of Cost-Benefit Studies

Numerous criticisms have been levelled against the approach of cost benefit studies. Many of these criticisms are centred on the assumptions underlying the cost benefit studies. For instance, assumption about the average span of working life in life time returns will vary from researcher to researcher. Some of the researchers do not take waiting time for employment into account or underestimate the same. Further, job in life need not be tied to the qualification of a person. Sometimes women are not considered for certain jobs even though they have the requisite qualifications.

Promotions within a career need not be based on additional qualifications or merit. There has been a long standing debate on the role of intelligence in success in life. Intelligence, defined as native ability, an inborn potential that is inherited from one’s parentage is considered as crucial for achievement and success in life. The environmentalists reason out that intelligence is a social construct. It has no meaning when it is divorced from social life. It is fashioned by the vicarious and rich quality of the social milieu in which one lives. The level of development of a society is dependent upon the levels to which a person’s abilities can blossom. Education, whether it is formal or informal or non formal, is one of these social determinants. Believers in inherited abilities discount the value of education in life time earnings. They consider that to a large extent the success of a person in a career or self employment or business or trade depends on his intelligence which is an inborn potential. Intelligence or innate abilities of a person, his personality structure, styles of work etc. may influence his chances of getting better jobs, promotions and higher earnings.


Keeping in view all these objections to the computation of returns wherein qualifications are given status as causal variables for life time earnings of a person, researchers in the area of cost benefit studies generally allow a correction factor, by way of a coefficient (or a constant), to take care of contributions to life time earnings from all the extraneous variables. The per centage of allowance credited to these variables ranges from 20 to 30 in studies on estimates of returns.

 

Posted Date: 12/17/2012 5:14:24 AM | Location : United States







Related Discussions:- Critique of cost-benefit studies, Assignment Help, Ask Question on Critique of cost-benefit studies, Get Answer, Expert's Help, Critique of cost-benefit studies Discussions

Write discussion on Critique of cost-benefit studies
Your posts are moderated
Related Questions
Suppose an economy has four sectors, Agriculture (A), Energy (E), Manufacturing (M), and Transportation (T). Sector A sells 10% of its output to E and 25% to M and retains the rest

Problem 1: i) It has often been argued that a monopoly has both costs and benefits. Discuss. ii) Explain, using diagram the short and long equilibrium positions of a monopo

Marginal Utility and Indifference Curve - If the consumption of a product moves along an indifference curve, additional utility derived from the increase in consumption of sing

Curvature of the Iso-quant: An iso-qunat is convex to the origin. This is so because as more and more units labour are employed, the producer would prefer to give up less and

Explain how Keynesian economics views the role of markets and government intervention in fighting business cycles. Keynesian economics believes markets frequently fail and gov

THEORY OF INTER-TEMPORAL CONSUMPTION: In the previous two units, we have been concerned with choices among contemporaneous commodities. An important class of choices made by c


Uses of Balance of payments account: It removes the uncertainty associated with the flexible exchange rate regime and brings stability. It also indirectly imposes some anti inf

Short run production period and long run production period: The short run is a period of production during which some factors of production are fixed and some too are variable

Strategic Planning for Enhancing Exports: Strategic Planning for Enhancing Exports need to be undertaken at the national level. It is necessary  to undertake a separate and