Why is this an ethical dilemma

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM131238986

Case . Cultural Values and Competent

Mental Health Services to Minors

Irina, a 13-year-old girl of Arabic cultural heritage living in Boston, Massachusetts, was brought by her parents to a hospital emergency room after an assault by a stranger. Based on her injuries, the hospital staff suspected that the attacker had also sexually assaulted the girl, but she and her parents refused medical evaluations for rape. The family received a referral to see Janet Matthews, a clinical psychologist specializing in adolescent trauma. During their initial meeting with Dr. Matthews, the parents asked the psychologist not to discuss any sexual aspects of the assault with their daughter but to treat the psychological trauma from the assault in general.

They told the psychologist that admitting a rape had taken place would cast a stigma on their daughter and make her ineligible to be married to men in their closely knit ethnic community. When asked in private, the girl also requested that sexual issues not be discussed for the same reason.

Ethical Dilemma

Dr. Matthews does not know if she should agree to the parents' and child's request.

Case Study Two Worksheet

Respond to the following questions in 1,250 to 1,500 words.

1. Why is this an ethical dilemma? Which APA Ethical Principles help frame the nature of the dilemma?

2. How might Irina's age and parents' involvement in the referral affect how Dr. Matthews can resolve the dilemma? How might the state law on treatment of minors and HIPAA rule on access of guardians to a minor's health care record influence Dr. Matthews' decision?

3. How are APA Ethical Standards 2.01a b, and c; 2.04; 3.04; 3.06; 4.01; 4.02; and 10.10a relevant to this case? Which other standards might apply?

4. What are Dr. Matthews' ethical alternatives for resolving this dilemma? Which alternative best reflects the Ethics Code aspirational principle and enforceable standard, as well as legal standards and Dr. Matthews' obligations to stakeholders?

5. What steps should Dr. Matthews take to ethically implement her decision and monitor its effects?

Reference no: EM131238986

What are the areas of stress you may need to address

The educational process can be stressful. When you consider your future career path and how you hope to attain it via college, what are the areas of stress you may need to a

Write on thesis statement for the individual versus society

Who can complete a complete paragraph based on the thesis statement for ‘the individual versus society'? You'll select at least one literary work such as "The Lottery" by Shir

What are the six stages of evidence handling

In a 3 page report, complete the following: What are different crimes that are committed on a computer or with a computer? What are the 6 stages of evidence handling

Examples of environmental laws and policies

Is it possible to have effective environmental laws? What are some examples of environmental laws and policies around the world? Here comes economics again, how does the cost-

Communicate we disclose information

When we communicate we disclose information about ourselves to the people we communicate with.  Discuss how we disclose information and how we disclose the proper amount in a

Morbidity and screening procedures

Consider how understanding the course of disease can be employed to better measure and interpret morbidity. Give specific examples to support your response.

How significant were religious motivations in early travel

How significant were religious motivations in early travel? Do these still exist? If so, list examples. Why has air travel become the primary mode for middle- and long-distanc

Analysing city livability-baltimore

Choose a city to research, like Baltimore. Evaluate how "livable" your city is. Come up with at least five tasks to determine livability.


Write a Review

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd