What is public policy

Assignment Help Management Theories
Reference no: EM131378762

New England Surrogate Parenting Advisors (NESPA) is a nonprofit organization the purpose of which is to match potential surrogate mothers with couples who are unable to have children of their own. In this case, a surrogate mother candidate was matched up with a couple who wanted to have a baby but could not do so on their own. The couple and the surrogate mother entered an agreement that stipulated that the father would pay for all pregnancy expenses plus a $10,000 fee to the mother for "conceiving, carrying and giving birth to the child." The fee was to be transferred to the surrogate mother in installments based on a structured payment plan. The final $3,500 was to be paid to the surrogate mother when the child was born.

All three parties to the agreement-the surrogate mother, the father, and the father's wife-underwent psychological screening by a psychologist. The psychologist reported that the surrogate mother was a stable, considerate, and knowledgeable woman who was aware of what she was doing and would be emotionally and psychologically capable of transferring custody to the child's biological father. For a while everything went according to the contract. The surrogate mother conceived a child by the father. The first two payments were sent and accepted by the mother.

However, at the end of the sixth month, after receiving the third payment, the mother changed her mind, returned that third payment, and told the father's attorney that the contract was ended. That was the only money returned. She kept the first two payments and the expense money she had received under the agreement. The father sued for custody, arguing that the surrogate mother had breached the contract. The judge agreed and transferred custody to the father based on the contract and because she believed such a move would ultimately be in the child's best interests. The surrogate mother appealed. The state supreme judicial court noted that, since the state had no statute covering this type of agreement, it would apply an adoption statute that was roughly analogous to the situation.

Under that statute, a mother could not give up her child for adoption until four days after the child's birth. The statute also outlawed the payment of money to the mother for an adoption, although she could be paid pregnancy expenses. If the court applies this statute to this case, the contract is illegal and, therefore, void. Can the court apply an adoption statute to a contract claim?

If so, should the court apply that statute in this case? Moreover, if it does apply the statute, what is the net effect of that application in this case? In other words, who wins? (See R.R. v. M.H. and Another, 426 N.E.2d 790 (Supreme Court of Massachusetts).)

Opening Case Questions
1. Can the judge apply adoption law to a contract case or should she confine her ruling to contract law? Explain

2. Sometimes a judge will apply the public policy doctrine in this type of a case. What is public policy? Explain.

3. Does public policy apply here? Explain. If public policy applies, what would the result be? Explain.

4. Could the surrogate mother argue that the contract is void because she was suffering from a mental impairment when she entered the agreement? If so, would she win? Why or why not?

5. Should the court consider the best interests of the child in a contract case like this? Explain.

Reference no: EM131378762

Questions Cloud

What agreements are illegal under statutory law : What is the legal status of an agreement to commit a tort or a crime?- What agreements are illegal under statutory law?
Find appropriate values for the ring : Determine appropriate values for the ring inside diameter and the clamping force.
What is the age of minority and what is the age of majority : What is the age of minority and what is the age of majority?- What is the legal status of a contract made by a minor?
Prepare the journal entries : ACCOUNTING CYCLE REVIEW PROBLEM II MFE6110 - Prepare the Journal Entries, T-accounts, and all four Financial Statements and Prepare the Journal Entries, T-accounts, and all four Financial Statements.
What is public policy : Can the judge apply adoption law to a contract case or should she confine her ruling to contract law?- Sometimes a judge will apply the public policy doctrine in this type of a case. What is public policy? Explain.
What was theodora role in the governance of constantinople : What were the outstanding accomplishments of the Byzantine empire under Justinian and Theodora's rule? What was Theodora's role in the governance of Constantinople
Write a paragraph relating this regulation to this incident : The employee was being trained on the operation of the industrial finger jointer on the day of the incident and was working on the industrial jointer at the time of the incident.
What is the relationship between dangdut and islam : What is the relationship between Dangdut and Islam? Why are Muslim clerics against it
Discuss two implications these court rulings have : Analyze the Bakke and the University of Michigan rulings and discuss two implications these court rulings have on you as the personnel manager of your agency.

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Management Theories Questions & Answers

  Marla santigo is an accountant for at lemnah company

Marla Santigo is an accountant for at Lemnah Company. Marla loves her job and spends countless hours working at the office. She enjoys working on taxes and reviewing financial records. Being an accountant was her dream and she reached hers goal after..

  Homeless shelter

Homeless Shelter

  The design and organization of our team

The Design and Organization of Our Team.” It must include a code of conduct created by your team and to be used to guide all of its members.

  Nutrition without harming the environment

1. Is this a viable sustainable entrepreneurship concept? Why or why not? Be specific. 2. How would this venture be viewed in terms of triple bottom line thinking?

  Career management-researching career opportunities

Assignment 1 : Career Management: Researching Career Opportunities Based on the preferences you identified in your career self-assessment (see page xxxviii in the Prologue) and the academic, professional, and personal qualities you have to offer, ..

  Advantages and disadvantages of the swot analysis

Explain the purpose of a SWOT analysis. What are the alternatives? Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of the SWOT analysis

  Explain and critically discuss what 21st century managers

Explain and critically discuss what 21st Century managers can learn from the 20th Century management theory and concepts.

  Distinction between relationship and causal relationship

In response to the question the distinction between relationship and causal relationship is that two factors may be correlated, but one does not necessarily cause the other. If explaining this correctly in order to recognize the difference between..

  Discuss and explain whether there is valid consideration

Discuss and explain whether there is valid consideration for each of the following promises:- A and B entered into a contract for the purchase and sale of goods. A subsequently promised to pay a higher price for the goods when B refused to deliver ..

  Solve this problem by dynamic programming

A college student has 7 days remaining before final examinations begin in her four courses, and she wants to allocate this study time as effectively as possible. She needs at least 1 day on each course, and she likes to concentrate on just one cou..

  Appeal to the internal revenue service

Professional Malpractice. Jeffery Guerrero hired James McDonald, a certified public accountant, to represent him and his business in an appeal to the Internal Revenue Service.

  What is meyers-briggs type indicator personality inventory

What is the Meyers-Briggs Type Indicator personality inventory, and why is it a useful tool for healthcare executives? Describe why human resources management is comprised of strategic and administrative actions.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd