What is mandatory subject of bargaining

Assignment Help Operation Management
Reference no: EM131139379

The company and union have had a bargaining relationship for more than 20 years. On July 11, bargaining unit member Allan Engle was performing his assigned work duties of cleaning the bathroom on the second floor of the company's administrative building when he glanced up and observed a camera approximately 6 to 8 feet away located in an air vent and pointed directly at him. Engle reported his discovery to three other bargaining unit members, including union steward Luther Hall, who went to the second floor bathroom in question and confirmed that the hidden camera was there. The following day the local union president was notified, but when she went to investigate, the hidden camera had been moved. On July 15, local union president Wanda Jackson was asked to meet with the company's HR manager Susan Albright. Albright asked Jackson if she had heard about the camera that was discovered in the sanitation department's restroom. Albright went on to say that the camera had been installed by the company because of a reported theft problem in that area, and that it was lawful as long as the company had a legitimate business reason for doing so. Albright stated that once the camera had been discovered and union members appeared irate over the issue, the camera was immediately removed by management. Local union president Jackson believed the company could have accomplished its theft investigation through less intrusive means, and the union did not approve of management's invasion of employees' privacy. The union sent a letter to the company, dated August 1, indicating that an internal investigation by union members had also uncovered hidden cameras being used in the employee's physical fitness room. On August 16, Jackson sent a hand-delivered letter to HR manager Albright demanding that the company bargain over the subject of video camera use in the work place. The company refused to bargain over the subject, whereupon the union filed an unfair labor practice charge, alleging that the company's actions violated Section 8 (a)(5) and (1) of the LMRA, as amended. The union argues that the use of surveillance cameras in the workplace for providing evidence of work-rule violations by employees, for which they could be subject to discipline or discharge, is clearly an issue that is germane to the working environment and job security interests of union members. Therefore, the union believes management has a legal duty to bargain in good faith, upon request, over issues such as the number and location of video cameras within the workplace. Other issues over which bargaining unit members might have an interest in bargaining include whether employees will be given prior notice that their conduct may be subject to filming; who will access to the video recordings made; for what purposes the video recordings may be used; and the circumstances under which the cameras can be required to be removed. The company essentially makes two arguments. First, the company believes it has an absolute right to engage in actions (like using cameras) to protect the legitimate business -related interests of the ownership. The company noted that it had for many years used 17 video cameras located both inside and outside company buildings to observe activity for protecting company property from theft or damage and to discourage other work-rule violations (e.g., drug use, sleeping on the job). These 17 cameras were in plain sight, and their existence had been known to the union's membership for many years without any prior objection from the union. In recent years, 11 additional hidden video cameras had been installed inside the company to observe specific areas where employee misconduct was suspected. To require management to bargain in advance over the use or placement of such surveillance equipment would significantly reduce the effectiveness of this method of monitoring employee conduct on the employer's premises. Second, management argues that even if the Board were to find that a duty to bargain existed, based on the circumstances in this case, the union waived its right to bargain over the subject of surveillance cameras. The company points to the length of time it has used video cameras without any objection by the union as evidence that the union has acquiesced in this practice and essentially acknowledged management's right to use surveillance cameras for legitimate business reasons. The company acknowledges that the union has a right to file a contractual grievance over any alleged misuse or abuse of surveillance methods leading to a lack of just cause for disciplinary or discharge action against a bargaining unit member. However, the right to grieve a management discipline or discharge decision is not equivalent to a right to require management to bargain, in advance, over the right to use camera surveillance as a legitimate investigatory technique.

After reviewing this case study, what is a mandatory subject of bargaining?

Reference no: EM131139379

Questions Cloud

Critical path as source of credibility and validation : Deliverable where you substantively support your choices using the critical path as a source of credibility and validation. Include 5-7 peer-reviewed references. This will require you to use MS Word and/or EXCEL to support calculations and use flowch..
The field of electronic musical instruments : Art Fleming is a design engineer with a proven track record in the field of electronic musical instruments. He recently designed a new VLSI (very large scale integrated) chip. This chip is meant to be the heart and soul of a digital sampling keyboard..
Portfolio management-game theory application in real world : Portfolio management: how would you apply what you learned in this chapter to your own portfolio? Knowing what you know now would you have made a different investment decision? Game Theory application in the real world: Can you think of legacy compet..
What is mandatory subject of bargaining : The company and union have had a bargaining relationship for more than 20 years. On July 11, bargaining unit member Allan Engle was performing his assigned work duties of cleaning the bathroom on the second floor of the company's administrative build..
Strategies for developing diversity sensitive organization : Describe some of the practices, policies, and norms that you would expect to find in an organization that prides itself on building a culture of respect and trust. In your opinion, what would be some strategies for developing a diversity sensitive or..
Influenced modern health care information systems : Analyze major events and technological advantages that influenced modern Health Care Information Systems. Consider the following events and technological advantages: Governmental Programs Documenting Care and automation Financial requirements and aut..
Employee work ethics-time management-cost management : The purpose of this assignment is to conduct internal and external research to determine previously attempted solutions and potential solutions that could be implemented to solve identified problem. The Three Problems Are Employee Work Ethics, Time m..
Use of filixibility has moved away its original paradigm : Do you agree with Juliet Bourke that the use of filixibility has moved away its original paradigm? Discuss the implications of excessive working hours on the performance of employees and managers. Discuss ways in wich employers could facilitate work-..

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Operation Management Questions & Answers

  Why these two are reacting differently to their jobs

Tony and Carol work as home sales representatives. After work Tony often comes home a migraine headache and feeling emotionally exhausted. Tony has difficulty sleeping before and after a long day at work. When dealing with stress, give three explanat..

  Identify how it supports business processes

Identify how IT supports business processes. The business is relying on their capabilities to achieve the business goals. The IT strategy should include a plan for supporting those business capabilities, creating efficiencies, and competitive adva..

  Determine optimal stocking quantity

The Express was established as the town newspaper after the first year of operations. The daily demand remained at 500, the standard deviation of daily demand at 10.0 Armentrout retailed at $1 newspapers purchased from Sheen.

  Determine total cost to make a blaster unit

Determine the total cost (purchase price + delivery cost) to make a Blaster unit using thesewoofer and tweeter components and each delivery combination option?

  Modify the definition of the class romantype

Modify the definition of the class romanType so that the data membersare declared as protecred. Use the class string to maniputlate extraction operators for easy input and output. The stream insertion operator outputs the Roman numberal in the Rom..

  The feds beige book researches

The Feds Beige Book researches _____.

  Why should a first-line supervisor understand

Why should a first-line supervisor understand the organization's objectives?

  Develop list of topics that no-purchasing personnel

In a 1-2 pages develop a list of topics that no-purchasing personnel should be allowed to talk about with their counterparts at suppliers. Then, develop a list that only purchasing-personnel should be allowed to talk about with suppliers.

  Understanding of maslow hierarchy of needs

Your supervisors have come to you and told you that they want to have a better understanding of Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs. Their reasoning is to have a better understanding of where the workers who report to them are coming from in this hierarchy.

  Explain the managerial significance of aggregate planning

Explain the managerial significance of aggregate planning.

  Customers arrive at an automated coffee vending machine

Customers arrive at an automated coffee vending machine at a rate of 3 per minute, following a Poisson distribution. The coffee machine dispenses a cup of coffee in exactly 15 seconds. What is the average number of people waiting in line? What is the..

  What are the humanities and how are they relevant

Write a five to six-page essay on the following topic: What are the humanities and how are they relevant to our lives? Illustrate your discussion with reference to one specific ancient/medieval text assigned in this class and explain its relevanc..

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd