What lessons does p&gs mishap with sk-ii in china

Assignment Help Marketing Research
Reference no: EM131378051

DISCUSSION QUESTIONS

1. What lessons does P&G's mishap with SK-II in China inspire for advertisers in China?

2. Did P&G handle the SK-II case correctly? What would you recommend to P&G China for the marketing of its SK-II product line?

International Marketing Communications Professor Shintaro Okazaki

Case #1

Source: Kotabe, M., and Helsen, K. (2010), Case 13-1 and 13-2, in Global Marketing Management, 5th edition, New York: John Wiley & Sons, p. 461-462.

CASE 1: P&G CHINA-A LEGAL CLOUD OVER SK-II

SK-II is an ultra-premium skincare range that originated from Procter & Gamble's Japan division. According to P&G's product literature, the SK-II product combines the magic of nature with the advances of science. A Japanese monk visiting a sake brewery noticed that brewery workers had very soft and youthful hands. Even an elderly wrinkled man had the silky smooth hands of a young boy. A team of skincare scientists discovered the secret: a clear liquid that could be extracted during the yeast fermentation process. The liquid became known as the ‘‘Secret Key'' to beautiful skin.

De-Wrinkle Active, the latest launch in China from P&G's SK-II skincare line, attracted unwelcome publicity in early March 2005 when Lu Ping, a woman from Jiangxi province, filed a lawsuit against P&G, China's biggest advertiser, the company that distributed it, and even Carina Lau, the celebrity who endorsed SK-II in P&G's advertising. The plaintiff said she had spent Rmb. 840 (US$100) on a 25-gram bottle of SKII anti-aging De-Wrinkle Essence in the hope that ‘‘the concentrated treatment would work to help iron out 47 percent of deep lines and wrinkles after 28 consecutive days of usage,'' as the product's promotional materials had promised.

Unfortunately for Mrs. Lu, the ‘‘miracle cure'' failed to remove her wrinkles. Instead, it triggered an allergic reaction, which left the woman in pain. Lu alleged that she was misled by the brand's advertising. A local industrial watchdog claimed that P&G's statistics for SK-II's claims came from a lab experiment on 300 Japanese women and lacked authoritative proof. After a 20-day investigation into SK-II, the Nanchang Commercial and Industrial Bureau fined P&G with a penalty of Rmb. 200,000 (US$24,000) for making false advertising claims.

Initially P&G considered Lu's case as a spiteful act to draw media attention. P&G insisted that all of its cosmetic products had undergone stringent tests and were well received in Japan and the
U.S. On March 25, the firm softened its tone and admitted that its advertising had been misleading. In April, P&G paid the fine and made an apology to consumers. Lu, on the other hand, lost her case because of insufficient evidence. She said she would appeal the verdict. Sales of SK-II brand had slipped by nearly 30 percent. P&G planned to launch a new SK-II campaign in September 2005. The SK-II case underlines an emerging trend in China-consumer activism, which has become a major force in Chinese society today.

Reference no: EM131378051

Questions Cloud

How efficient would 6 bit code in asynchronous transmission : How efficient would a 6-bit code be in asynchronous transmission if it had 1 parity bit, 1 start bit, and 2 stop bits?
Read the 2012 harvard business review article : Read the 2012 Harvard Business Review article "Macroeconomic Policy and U.S. Competitiveness," by Richard H.K. Vietor and Matthew C. Weinzierl. Critically analyze and discuss the recommendations the authors offer. When is government intervention j..
Describe the importance of a current issue in health science : Describe the importance of a current issue in health science. Identify opportunities for improvement within health science. Describe how current issues in health sciences relate to health science professions
What is the transmission rate of information bits : What is the transmission rate of information bits if you use ASCII (8 bits plus 1 parity bit), a 1,000-character frame, 56 Kbps modem transmission speed, 20 control characters per frame, an error rate of 1%, and a 30-millisecond turnaround time?
What lessons does p&gs mishap with sk-ii in china : De-Wrinkle Active, the latest launch in China from P&G's SK-II skincare line, attracted unwelcome publicity in early March 2005 when Lu Ping, a woman from Jiangxi province, filed a lawsuit against P&G, China's biggest advertiser, the company that ..
Find a software vendor that sells a package : Search the Web to find a software vendor that sells a package that supports each of the following protocols: SDLC, HDLC, Ethernet, and PPP.
List the desired characteristics of each material : List the requirements for each application and list the desired characteristics of each material.
Draw three-view orthographic drawing based on isometric view : Draw a three-view orthographic drawing based on the isometric view shown below. Draw the isometric view of the object below, given the following three-view orthographic drawing.
Find out the average error rates : Investigate the network at your organization (or a service offered by an IXC) to find out the average error rates.- What is the efficiency if a 100-byte file is transmitted using Ethernet? A 10,000-byte file?

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Marketing Research Questions & Answers

  Research press coverage and the internet

Research press coverage and the Internet to collect information on the current status of the project.- What are the successes and failures to date?

  What is the difference between pushing and pulling

What is the difference between pushing and pulling using promotions to sell a product? Go into detail. Give examples for both pushing and pulling. Tell me the difference between institutional advertising and product advertising.Tell me the advanta..

  Develop guidelines reflecting organisational policy

Develop guidelines reflecting organisational policy and procedures to be used for conducting research -  develop a report describing and evaluating the research undertaken and the findings presented.

  Find a organizations that have seized sustainability

you will find a organizations that have seized sustainability opportunities in the marketplace. While each organization's goals differ, they share the common theme that they saw a sustainability-related opportunity, and are now trying to make the ..

  How do you feel remington has handled the situation

After Viewing the Remington Under Fire Video write a 2-page double spaced essay regarding the ethics of product responsibility and consumer safety. How do you feel Remington has handled the situation? What needs to be done to fix the product? What..

  Do you like your team dynamics

Watch the video titled "Mark Zuckerberg on Team Dynamics" .Then express whether or not you agree with Mark Zuckerberg's opinion on managing team dynamics. Explain whether or not you believe the team dynamics Mark Zuckerberg experienced are unique ..

  Discuss a product whose price you have seen change

Pricing is controlled by the manufacturer or producer of the product or service. The manufacturer or producer understands the competition (competitive activity), the consumer and their own company requirements.Discuss a product whose price you have..

  Marketing solution for organization

Evaluate pricing strategies and programs for setting andadapting the price of your energy-related product, service, orinitiative.

  The ford pinto case is a well known case

Would Ford's decision to forego repairing the defective design comply with these ethical guidelines? If so, why? If not, then what actions should Ford have taken to satisfy them? Explain your reasoning.

  What type of it infrastructure does your school have

What type of IT infrastructure does your school have? If it uses a client/server infrastructure how does your school's client/server network increase student productivity?

  Write a paper about the article the millionaire next door

Write a paper about the article The Millionaire Next Door and your consumer behavior textbook "Buying, Having, Being" by Solomon.

  Discuss how walmart relies upon strategic surveillance

Retail companies like Walmart are heavy users of strategic control systems. Think about how it utilizes RFID technology to track products from inventory to the market shelves. Discuss how Walmart relies upon strategic surveillance, special alert c..

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd