Who bears the loss for a shipment of missing watches

Assignment Help Business Management
Reference no: EM131155385

Who Bears the Loss for a Shipment of Missing Watches?

On March 4, Pedro Pestana, a resident of Chetumal, Mexico, entered into a contract in which he agreed to purchase from the Karinol Corporation, a company based in Miami, Florida, 64 watches for $6,006.An employee of Karinol Corporation wrote the contract in Spanish, and at the bottom of the agreement was a notation that said, "Please send the merchandise in cardboard boxes duly strapped with metal bands via air parcel post to Chetumal. Documents to Banco de Commercio De Quintano Roo S.A." The contract contained no provisions for allocating the risk of loss on the goods sold while they were in transit; it also did not include any specific shipping terms (such as F.O.B., F.A.S., C.I.F, or others). Pestana paid Karinol a 25 percent deposit on the watches prior to their shipment.

On April 11, a Karinol employee took the watches, which were packaged in two cardboard cartons, to the freight forwarding company that Karinol typically used to make international shipments, American International Freight Forwarders. Karinol also purchased insurance on the watches from the Fidelity & Casualty Company of New York. An employee of American International Freight Forwarders put metal straps on the two cartons of watches and delivered the packages to TACA International Airlines for shipment to Belize City, Belize, where Bernard Smith, an agent for Pestana, was to pick them up and take them to Pestana in Chetumal.

On April 15, the packages arrived in Belize City, TACA INternational Airlines placed them in storage in a customs warehouse and notified Smith that the packages were available for pickup. On May 2, Smith picked up the packages, which were still bound by the metal straps specified in the original contract, but when he opened them for customs officials to inspect, the watches were missing. Pestana contacted Karinol Corporation about the missing watches, but a manager at Karinol told Pestana that Karinol had no liability for the lost watches and that Pestana must bear the loss and requested payment of the remaining $4,504 balance due. Pestana filed a lawsuit against Karinol Corporation, claiming that the watches were lost or stolen while the packages were in Karinol's care. He also cited the notation at the bottom of the contract that required Karinol to ship the watches "to Chetumal," which Karinol failed to do. Therefore, Pestana claimed, Karinol Corporation should bear the loss of the watches.

Directions: Read "Entrepreneurship in Action: Who Bears the Loss for a Shipment of Missing Watches," in Chapter 19 on page 663. Answer the following questions:

? What mistakes did Karinol Corporation and Pedro Pestana make when they created the contract for the sale of the watches?

? In the absence of an agreement on risk of loss and specific shipping terms in the parties' contract, what kind of contract will the court rule this is?

? Who will prevail in this case?

? What could the losing party have done to protect against the loss or theft of the watches?

Write a 1-2 page paper detailing the above questions, and be sure to cite your references.

Reference no: EM131155385

Questions Cloud

Canadian residents holding canadian dollardenominated bonds : what would this mean for the exposure of-  Canadian residents holding Canadian dollar-denominated bonds?- US residents holding Canadian-dollar bonds?
Prepare a revised analytical essay about poetry : Prepare a Revised Analytical Essay about Poetry. Review any feedback that you got about the introduction. Decide whether to revise the introduction based on that feedback from your instructor.
What you were most surprised about regarding : Listen to a song from a genre of music that you are not familiar with (Country, Classical, Rap, Pop, R&B, etc.) and share what you were most surprised about regarding this genre
Value that technology offers organizations : In a paper, evaluate the value that technology offers organizations and to customers. Are technologies enablers of innovation? Next, analyze innovation. How is innovation developed in response to customer needs? What is the value of innovation for ..
Who bears the loss for a shipment of missing watches : On March 4, Pedro Pestana, a resident of Chetumal, Mexico, entered into a contract in which he agreed to purchase from the Karinol Corporation, a company based in Miami, Florida, 64 watches for $6,006.An employee of Karinol Corporation wrote the c..
For which kind of company constant growth model work best : If you were analyzing the consumer goods industry, for which kind of company in the industry would the constant growth model work best?
Describe and explain scenes that apply to the social theme : Aside from verbal language, identify all observed body language, facial expressions, gestures, posture stances, modes of dress, nonverbal cues, symbols, and any other means by which inequalities are displayed.
Describe the typical design of a college course : Describe the typical design of a college course and the outcomes that result for students in these courses. In addition, describe a situation in which you found yourself falling into this style of learning.
Approach of archie carroll-approach of milton friedman : In a page, explain the difference between the approach of Archie Carroll and the approach of Milton Friedman to the responsibilities of business.

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Business Management Questions & Answers

  Explain customer centricity impact the areas of finance

How does customer centricity impact the areas of finance, human resources, information technology, marketing, research and development, operations, and sales?

  Develop a action research project proposal on homelessness

Develop a action research project proposal on homelessness. The proposal should be professional and be written for presentation to those who will be responsible for reviewing and/or approving your proposal

  The voyages of zheng he reveal a powerful

The voyages of Zheng He reveal a powerful, accomplished and restored Confucian state and civilization in China that was at least equal to

  Explain a wbs created for a project you have worked on

Explain a WBS created for a project you have worked on. Was a WBS created for a project you have worked on? If so, did the team refer to the WBS while sequencing work and creating a risk plan

  Identify multiple components of culture

When studying the effect of maternal alcohol use and disruptive behavior in children, maternal alcohol use is likely

  Formulate problem as a linear program

Formulate problem as a linear program - the available supplies at the factories, demands at the final destinations, and shipping costs

  Explain kohlberg-s stages of moral development

Analyze your own life and try to set-up as honestly and accurately as possible where values have come from. Where might you fit in Kohlberg's Stages of Moral Development?

  Show the dimensions of cultural differences

Which of these differences has the largest effect on employee behavior and how can you develop training that motivates learning and incorporates the different learning styles of the trainees

  Servant leadership theories and philosophies and capacities

Explain one attribute or capacity of servant leadership and explain how and where you might apply this principle at work or in a community setting you are familiar with.

  Who would you invite to a meeting to discuss your

who would you invite to a meeting to discuss your organizations global expansion objectives?why would you invite each

  Develop an individual action plan

Using the strategic outcomes (initiatives) from the first question develop an individual action plan for each. The Action plan should address the following:

  Determining the key elements of leadership

Determine the key elements of leadership you would need to be successful in your business venture. Explain your rationale.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd