case, Business Law and Ethics

Corgi was the breeder of prize-winning pedigree dogs that often sold for very high prices. Reynolds, a wealthy businessman who had recently retired, decided to purchase one of these dogs. His intention was to enter the animal in the various dog shows that were held from time to time across the country.

Reynolds knew very little about dogs. He explained to Corgi that he wished to purchase a young dog that was already a prize-winning specimen of the breed. Corgi took Reynolds to a fenced run where several young dogs were caged. He pointed to one dog that he said, in his opinion, had the greatest potential, and that it had already won a prize at a local dog show. Corgi pointed to a red ribbon pinned to the opposite wall of the kennel building and explained that it was a first-prize ribbon that the dog had won. Reynolds did not bother to examine the ribbon.

Reynolds purchased the dog for $1,000 and took it home. His neighbour later saw the dog in Reynolds'''' backyard. He instantly recognized it as the dog that had recently won the first-prize ribbon in the children''''s pet show at the neighbourhood park. When he told Reynolds where he had last seen the dog, Reynolds telephoned Corgi immediately and demanded his money back.

Corgi refused to return Reynolds'''' money or take back the dog, and Reynolds threatened to take legal proceedings against him. Reynolds was unable to do so immediately, however, as he was called out of town on a family matter the next day. He was obliged to leave the dog with his neighbour during his absence. Reynolds advised the neighbour to take care of the animal as if it were his own.

Reynolds was out of town for several weeks. During that time, his neighbour entered the dog in a dog show sponsored by a kennel club. The dog won first prize in its class for its breed. On Reynolds'''' return, the neighbour advised him of his success. The two men decided to enter the dog in another dog show that was scheduled to be held in a nearby city.

At this second show, the dog placed only third in its class, and Reynolds was disappointed. He returned home and immediately took legal action against Corgi.

Discuss the basis of Reynolds'''' claim and the defences (if any) of Corgi. Render, with reasons, a decision.
Posted Date: 10/16/2016 8:06:39 PM | Location :







Related Discussions:- case, Assignment Help, Ask Question on case, Get Answer, Expert's Help, case Discussions

Write discussion on case
Your posts are moderated
Related Questions
Determine the areas of open method of coordination The EU has indicated its intention to employ the OMC, but so far there is little evidence of progress. These areas include E

Capacity to Become a Partner - Partnership Law Competence to enter in partnership is co-extensive about capacity to contract.  Actually an infant may enter in a contract eithe

In relation to the scenario below, discuss relevant ethical and legal issues that relate to decision making regarding treatment vs non-treatment.   Please note , you are

Question : In July 2007 Amin sent a brochure of a hotel he was running and managing to Sam, a travel agent and included the following statement: "The hotel provides a range of

Rules for Loan creditors: Loan creditors and landlords are subject to special rules in certain circumstances: (a) if a person (usually a bank) lends money to the company to e

The phrase called information overload may be a bit of a problem because it used so often, but the fact remain that managers & support staff are merged in information of all kinds.

Raising Of Capital: In commercial parlance, the word 'capital' is generally used to denote the amount by which the assets of a business exceed its liabilities. Conversely, in

Disadvantage of a scheme of arrangement: The disadvantage of a scheme of arrangement is that it requires the preparation of elaborate documents and the observance of a strict

Group Accounts' form: S.151(1) provides that the group accounts laid before a holding company shall be consolidated accounts comprising- (a)   like with a consolidated bala

What are the international policies  -  Policy process In international policy, (politics) each state is part of a system and each is the guardian of its own security and indep