Comparison a competing firm-analysts earnings estimates, Finance Basics

Comparison to a Competing Firm

In Mergent Horizon, return to the competitor page, but now enter the list of competitors "As Defined by the Company."  From this list select a firm that appears to be one of your firm's closest competitors (this can be the same or different than the firm in question 1-5 above).  Return to the Edgar Online I-Metrix financial ratios page, and enter this firm's ticker symbol in the "Compare to" box.  In this case, use the "trailing 12 months" option.  Use this firm for comparison purposes in this and the following questions that involve comparisons to a competitor.

1.  What is the name of the competitor? : Dish Network

a.  Which exchange is its stock traded on? 

b.  What is the ticker symbol of this firm's stock?

c.   In which ways is this competitor firm a good match or basis of comparison for your firm? 

It could be good match because the blockbuster used to be its major competitor and Dish network acquired the blockbuster last year.

d.    In which ways is it not a good match?

2.  Report this summary data on leverage for your firm and its competitor.


Your Firm

The Competitor Firm







Interest Expense/Long term Debt



Times Interest Earned (TIE)



Interest coverage



1. Does it appear to you that your firm has an appropriate degree of leverage, or is over- or under-leveraged?  Why? 

2. What changes in leverage, if any, do you think would be appropriate for your firm to reduce its WACC?

3. Comparison of the firms' liquidity and operations:  First, report this summary data on liquidity and activity for the two firms:


Your Firm

The Competitor Firm


Current Ratio



Quick Ratio







Average collection period (ACP)



Inventory Days



Operating Cycle



Cash Conversion Cycle






Total Asset Turnover



Capital Expenditure/Sales






  • Does your firm's liquidity compare favorably or unfavorably to those of the competitor?  What areas of improvement, if any, are needed by your firm?
  • How does your firm's operations, as measured by the activity ratios, compare?  What areas of improvement, if any, are needed by your firm?

4.Analysts' earnings estimates. On Mergent Horizon, find and report the following these data for your firm.  If there are any missing estimates, indicate "na."

Comparison of Earnings Forecasts


Your Firm

The Competitor

Earnings per share for the firm's current fiscal year

Ending date of the current fiscal year



Mean estimate of earnings per share for this year



Low estimate



High estimate



Number of analysts



EPS for the firm's next fiscal year

Ending date of the next fiscal year



Mean estimate of earnings per share for this year



Low estimate



High estimate



Number of analysts



Long term growth rates

Mean estimate for the next 5 years



Low estimate



High estimate



Number of analysts



  1. Consider the ranges of earnings estimates in these three cases relative to the mean estimates.  What does this suggest about the reliability and certainty of these estimates?
  2. Which of these two firms has the better outlook based on these projections?  Why?
  3. Do these forecasts look reasonable to you?  Too optimistic or pessimistic?  Why?
Posted Date: 3/7/2013 2:04:12 AM | Location : United States

Related Discussions:- Comparison a competing firm-analysts earnings estimates, Assignment Help, Ask Question on Comparison a competing firm-analysts earnings estimates, Get Answer, Expert's Help, Comparison a competing firm-analysts earnings estimates Discussions

Write discussion on Comparison a competing firm-analysts earnings estimates
Your posts are moderated
Related Questions
Dividend Policies and Decisions Dividend policy determines the division of earnings among payments to stock holder's ad re-investment in the firm.  Hence now it looks at the f

A paper mill produces two grades of paper viz., X and Y. Because of raw material restrictions, it cannot produce more than 400 tons of grade X paper and 300 tons of grade Y paper i

1. Find the price of the following bonds. They are all risk-free, and the risk-free rate is 10%. (a) A fifteen-year zero coupon bond with face value $1,000. (b) A three year

Stock Repurchase The company can buy back also several of its outstanding shares instead of paying cash dividends. This is identified as stock repurchase and or bought back or

Please list five common mistakes in capital budgeting that could either overstate or understate the value of a project.Bonus: explain the relationship between the errors above and

Example of Capital Asset Pricing Model KK Ltd is an all equity firm whose Beta factor is 1.2, the interest rate on T. bills is currently at 8.5% and the market rate of return

Commercial Banks - Banking Institutions These are financial institutions such accept deposits of money from the universal public, safeguard the deposits and create them availa

Question: A deferred annuity policy is sold to a life aged 45 with the following benefits: • Basic payments start at $30,000 from age 65, increasing by $2,000 each year; •

Define the term Placement - Methods of Floating New Issues Under this method, issue houses or brokers purchase the securities outright with the intention of placing them wi

Advantages of Development Financial Institutions Advantages or Functions or can say Case for Development Financial Institutions 1. They grant venture capital 2. They gra