Contract law problems, Business Law and Ethics

Case Study

Cathy's septic tank at her house was old and it suddenly stopped  working.  On 9 June 2008 she called Dave, the owner of Septix Pty Ltd (-Septix?), to urgently give her a quote on installing a new one of the same type.  Dave promised to post her a quote in the mail that afternoon which he did.  

Cathy received the quote in her mailbox on 10 June 2008 which said: -

"Enclosed is a quotation for the replacement of your septic tank, including equipment, parts and installation, at 41 Downing Street, Jockville, NSW for the amount of $8,000.  If the quotation is acceptable and you wish to proceed, please sign the enclosed terms and conditions of sale document and mail it back to us with a cheque for a 20% deposit within 7 days from the date of this quotation".

 Cathy was desperate to have her septic tank replaced as soon as possible so she decided to accept Dave's quote by signing the forms and writing a cheque for a 20% deposit and putting them both in the reply paid envelope provided by Septix.  Cathy then dropped the letter in the post office mail box that afternoon.  

On the morning of 11 June 2008, before Dave's mail was delivered, Dave realised that the quote should have said $10,000 but his secretary had mistakenly typed the quote as $8,000.  Dave telephoned Cathy to tell her this but Cathy replied that she had already accepted the quote for $8,000 and that she had posted the acceptance and the cheque back to him the day before.  Dave argued that since he had not yet received the acceptance that it was not valid.  

Using the law of contract, advise Cathy and Septix whether there was a binding contract between them.  In your answer explain the basis for your answer and discuss what rights each party has under the contract, if any.

Posted Date: 2/21/2013 5:23:26 AM | Location : United States







Related Discussions:- Contract law problems, Assignment Help, Ask Question on Contract law problems, Get Answer, Expert's Help, Contract law problems Discussions

Write discussion on Contract law problems
Your posts are moderated
Related Questions
Explain the mode of acquisition - occupation The mode of acquisition is occupation. It is a means by which a State can acquire territory which belongs to no other entity. The o

Most executions take place using a lethal injection.  The company that manufactures the drug that is most used has now announced that it is choosing to no longer produce that drug.

QUESTION 1 (a) Why is it that businesses are increasingly exposed to scrutiny and criticisms? (b) Discuss four strategies which can be adopted to respond to these criticisms

Analyze the differences between a proposal and an invitation to treat and discuss the rules to determine the point of time on which an agreement is reached. Using the latest Malays

"Detriment" as consideration  An example of a 'detriment' that will legally suffice like the consideration for a promise is provided with the case of Carlill v. Carbolic Smoke

Promotion: A company comes into existence from the moment of its registration by the registrar of companies. However, the  registration is preceded by what is called "promotio

DISCLAIMER OF ASSETS: The liquidator has a statutory right of disclaimer of assets: s.135.  The rules are: (a)     he must obtain leave of the court; (b)     the right o

Committal Stage: In this such order 103 offers that a Bill having been read a second moment shall stand committed to a committee of the Whole House, unless the House commits t

Division of company's Powers: Article 80 of Table A states: "The business of the company shall be managed by the directors one who may... exercise all the such powers of th

QUESTION 1 Discuss the legislative framework governing employment law in Mauritius. QUESTION 2 Pam works as a technician at Continent Ltd. During the few past weeks, Pa