What type of organizational culture inhibit whistle blowing

Assignment Help Management Information Sys
Reference no: EM131081221

"Around here, we keep half the people ignorant so they aren't prejudiced, and half the people prejudiced so they aren't ignorant."

Dr. Jay Shulman, c.1980

First, consider the following case study background:

Because people don't like to be the bearer of bad news, and are sometimes afraid that their management may "kill the messenger", employees are often very reluctant to bring unwelcome but critically important project status information to their management. (This is sometimes known as the "mum effect.") Therefore, it is common that important project status information does not make it to the level of management that can take corrective action to do something about it. In fact, it is typical that the farther up the hierarchy a manager is, the less information he or she will have about the project. Unfortunately, this sometimes means that those who have the authority to change things, are the very people who do not know the necessity of the change and/or who do not have sufficient information to enable an appropriate change.

Whistle blowing (see below) is an extreme case of bearing the bad news up the hierarchy. Sadly, whistle blowing can be dangerous to one's own career. Unfortunately, whistle blowing in some organizations is considered illegitimate behavior bordering on insubordination. Even when people blow the whistle, management can ignore it (sometimes known as the "deaf effect"), essentially saying "don't give me bad news that I don't want to hear."

All this is counterproductive to projects, whose success depends on sound decisions and timely corrections of deviance from plan. For instance, issues that are not elevated to the proper decision-maker before they mature into full-blown problems, become a risk to the success of the entire project. If the decision-maker is kept in the dark, or refuses to make a decision, or punishes the bearer of bad news, then he or she will no longer be in a position to take timely corrective action to keep the project on track to success.

Then consider these informal definitions so that we know we're talking about the same thing:

Whistle blowing is reporting someone (usually your own management) for doing something illegal or unethical. (Like intelligent disobedience from the questions on the Project Scope Module, we are well advised to pick our battles wisely. Even the Federal whistle blowing office admits that whistleblowers generally are retaliated against, even though that is illegal.)

Recall that in this context, intelligent disobedience, like civil disobedience, is refusing to go along with something that is unethical (whether it's legal or not), while fully realizing that we may be punished or penalized for disobeying, and being willing to take the penalty for the "greater cause". As Harry Truman said, "if you can't take the heat, stay out of the kitchen." The "intelligent" part comes from not being belligerent and especially from picking our battles wisely.

Insubordination, on the other hand, is probably less-than-intelligent, since it seems to usually be belligerent, not pick its battles wisely, and not be for a greater cause such as ethics. It usually results in management taking career-threatening actions against the employee.
Finally, there's just garden variety differences of opinion. While it should be obvious that that should always be encouraged -- two heads are better than one, after all -- nevertheless, in some organizations, it actually isn't!
Now answer the following questions:

a) What type of organizational culture might inhibit whistle blowing? Why?

b) What should a project manager do to encourage his project team's willingness to report project problems?

c) How can a project manager effectively report project problems to the sponsor, stakeholders, and senior management? What techniques might the PM use?

If you have not worked for an organization that had internal auditors, Inspectors General (IGs), or other internal inspectors then skip to Part E, below. If you have worked for such an organization, then answer Part D:

d) If you have worked for an organization that had internal auditors, IGs, or inspectors, were they effective? Were they welcome? What, in your experience, was done well and what was done poorly with such internal auditors and inspectors?

e) If you have not worked for an organization that had internal auditors, inspectors, or IGs, do you think it would be beneficial, detrimental, or problematic? Why?

2 pages, all citations must be included. APA format.

Reference no: EM131081221

Questions Cloud

Undertaking arbitrage activity : Explain how an individual would profit from financial arbitrage in this situation. Calculate the % return the individual would earn from undertaking arbitrage activity.
Risk of running out of money : Using the Time Value of Money tell me how much you need to save per year, at what percentage, for how many years to reach your retirement goal. Then tell me how you will take an income from that goal without the risk of running out of money.
State the definition for a sequence : Consider the set T = {y ∈ Q: 0 ≤ y ≤ x} where x is defined as above. Determine its maximum and minimum if they exist. Determine its supremum and infimum. Detailed proofs are not required, but you should justify your answers. State the definition f..
Interest expense associated with first payment : Start with the same numbers as in the previous example (Loan=$52,000, 25 years, k=.14, end of month payment). What is the interest expense associated with the first payment?
What type of organizational culture inhibit whistle blowing : If you have worked for an organization that had internal auditors, IGs, or inspectors, were they effective? Were they welcome? What, in your experience, was done well and what was done poorly with such internal auditors and inspectors?
Decision-making parallel individual decision-making : In what ways does group decision-making parallel individual decision-making? How does group interaction change and influence the decision-making process? If the group is part of an organization, how do organizational factors influence decision-mak..
The magnitude frequency response of a filter : 1. (TCO 1) The magnitude frequency response of a filter is usually graphed in decibels versus frequency using which of the following equations?
Compensation system influences employees : Discuss how the compensation system influences employees' motivation, productivity and satisfaction. How important is the compensation system in an employees' productivity?
What else should you do during project execution : Would taking these remedial actions depend on when you detected the changes? That is, do they require knowing in advance that there is going to be a slippage or speed-up of a task, or not?

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Management Information Sys Questions & Answers

  Explain key characteristics and deployment models of cloud

To explain the phases of transition from classic data center to virtual data center and then to the Cloud and To describe virtualization technology at compute, storage, network, desktop, and application layers of IT infrastructure

  Impact of information technology on business

Impact of information technology on business - What are your thoughts on how security and privacy will be controlled?

  What do you meant by operations management

What do you meant by operations management? Why is it important? Is a good knowledge of operations management more important in service or manufacturing industries? Explain your answer.

  Draw connections within social media and technology

draw connections within social media and technology between learning and business communication. How does the "learning" theory transfer to the networked world for business?

  What does ford mean by global gridlock

Explain the concept of connected cars. Why does Bill Ford see a need for connected cars? What does Ford mean by "global gridlock"? Brainstorm a few other ways in which an IT network could help to reduce global gridlock. Do not limit yourself to cur..

  Develop list of five to seven feature of your application

Develop a list of the top five to seven features of your application. Explain how those features pertain to your viral hook. Explain how those features will help increase wedding revenue.

  Cross-functional integrated enterprise systems

Why is there a trend toward cross-functional integrated enterprise systems in business? Why would systems that enhance a company's relationships with customers have such a high rate of failure?

  Implement and require extensive organizational change

They cannot provide value if they are implemented atop flawed processes or if firms do not know how to use these systems to measure performance improvements. Employees require training to prepare for new procedures and roles.

  The infrastructure and regulation of the internet

Topic: The infrastructure and regulation of the Internet has seen many changes over the past two decades. It will certainly see as many, if not more, in the next. We have discussed where the Internet came from, why, how it is structured

  Creating separate web sites for each country

Companies creating separate Web sites for each country in which they do business is called _____ of a Web site

  Describe the flow of materials

Describe the flow of materials to this organization, the organization's function, and the customers it serves and Compare and contrast these practices with other supply chain practices, both domestic and global.

  As the network administrator you have been given the task

as the network administrator you have been given the task of preparing a presentation for the stakeholders of a new

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd