What is the president''s legal obligation to acme

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics
Reference no: EM13871100

What is the issue in this scenario with the president in term of both a legal and an ethical dimension? what is the president's legal obligation to Acme, and any other person? what is the ethical reason?

FACT PATTERN AND QUESTION Acme manufactures widgets that purify the air and are advertised to meet environmental standards. The widgets are made in Canada and sold around the world. The air purifying widget business is fiercely competitive, with major competitors in Japan, Germany, Korea, USA and soon China. Everyone is fighting to get an edge or to hold on tenaciously to whatever they already have. The president of Acme was hired under an employment contract. The contract is very lucrative for her both in terms of money and perks, i.e. private schools for her children, a chauffeur every morning and evening. The contract requires her to exercise her best efforts to make Acme as profitable as possible and a world leader in widgets. The president is under extreme pressure to maintain the market lead for Acme's widgets. Failure to keep the market lead means both her contract position is at risk and, she will also have to order lay-offs. The President knows many of the workers on the factory floor. They are married men and women highly skilled in their trades (i.e. tool & dye) supporting families, often with children in post-secondary institutions. The president has fostered a corporate climate that stresses naked achievement and initiative at any cost. The old cliché about "seek forgiveness not permission" permeates the company. As long as Acme is making money, how it happens matters not to the president. There is an old English proverb that holds: "if you build a better mousetrap, the world will beat a path to your door". This resonates with the president. She knows that if she markets a truly better widget, Acme will have plenty of world-wide customers and therefore not only keep but increase its market share. Consequently, the president orders the vice president of engineering, Mr. Dilbert, to build a new air purifying widget that will not only meet strict new environmental government standards, it will surpass them and satisfy the phased in regulatory standards for the next 7 years. However, the harsh reality is that this objective cannot be met without investing billions of dollars and years of work. Acme has neither the luxury of money nor time. Mr. Dilbert, has fully absorbed the culture of Acme. So the VP knows he has to come up with a solution-any solution. So Mr. Dilbert comes up with a bypass valve for widgets. The by-pass value will operate to trick government inspectors (and their testing equipment) into concluding the widget actually purifies the air to the standards claimed by Acme and in full satisfaction of regulatory strictures. The bypass is a simple software programming step which Dilbert views as an extremely elegant engineering solution. The President discloses the course of action to the law department. To protect herself and the engineering staff, the President seeks a legal opinion from the law department that the concept is technically legal. Moreover the President makes it clear that if the law department will not approve the course of conduct she will find new lawyers that will, and the present lawyers can vacate their desks (they will be fired). The legal department generates a memorandum saying that given ambiguities in the law, the architecture of the device and testing tolerances, Acme is not in breach of the law. Edward Snowstorm, a low level contract employee at Acme snitches / whistle-blows / discloses to the government regulators that the widget has the bypass value and triggering software. Edward Snowstorm by making this disclosure is breaching his employment confidentiality agreement with Acme that holds that Snowstorm must not disclose to anyone anything he learns on the job at Acme. The president finds out about Edward Snowstorm leaking this information to the government and fires him.

Reference no: EM13871100

Questions Cloud

Discuss most common indicators of educational performance : Discuss the criticisms of human capital theory put forward by proponents of screen- ing theory. Discuss the most common indicators of educational performance and their strengths and weaknesses.
Does the accounting guidance issued by fasb : Does the accounting guidance issued by FASB apply to proprietary funds? Explain.
Stocks returns impact the standard deviation of portfolio : Assume you have a two-stock portfolio. How does the correlation coefficient, ρ, between the two stocks’ returns impact the standard deviation of this portfolio? Explain your answer. (Hint: The two variables under discussion are ρ and σP.)
Psychological research can raise concern on ethical issues : Psychological research can raise concern on ethical issues. Most issues are focused on the use of deception with human subjects and the use of harmful or painful testing with animal subjects. Describe how experimenter design can minimize these con..
What is the president''s legal obligation to acme : What is the issue in this scenario with the president in term of both a legal and an ethical dimension? what is the president's legal obligation to Acme, and any other person? what is the ethical reason?
What is the dollar amount of your risk premium : If both gambles offer you the same expected utility (i.e., the same expected satisfaction), what is the dollar amount of your risk premium?
To what extent is investment in education a necessary : To what extent is investment in education a necessary condition for economic development? What is meant by the complementarities between investment in physical and human capital? Why are these important?
Determine the amount of the equal-annual : Determine the amount of the equal, annual, end-of year deposits necessary to accumulate the given sum at the end of the specified period, assuming the stated annual interest rate.
The rationale for the market value method : On January 1, 2009, Brewster Company issued 2,000 of its five year, $1,000 face value

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Business Law and Ethics Questions & Answers

  Buyona wishes to purchase a used widget she goes to

buyona wishes to purchase a used widget. she goes to sellena the local widget dealer. sellena offers a used widget to

  You are new member of internal affairs and are still

you are new member of internal affairs and are still getting to know everybody. you have been asked by your lieutenant

  Explain uav and law enforcement

Explain UAV and Law Enforcement and I am in the process of preparing a response regarding UAVs as emerging technology in law enforcement

  Determine each country''s legal traditions

Compare and contrast the two countries for their definition of the crime, crime rate, and tools used to measure the crime. Determine each country's legal traditions and their major influences on crime definition, rate, and measurement. Examine the ex..

  Explain intellectual property and technology

Explain Intellectual Property and Technology and Technology makes it easy to copy and distribute music and movies without paying royalties

  Discuss payments options and discuss the pros and cons

Compare and contrast three (3) payments options and discuss the pros and cons of each. Examine the three (3) elements of the Prompt Payment Act, and provide one (1) example of each

  Describe the goals and conditions of parole

Write a 350- to 500-word paper in which you describe the goals and conditions of parole. Include the following components: The concepts on which parole is based

  Explains the specific areas of law

Explains the Specific Areas of Law to Be Used for Analysis of the Business Situation

  Utilize transgressive protest tactics

Occupy Wall Street is the most significant social movement to utilize transgressive protest tactics in the United States in the last forty years

  What defenses does danny have

Will Paul and Priscilla be able to prove all elements of their breach of contract claim? Explain your answer. What defenses does Danny have? What remedies do Paul and Priscilla have

  The discipline of criminology requires a detailed study of

the discipline of criminology requires a detailed study of crime and criminals. criminologists seek to answer the why

  Explain intellectual property and trademarks

Explain Intellectual Property and Trademarks and Under what circumstances would you consider using federal or state trademarks

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd