What performance appraisal system would you develop

Assignment Help HR Management
Reference no: EM131230074

Application Case Questions

• Do you think that the experts ‘recommendations will be sufficient to get most of the administrators to fill out the rating forms properly? Why? Why not? What additional actions (if any) do you think will be necessary?

• Do you think that Vice President Winchester would be better off dropping graphic rating forms, substituting instead one of the other techniques we discussed in this chapter, such as a ranking method? Why?

• What performance appraisal system would you develop for the secretaries if you were Rob Winchester? Defend your answer.

Application Case: Appraising the Secretaries at Sweetwater U

Rob Winchester, newly appointed vice president for administrative affairs at Sweetwater State University, faced a tough problem shortly after his university career began. Three weeks after he came on board in September, Sweetwater's president, Rob's boss, told Rob that one of his first tasks was to improve the appraisal system used to evaluate secretarial and clerical performance at Sweetwater U. The main difficulty was that the performance appraisal was traditionally tied directly to salary increases given at the end of the year. Therefore, most administrators were less than accurate when they used the graphic rating forms that were the basis of the clerical staff evaluation. In fact, what usually happened was that each administrator simply rated his or her clerk or secretary as "excellent." This cleared the way for them to receive a maximum pay raise every year.

But the current university budget simply did not include enough money to fund another "maximum" annual raise for every staffer. Furthermore, Sweetwater's president felt that the custom of providing invalid feedback to each secretary on his or her year's performance was not productive, so he had asked the new vice president to revise the system. In October, Rob sent a memo to all administrators, telling them that in the future no more than half the secretaries reporting to any particular administrator could be appraised as "excellent." This move, in effect, forced each supervisor to begin ranking his or her secretaries for quality of performance. The vice president's memo met widespread resistance immediately-from administrators, who were afraid that many of their secretaries would begin leaving for more lucrative jobs, and from secretaries, who felt that the new system was unfair and reduced each secretary's chance of receiving a maximum salary increase. A handful of secretaries had begun picketing outside the president's home on the university campus. The picketing, caustic remarks by disgruntled administrators, and rumors of an impending slowdown by the secretaries (there were about 250 on campus) made Rob Winchester wonder whether he had made the right decision by setting up forced ranking. He knew, however, that there were a few performance appraisal experts in the School of Business, so he decided to set up an appointment with them to discuss the matter.

He met with them the next morning. He explained the situation as he had found it: The current appraisal system had been set up when the university first opened 10 years earlier. A committee of secretaries had developed it. Under that system, Sweetwater's administrators filled out the forms. This once-a-year appraisal (in March) had run into problems almost immediately, since it was apparent from the start that administrators varied widely in their interpretations of job standards, as well as in how conscientiously they filled out the forms and supervised their secretaries. Moreover, at the end of the first year it became obvious to everyone that each secretary's salary increase was tied directly to the March appraisal. For example, those rated "excellent" received the maximum increases, those rated "good" received smaller increases, and those given neither rating received only the standard across-the-board cost-of-living increase. Since universities in general-and Sweetwater, in particular-have paid secretaries somewhat lower salaries than those prevailing in private i ndustry, some secretaries left in a huff that first year. From that time on, most administrators simply rated all secretaries excellent in order to reduce staff turnover, thus ensuring each a maximum increase. In the process, they also avoided the hard feelings aroused by the significant performance differences otherwise highlighted by administrators.

Two Sweetwater experts agreed to consider the problem, and in 2 weeks they came back to the vice president with the following recommendations. First, the form used to rate the secretaries was grossly insufficient. It was unclear what "excellent" or "quality of work" meant, for example. In addition, they recommended that the vice president rescind his earlier memo and no longer attempt to force university administrators to arbitrarily rate at least half their secretaries as something less than excellent. The two consultants pointed out that this was unfair, since it was quite possible that any particular administrator might have staffers who were all or virtually all excellent-or conceivably, although less likely, all below standard. The experts said that the way to get all the administrators to take the appraisal process more seriously was to stop tying it to salary increases. In other words, they recommended that every administrator fill out a form for each secretary at least once a year and then use this form as the basis of a counseling session. Salary increases would have to be made on some basis other than the performance appraisal, so that administrators would no longer hesitate to fill out the rating forms honestly.

Rob thanked the two experts and went back to his office to ponder their recommendations. Some of the recommendations (such as substituting the new rating form for the old) seemed to make sense. Nevertheless, he still had serious doubts as to the efficacy of any graphic rating form, particularly compared with his original, preferred forced ranking approach. The experts' second recommendation-to stop tying the appraisals to automatic salary increases-made sense but raised at least one very practical problem: If salary increases were not to be based on performance appraisals, on what were they to be based? He began wondering whether the experts' recommendations weren't simply based on ivory tower theorizing.

Reference no: EM131230074

Questions Cloud

Company background and product description : Written report should focus on key ideas with an associated journal article for each idea and a discussion of which ideas are most important and why
Coverage of classic rock-main trends in wide scope of music : A music magazine has had steady business with the current 45 to 65 year old demographic, because of its coverage of “classic rock”, as it has aged from youth to middle aged. The magazine has also needed to continually reach out to the current youth o..
Compute the required pressure in the oil : a hydraulic cylinder must be able to exert a force of 45.5 kn. The piston diameter is 65 mm. Compute the required pressure in the oil
Computer system that has no operating system : What inconveniences can be faced by a user who is interacting with a computer system that has no operating system?
What performance appraisal system would you develop : Do you think that the experts ‘recommendations will be sufficient to get most of the administrators to fill out the rating forms properly? Why? Why not? What additional actions (if any) do you think will be necessary?
Make a list of the most important relationships : Determine the kind of support team you want to build. -  Make a list of the most important relationships in your life, right now and in the past.
Eliminate as much as possible potential estate tax liability : Eliminate or reduce as much as possible the potential estate tax liability and 2) maximize the amount of wealth to the client's heirs (typically the children and grandchildren).
Pieces of information about a user that the system : Your design should include a list of many pieces of information about a user that the system could collect. It is permissible for the system to ask an authenticated user for certain additional information, such as a favorite book, to use in subseq..
Describe how to get started using it : Explain how it can be used as a tool for effective instruction and provide at least one example of how it can be used to achieve a 21st century learning goal.

Reviews

Write a Review

 

HR Management Questions & Answers

  Explain how your recommended strategies should be employed

What additional strategies could be employed to reflect flexibility, promote sustainability, foster effective change management, and further organizational goals? Clearly explain how your recommended strategies should be employed. Defend your eval..

  Asynchronous communications method

Determine one other asynchronous (lag time) communications method that would serve as a good back-up system that is secure.

  Human resources - you have been hired by mr johnson as an

human resources - you have been hired by mr. johnson as an hr professional to work in his company comfortable shoes.you

  What are the four types of training objectives

What are the strengths and shortcomings of a decentralized approach to training managers and hourly employees and why was the turnover rate among management trainees in Dunkin' Donuts' centralized program so high?

  Advantages in relation to situation and culture at pegasus

Describe 3 models of change. Discuss their advantages and disadvantages in relation to the situation and culture at Pegasus.

  Five leader decision styles

There are five levels of subordinate participation in decision making ranging from highly autocratic (leader decides alone) to highly democratic (leader delegates to group):

  Hr policy research paper instructions

Normal 0 false false false EN-US X-NONE X-NONE MicrosoftInternetExplorer4 ..

  Types of forecasting methods

What would be some different types of capacity and the constraints that an Dry Cleaners could act on now and in the future and What are different types of forecasting methods that a Dry Cleaners uses?

  Emerging challenges that human resource practioners face

Select and discuss three current or emerging challenges that human resource practioners face in meeting the diverse needs of the contemporary workforce

  How do environmental factors influence motivation

What are some of the I-O psychology-based approaches that effective leaders use to inculcate morale and motivation in the workplace? How do environmental factors influence motivation?

  How does power move a change initiative forward and how is

how does power move a change initiative forward and how is it used to block changes?what can hr and senior leadership

  Explain what size union is best

Explain What Size Union Is Best - Globalization has increased competition in the markets for factors of production as well as in the product markets.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd