What is the employers view as to the origin of explicit

Assignment Help Project Management
Reference no: EM131281319

A labor arbitrator returned a heavy truck operator, James Smith, to service with specific stringent conditions after the operator had failed a second random drug test within a 15-month interval by testing positive for marijuana use. The employer sought to have the arbitrator's award vacated in federal court on the basis that the award contravened the public policy against the operation of dangerous machinery by workers who test positive for drugs. The federal district court, while recognizing a strong regulationbased public policy against drug use by workers who perform safety-sensitive functions, held that the employee's conditional reinstatement did not violate that policy and ordered the enforcement of the arbitration award. The court of appeals affirmed.

The Supreme Court granted certiorari.] BREYER, J.... We agree, in principle, that courts' authority to invoke the public policy exception is not limited solely to instances where the arbitration award itself violates positive law. Nevertheless, the public policy exception is narrow and must satisfy the principles set forth in W.R. Grace and Misco. Moreover, in a case like the one before us, where two political branches have created a detailed regulatory regime in a specific field, courts should approach with particular caution pleas to divine further public policy in that area....

Regarding drug use by persons in safety-sensitive positions, then, Congress has enacted a detailed statute. And Congress has delegated to the Secretary of Transportation authority to issue further detailed regulations on that subject. Upon careful consideration, including public notice and comment, the Secretary has done so. Neither Congress nor the Secretary has seen fit to mandate the discharge of a worker who twice tests positive for drugs.

We hesitate to infer a public policy in this area that goes beyond the careful and detailed scheme Congress and the Secretary have created. We recognize that reasonable people can differ as to whether reinstatement or discharge is the more appropriate remedy here. But both employer and union have agreed to entrust this remedial decision to an arbitrator. We cannot find in the Act, the regulations, or any other law or legal precedent an "explicit," "well defined," "dominant" public policy to which the arbitrator's decision "runs contrary," Misco, 484 U.S., at 43; and W. R. Grace, 461 U.S., at 766. We conclude that the lower courts correctly rejected Eastern's public policy claim. The judgment of the Court of Appeals is Affirmed.

[The concurring opinion of Justice Scalia, joined by Justice Thomas, criticizes the majority's statement that "[w]e agree, in principle, that courts' authority to invoke the public policy exception is not limited solely to instances where the arbitrator's award itself violates positive law." Justice Scalia complained that this dictum opens the door to "fluid public policy arguments of the sort presented by the petitioner, [Eastern Coal]." Justice Scalia believes that it is hard to imagine how an arbitration award could violate public policy as identified in W. R. Grace, Misco, and Eastern Coal without actually conflicting with positive law. In sum, he believes that dictum "is not worth the candle."]

Case Questions

1. What is the employer's view as to the origin of "explicit," "well-defined," and "dominant" public policy that makes the agreement to reinstate Smith contrary to public policy?

2. Did the Supreme Court accept the employer's position? Explain.

Reference no: EM131281319

Questions Cloud

How does the american institution influence american society : How does the American institutions influence american society and values?
Estimate the friction drag on the sign : A thin smooth sign is attached to the side of a truck as is indicated in Fig. P9.53. Estimate the friction drag on the sign when the truck is driven at 55 mph.
Why might government and big buiness not like the muckrakers : Why might government and big buiness not like the muckrakers ?
When should you teach your procedures : When should you teach your procedures? What does it mean to "teach, model, and practice" your procedures? How might procedures have an effect on student achievement?
What is the employers view as to the origin of explicit : What is the employer's view as to the origin of "explicit," "well-defined," and "dominant" public policy that makes the agreement to reinstate Smith contrary to public policy?
Write an eassy on social justice : Write an eassy :In your essay you should include your own definition of social justice and a brief explanation of why you chose the individual. You must also include a brief analysis of the historical period in which the individual lived with a sp..
Calculate the cross elasticity of demand : When the price of a cell phone increases 10 percent, the quantity of cell phone calls demanded decreases by 4 percent, calculate the cross elasticity of demand for cell phones calls with respect to the price of a cell phones? Cell phones and cell ..
Is compulsory arbitration constitutional : Were conciliation and mediation affected by the 1947 Act? If so, how? Is compulsory arbitration constitutional? Is a voluntary arbitration decision enforceable? If so, how?
Shop sells a variety of smartphones : A small shop sells a variety of smartphones. Suppose we know that the battery life of Smartphone A is normally distributed with a mean of 15 hours and a standard deviation of 6.4.

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Project Management Questions & Answers

  What is the purpose of the contract clause

How does the First Amendment protection of corporate political speech differ from the protection of corporate commercial speech?

  Managing or controling projects

Managing or Controling Projects - In project management, the control process can be replaced with proper standards and guidelines

  Why is mean an inappropriate measure of central tendency

Why is the mean an inappropriate measure of central tendency in gender of respondent (male or female);- marital status (single, married, divorced, separated, widowed, other);

  Create a documentation for the software called 2plan

Create a documentation for the software called 2Plan. What the motivation for this project is (e.g. to fill a gap in the product portfolio)? What the project will deliver. Is it a new product or an extension of an existing one?

  Explain the three forms of shorter reports and provide an

explain the three forms of shorter reports and provide an example of each saying to whom it is being sent a brief

  Developing rfp for a real-world project

Develop a RFP for a real-world project that you have participated in. Optimally, this would be an actual business or government project.

  Write a piecewise definition of the fees charged

Write a piecewise definition of the fees F(x) charged for the emission of x tons of pollutant in a year.- What is the limit of F(x) as x approaches 4,000 tons? As x approaches 8,000 tons?

  Traditional herbal medicinal used in the management of

traditional herbal medicinal used in the management of sexual importance in marakwet east.1. the project summarythis

  Critique of two project management planning tools

How the tools you selected might aid your understanding and experiences with managing projects - How the tools might make managing projects more challenging.

  Communication and technology help on the job

Communication and Technology help on the job - Explain how has technology helped you communicate while on the job?

  Draw a stock control card and discuss the completion process

Draw a stock control card and discuss the completion process

  Describe the four goals of configuration management

Describe the four goals of configuration management in your own words, and explain why each is important.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd