Analyse ethical and legal issues , Business Law and Ethics

Fran is a 68 year old female patient with a history of diabetes.  Fran separated from her husband, Derek, 3 years ago (although they are not divorced) and over the past few years they have seen each other rarely. Fran now lives in the downstairs self-contained 'granny flat' of her daughter, June. Her son, Marcus, lives a 1 hour drive away. They talk on the telephone at least once a week and Marcus often visits his sister and Mum.

Although Fran has suffered from peripheral vascular disease over a number of years, she has continued to maintain an independent lifestyle and regularly goes out with friends and enjoys weekly games of bowls at her local club.

Fran was recently admitted to hospital with arterial ulcers and sepsis. Due to septic shock, she was intubated and sent to the intensive care unit. Nursing staff on her treating team have been the main point of contact for the family during their daily visits. Fran is currently unconscious and is not expected to regain consciousness until the sepsis resolves.  The treating team advise Fran's family that due to the advanced stage of her condition, a decision needs to be made quickly about which treatment option should be chosen for Fran.  The treating team advises that the options are:

1)  Fran can have her leg amputated. This is seen to be the safest option as it minimises the risks of sepsis.  However, in order to regain mobility and independence a significant period of recovery and rehabilitation would be necessary.

2)  The treating team can attempt to revascularise her leg. This will potentially save the limb, but raises the risk of Fran's condition deteriorating if the sepsis does not resolve.

Marcus says that he wants what is best for his Mum and that means the safest option. He does not want his Mum to suffer any further complications and believes that the amputation should be carried out immediately.  Being the eldest child, Marcus feels that he should be the one who makes decisions for his Mum. Fran's husband, Derek, also agrees with Marcus.

However, June believes that what has been most important to Fran in the past few years has been her ability to live independently, including her weekly social interaction at the bowls club. June says that although nothing was ever put into writing her Mum often said that, if necessary, she wanted June to make decisions for her so that she is not, 'stuck in bed like those poor people in a nursing home who have no life'. Therefore, June wants the treating team to try revascularising Fran's leg.

Analyse the relevant ethical and legal issues in relation to this scenario by applying the ethical decision-making framework provided in this unit.

Posted Date: 2/25/2013 12:06:28 AM | Location : United States







Related Discussions:- Analyse ethical and legal issues , Assignment Help, Ask Question on Analyse ethical and legal issues , Get Answer, Expert's Help, Analyse ethical and legal issues Discussions

Write discussion on Analyse ethical and legal issues
Your posts are moderated
Related Questions
Hi Dear, Could you please do my online quiz in Business Law. This is a 10 question quiz, made up of a combination of multiple choice and true/false type questions. You have 12 min

Question 1: (a) In the Mauritian Legal System, there is a hierarchy of courts. Describe the various courts. (b) State and critically examine the features of the 5 main sour

QUESTION 1 Arbitration has proved itself to be a valuable scheme in alternative dispute resolution of conflicts. Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of Arbitration as a su

Bills: Further an Act of Parliament begins as a Bill that is the draft of law that Parliament intends to make.  In section 46(1) of the constitution states like "the legislati

Jurisdiction - High Court Whether under Section 60 of the constitution states in which the High Court shall have 'unlimited original jurisdiction in civil and the criminal mat

District Magistrate's Court - Civil Jurisdiction Conversely the civil jurisdiction of the district magistrate's courts in claims not below customary law was changed through St

Unauthorized Contracts: It may sometimes happen that a company's agent, while entering into a contract on behalf of the company, exceeds his powers under the articles of assoc

Brokerage: Brokerage is a payment made by a company to a broker, or brokers, in consideration for "placing" the company's shares. It differs from underwriting commission in th

Misfeasance by the auditors: However it is not sufficient to describe that the frauds must have been detected whether the entries in the books had been put mutually in a way w

1. How does the Melian dialogue represent key concepts such as self-interest, the balance of power, alliance, capabilities, empires and justice? Athenian leaders arrive on the is