What kinds of species were protected and why

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM132190806

The endangered dusky gopher frog, a darkly colored, moderately sized frog with warts covering its back and dusky spots on its belly. Photo: U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service/Reuters

Amid all the hand-wringing about a polarized Supreme Court, note Tuesday's unanimous decision for regulatory sanity. The case concerned whether a frog's "critical habitat" can include land where the frog doesn't live and can't survive.

Weyerhaeuser v. U.S. Fish and Wildlife involves more than 1,500 acres in Louisiana that the government declared "critical habitat" for the dusky gopher frog, which is protected under the Endangered Species Act. Two problems: The critter hasn't been seen in those parts for about five decades, and it can't survive on the land without clearing forest canopy.

The timber company that operates on the land sued on the sensible grounds that the place can't be critical habitat if the creature would die on arrival.

The law allows Fish and Wildlife to designate certain unoccupied areas as critical habit but only if they're essential to the conservation of the species. The designation threatens development on the land and could cost the owners $34 million by the government's estimates.

The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled for the government in a decision with no limiting principle-by the circuit's logic, a desert could be critical habitat for a fish, as more than a dozen state attorneys general pointed out in an amicus brief to the Supreme Court.

The Supremes ruled for the land owners 8-0. (Justice Brett Kavanaugh wasn't seated at the time of oral argument.) Chief Justice John Roberts wrote for the Court that "according to the ordinary understanding of how adjectives work, ‘critical habitat' must also be ‘habitat.'" The case is sent back to the circuit court to consider if the land is habitat, among other questions.

The Justices also ruled that the critical habitat designation is subject to judicial review. One mystery is why the Trump Justice Department defended such an expansive interpretation of the law. Maybe the next Attorney General can take the career bureaucracy off autopilot.

The Justices could revisit the case if the Fifth Circuit muffs the Court's questions. Meantime, the dusky gopher frog would have a better chance of surviving in more places if the Endangered Species Act gave private land owners an incentive to protect wildlife rather than subjecting them to years of federal legal harassment.

Appeared in the November 28, 2018, print edition.

A. 1) Do you think this decision will hinder endangered species protections? Why or why not?

B) Now that you've read Petersen's book on the Endangered Species Act, Acting for Endangered Species: The Statutory Ark, you can address the following questions:

History of Endangered Species Protection

Prior to the ESA, what kinds of species were protected and why?

Why was the ESA enacted in 1973 and why, for such a controversial statute, was it enacted so easily?

Snail Darter Controversy

Why did the FWS refuse to list some species after the snail darter controversy?

What role did private citizens and NGOs play in the snail darter controversy?

Spotted Owl Controversy

Why was the tiny NGO "Greenworld" the initiator of the spotted owl listing issue, instead of a larger, better-established group?

What was the legal issue in Babbitt v. Sweet Home and what was the Court's holding?

Why is this book subtitled the "statutory ark"?

Reference no: EM132190806

Questions Cloud

What is the maximum saver credit : During the year, Amy also contributed $2,500 to a Roth IRA. What is the maximum saver's credit she may claim for the year
Calculate the amount of money that will have accrued : Calculate the amount of money that will have accrued if he leaves the money in the bank for 1, 5 and 15 years
By what percentage must you increase the radius : What is the area in m2? What is the area in cm2? You desire to the area to be larger by 12.0%. By what percentage must you increase the radius?
Determine the basic earnings per share for junkyard arts : Junkyard Arts, Inc., had earnings of $484,100 for the year. Determine the basic earnings per share for Junkyard Arts for the year
What kinds of species were protected and why : The timber company that operates on the land sued on the sensible grounds that the place can't be critical habitat if the creature would die on arrival.
What is the amount of tom income or loss on the sale : Tom held the shares for a little more than a year and sold them when the market price was $12. What is the amount of Tom's income or loss on the sale
When did fortress walls around cities come to an end : When did fortress walls around cities come to an end in England, as opposed to the continental countries?
What happens to gdp in a recession : What is a recession? In the United States, who determines a recession? What happens to GDP in a recession? Why?
How much must tanya include in taxable income : Tanya selected $3,360 ($280 per month) of parking, $1,840 in 401(k) contributions, and $800 of cash. How much must Tanya include in taxable income

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  Discuss the diagnosis presented in one of the videos

Discuss the diagnosis presented in one of the videos (Bonnie or Phillip). According to DSM-5 diagnostic criteria

  Identify a strategy to cluster the assessment data

Initial Discussion Post: Identify a strategy to cluster the assessment data. Describe how you used the identified strategy to cluster data for one (1) of the identified diagnostic labels

  Advise if king of ovens may be liable for breaches

7159AFE Principles of Business and Corporations Law - Advise if King of Ovens may be liable for breaches of the Australian Consumer Law 2010 (Cth)

  Responsibilities for psychologists or social workers

Ethical and legal responsibilities for psychologists or social workers. Identify the state two of the ethical or legal responsibilities. Do you believe these are valuable/ Why or why not.

  Democratic-republicans opposed henry clay''s american system

Democratic-Republicans opposed Henry Clay's American System because

  Different types of legally protected speech

Legally Protected Speech Paper Using the Electronic Reading Reserve (ERR), the Internet, textbook, or other resources, prepare a 350-700-word paper in which you define free speech. In your paper, compare and contrast at least two different types o..

  Rate of natural population increase

Population distribution, population density, physiologic density, rate of natural population increase, and doubling times are all-important geographic concepts. However, they all require a little work to understand.

  Discuss branding tactics of the products

Marketers determine which channels to use based on characteristics, positioning strategies, and branding tactics of the products

  Describe truman"s goals in his fair deal domestic policy

"Describe Truman"s goals in his Fair Deal domestic policy. Evaluate his successes and failures in accomplishing those goals.

  Describe the implementation procedures of rcs procedures

Describe the implementation procedures of RCS procedures? Highlight the pros and cons of RCS mechanism. Compare the temperature reconstruction using MBH and RCS mechanism. Explain the reason behind the correlation and variations.

  Discuss about the proprietor of a small retail grocery store

Dan was the proprietor of a small retail grocery store. One day while Dan was alone in the store, John, a stranger to Dan

  How do your personal views affect your behavior

NRS-437V: Reflect and share your own personal thoughts regarding the morals and ethical dilemmas you may face in the health care field. How do your personal views affect your behavior and your decision making?

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd