Why the renegotiated contract should be enforced

Assignment Help Business Economics
Reference no: EM131087045

Homework 3 - Contract Law

Question 1. Renegotiating Contracts (from final exam, fall 2007)

I run a retail store that hires extra cashiers for the holiday rush. Each year, we sign six-week contracts with short-term employees, under which we train them for two weeks before Thanksgiving and then employ them as cashiers for all of December at a pre-agreed wage.

Consider the following two scenarios:

- You agree to the contract. The day after Thanksgiving, I've already invested time and money in training you, and don't have time to train a replacement; you suddenly realize you're in a strong bargaining position, and threaten to quit unless I raise your salary. Feeling I have no choice, I rewrite the contract to pay you more.

- You agree to the contract. Watching you interact with customers and other employees during training, I realize you're better suited to be a store manager than a cashier. The work is harder - you wouldn't agree to do it for the same wage - but your additional value to me as a manager is much greater than the additional cost (effort) to you. We rewrite the contract to make you a manager and pay you more.

(a) Give an economic argument why the renegotiated contract should be enforced in the second scenario, while the original contract should be enforced in the first.

(b) Would either renegotiated contract be enforced under the Bargain Theory of contracts?

Question 2. You Should Really Read the Contract

In Allied Van Lines v. Bratton (Florida Supreme Court, 1977), the court writes,

"No party to a written contract in this state can defend against its enforcement on the sole ground that he signed it without reading it."

What would be the impact if one could always get out of a contract by claiming you had failed to read it? What exceptions to this rule seem necessary for efficiency?

Question 3. "Zero-Sided Contracts"

(from midterm, fall 2007)

David Friedman's book, "Law's Order" (p. 160), discusses the following situation:

"A physician comes upon an auto accident, stops, and treats an unconscious and badly bleeding victim. A week later the victim receives a bill for services rendered. Must he pay it?

Under current U.S. law the answer is yes."

Consider the following alternatives:

(i) The victim need not pay anything
(ii) The victim must pay only the value of whatever materials were used up in treating him (bandages, etc.)
(iii) The victim must pay the going market rate for comparable medical services
(iv) The victim must pay whatever the doctor demands

Which of these do you expect to lead to the most efficient outcomes? Why?

Question 4. Mutual versus Unilateral Mistakes

In 1887, the Michigan Supreme Court decided the case Sherwood v. Walker. The defendant, Hiram Walker (yes, that Hiram Walker), contracted to sell a cow to the plaintiff, Sherwood, for $80. A barren cow is worth its weight in beef, around $80; a fertile cow is worth much more (at least $750) as a breeder and milk-producer.

Before Walker delivered the cow, he discovered she was pregnant, and refused to hand her over. Sherwood sued, asking that the contract be honored.

The court ruled for Walker, saying, "A barren cow is substantially a different creature than a breeding one"; as long as both Walker and Sherwood both believed the cow was barren, there was a mutual mistake about the object being sold, and the contract was void.

The dissenting opinion, however, thought Sherwood believed the cow might be able to breed, in which case there was simply a disagreement over what the cow was worth, and Sherwood shouldn't be penalized for being right.

In general, mutual mistake (both sides being mistaken about the true value of an object) is grounds for voiding a contract, but unilateral mistake (one of us being mistaken) is not.

(a) Consider a contract to sell an old piece of furniture which looks worthless, but turns out to be a valuable antique. Explain how the principle of "uniting knowledge and control" supports this rule.

(b) Consider a contract to buy farmland that may or may not have oil underground. Give another argument against voiding a contract due to "unilateral mistake".

(c) Do the same arguments hold with a painting that appeared to be valuable, but turned out to be a worthless forgery?

(d) From Thomas Miceli, "The Economic Approach to Law (Second Edition)" Stanford University Press, 2009, p. 106:

Consider a contract for the sale of a parcel of land from seller S to buyer B at a price of $15,000. After the sale is complete, the local government announces plans to build a highway near the property, which raises its value to $100,000. S sues to have the contract invalidated on the grounds of mistake. Suppose it is learned at trial that the land would only have been worth $5,000 if the highway had not been approved. What does this information tell you about S's claim that the mistake was mutual?

Reference no: EM131087045

Questions Cloud

Define what consider to be your strengths as communicator : Discuss what you consider to be some important areas for improvement in your communication. Explain how different your personal perceptions of your strengths and weaknesses are compared to the perceptions others have of you.
Different types of forecasts : Identify the different types of forecasts that can be developed for use by a company. Cite examples of how a company might use a particular forecast method and explain why that type of forecast was best suited for that situation.
Round to two decimal places when necessary : Assume that 20% of students at a university wear contact lenses. We randomly pick 200 students. Would it be unusual to obtain a sample proportion of 22%? Answer by calculating the appropriate z-score. Round to two decimal places when necessary.
What is an intranet : (a) What is an Intranet? (b) State five (5) benefits that a company derives from an Intranet. (c) i. What is Electronic Commerce (e-Commerce)?
Why the renegotiated contract should be enforced : Econ 522 - Economics of Law - Contract Law - Consider a contract to sell an old piece of furniture which looks worthless, but turns out to be a valuable antique. Explain how the principle of "uniting knowledge and control" supports this rule.
What is the purpose of relay mr : What is the purpose of relay MR?
Post implementation audit : (a) In the context of Project Management, what is a milestone „Slip Chart?? (b) When a project has slipped behind schedule, a number of options are open to the ProjectManager.List any five (5) of the options.
Dimensions of national culture : 1. Discuss the five value dimensions of national culture described by Hofstede. Give examples of how these dimensions relate to the workplace. include one limitation of this model.
Analysis of the amount of interest paid monthly : An analysis of the amount of interest paid monthly by a bank's Visa cardholders reveals that the amount is normally distributed with a mean of $27 and a standard deviation of $6

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Business Economics Questions & Answers

  Verify that the project is economically attractive

Consider the following investment project with a useful life of 8 years. The marketing department estimates that 10,000 units of the proposed product can be sold per year. Verify that the project is economically attractive (before-tax) at a 12% MARR ..

  Expectations regarding level of customer service received

How are customer expectations today different from customer expectations of say 10-15 years ago? What are some reasons that contribute to that change's expectations regarding the level of customer service received?

  Private practice needs van to carry crew and equipment

A construction manager just starting in private practice needs a van to carry crew and equipment. She can lease a used van for $3581 per year, paid at the beginning of each year, in which case maintenance is provide. What is the most she should pay f..

  About buying a term life insurance policy

Liam O'Kelly is 20 years old and is thinking about buying a term life insurance policy with his wife as the beneficiary. The quoted annual premium for Liam is $8.44 per thousand dollars of insurance coverage. Because Lia, wants a $110,000 policy (whi..

  What monthly payment should be made

A total of $50,000 is borrowed and repaid with 60 monthly payments, with the first payment occurring one month after receipt of the $50,000. The stated interest rate is 6% compounded monthly. What monthly payment should be made?

  Elucidate the consumer surplus at the equilibrium price

Supply is the world supply. Elucidate the consumer surplus at the equilibrium price. What is the producer surplus.

  Explain how would each of these traps impact the production

Explain how would each of these traps impact the production possibilities frontier.

  Is this higher or lower than the equilibrium interest rate

Describe where the liquidity-demand/money supply equilibrium appears on the graph. Suppose in this period the interest rate is i0. Is this higher or lower than the equilibrium interest rate? Will next period’s interest rate be higher or lower than th..

  Resources market and the product market

Distinguish between the resources market and the product market in the circular flow model.

  Contribute the price revolution

Discuss the social and economic effects of colonization? How did it contribute the “Price revolution”?

  56q1 based on internet research select one industrialized

56.q1. based on internet research select one industrialized country and determine that countrys top 5 exported and

  Anticipated rate of inflation rises

Suppose that the nominal rate of interest is holding steady at 8 percent even as the anticipated rate of inflation rises.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd