What do you find most puzzles about it

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM13950205

Dr. Ryan's Happiness Lecture

We have discussed happiness a bit from the standpoint of contemporary science. Now, let's consider where ancient philosophy might contribute to the discussion by overlapping with or extending these perspectives.

This lecture is a running commentary on the philosopher Aristotle. The large question it seeks to address is: ‘What does it mean to say

that ethics is about happiness?'

Human Agents

Aristotle started his consideration of ethics with something so fundamental one might almost overlook it: the structure of human actions.

Every human action deserving of the name aims at something; and that ‘something' is (or, at least seems) a good. Therefore, we might say paraphrasing Aristotle, "the good is that at which all human actions aim."

Another way to say it, is that ethics is rooted in desire, for we need to be ‘moved' to action, and for that we need a felt desire. Where the direct aim of study might be knowledge, the point of human life-where we are defined as "agents"-is the good attainable by and through our actions. Ethics, as a "science," meant helping us to attain what we desire. In other words, to act well and successfully achieve the goals we set.

But in our lives we pursue many good things, and even different kinds of goods. When I pump gas at the filling station, my goal is to get my car in a state to take me somewhere. I had a student once who played soccer well enough to gain a college scholarship. While the latter was an aim, he also confessed that playing soccer for him can be its own reward.

These kinds of considerations led Aristotle to start searching for a term and a concept that would capture the life of human desire and action in one great sweep. He thought that finding this would give ethical study something to aim at. He asked, is there one good for human agents that sums up all the rest? If so, he thought, it would have to be an "ultimate good." That is, this good is not made good by its leading to something else (e.g., gassing up the car). This good would not be one of the things we seek in order to get something else. Further, he said, in addition to being ultimate this good would have to be "self-sufficient." The one who possesses it would not be in a state of wanting anything else.

Is there a name for a good like that (i.e., ultimate and making its possessor self-sufficient)? Aristotle claimed that this what most people have in mind when they use the word "happiness."

"For the present we define as self-sufficient that which taken by itself makes life something desirable and deficient in nothing. It is happiness, in our opinion, which fits this description. Moreover, happiness is of all things the one most desirable, and it is not counted as one good thing among many others."

Now, while Aristotle thought everybody had some idea of happiness when they use the word, most would not be able to give a very good definition. This leads him to start examining what people usually say happiness is. Here are some of the most popular responses:

· Happiness is wealth
· Happiness is health
· Happiness is power
· Happiness is fame
· Happiness is honor

But on examination, Aristotle finds that each of these definitions is wanting: either not really ultimate or not able to make its possessor self-sufficient. For instance, it was clear to Aristotle that wealth couldn't be ultimate, because money was only good when you traded it in for something you really want. (Aristotle couldn't have foreseen the seeming endless shopping made possible by the internet of course.) Being famous, on the other hand, makes you dependent on lots of other people who must continue to know of you. Hardly self-sufficient.

The Human ‘Function' and Happiness

Aristotle turns in another direction for a definition of happiness. His view of the natural order assumed that every existing thing was designed for something, had a "function" of sorts. Rocks are designed to fall to the ground when dropped. Knives, a human artifact, are designed to cut. Among living things, functions are identified with respect to the kind of life an organism has. Plants take in nutrition (soil, water) and sunlight, and grow. Animals, in addition, have senses like sight and hearing, issuing in a distinctive way of inhabiting an "environment." To understand the human function, or what our life is for, we need to identify the distinctive life proper to us.
We share in the life of plants, he implies, in taking in nutrition to grow. We also share in animal life, since like them we respond to stimuli in our environment through our bodily senses. But above these, humans have reasoning. Because it's what distinguishes us, Aristotle states that our function is a life guided by reasoning. Further, the word that Aristotle uses for reason, logos, also signifies the capacity of language. So, it becomes clear that for Aristotle, a reasonable life was a life undertaken with others in societies. (In a later unit, will come back to the idea of "moral reasoning.")

So, for Aristotle happiness will be defined in relation to the kind of life fitting for humans, one that involves reasoning in important ways. Putting this with our earlier point that humans are bodily agents, we can now conclude that happiness will be a life of reasonable actions. Just one more point needs to be made here. Aristotle notes that in ordinary talk we evaluate many things that have a function. The function of a knife is cut, but "a good knife," we say, is one that cuts well. Thus, while human lives generally will reflect reasoning, a "good human life" will be one that ‘reasons and acts well.' Thus for Aristotle, happiness has everything to do with a life that expresses reasoning, and does so excellently.

Here are his words:

"...we state the function of man to be a certain kind of life, and this to be an activity or actions of the soul implying a rational principle, and the function of a good man to be the good and noble performance of these, and if any action is well performed when it is performed in accordance with the appropriate excellence: if this is the case, human good turns out to be activity of soul in accordance with virtue, and if there are more than one virtue, in accordance with the best and most complete." Nichomachean Ethics, Book I

Questions-

1. What do you find appealing in Aristotle's account of human happiness?

2. What do you find most puzzles about it?

Reference no: EM13950205

Questions Cloud

Create a commentary on the given article : create a commentary on the article on international trade and protectionism
Discuss how you will avoid future violations of the code : Discuss your decisions in relation to your personal values. Discuss your decisions in relations to your organization's values (Sigma Nu). Discuss how you will avoid future violations of the Code. What did you learn about yourself from the Substance A..
What is the total product purchased by adriana : What is the total product purchased by Adriana? What implications does this have for the management accounting information system?  How does the strategic positioning differ for the two companies?
Calculate total number of copies-publisher expects to sell : Your finance text book sold 54,500 copies in its first year. The publishing company expects the sales to grow at a rate of 19.0 percent for the next three years, and by 6.0 percent in the fourth year. Calculate the total number of copies that the pub..
What do you find most puzzles about it : What do you find appealing in Aristotle's account of human happiness? What do you find most puzzles about it and We have discussed happiness a bit from the standpoint of contemporary science
Debt-equity ratio be if firm wishes to keep ratios constant : A firm wishes to maintain a growth rate of 8 percent and a dividend payout ratio of 62 percent. The ratio of total assets to sales is constant at 1, and the profit margin is 10 percent. What must the debt-equity ratio be if the firm wishes to keep th..
Expected dividend payout ratio-constant dividend growth rate : Weaver Chocolate Co. expects to earn $2.75 per share during the current year, its expected dividend payout ratio is 60%, its expected constant dividend growth rate is 7.0%, and its common stock currently sells for $34.50 per share. New stock can be s..
Develop strategies in response to actual situations : Understand how significant life events impact on individuals and their social networks - Analyse possible group responses to significant life events that occur to one of its members
Describes the history of the hiv health issue : Write a paper of 750- words that describes the history of the HIV health issue. Include the following: Influences such as determinants of health and socioeconomic status. Past and present initiatives to address the issue

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  Examined as part of an external audit

What are the five major types of external forces that should be examined as part of an external audit? Give an example of each type of force.

  Provide significant historical or recent developments

What is the common demographic or target group that utilizes your transportation sector when traveling or touring? Explain your answers.

  How different cultural work values and worldviews

Give examples of how different cultural work values and worldviews can be sources of conflict and misunderstanding in the workplace. Discuss some of the specific gender-related career issues and career counseling implications.

  Change linguistic habits

Attempts to change linguistic habits such as the adoption of more neutral terms such as firefighter, police officer, and first-year student for gender- biased ones such as fireman, policeman, and freshman are based on.

  Conducting and analyzing statistical tests

Examine the relationship between student anxiety for an exam and the number of hours studied - Conducting and Analyzing Statistical Tests

  Explain what constitutes groups involved in iron triangle

Explain what constitutes the three groups involved in the iron triangle, and describe the role of each group. Identify a policy issue, other than one explained in the chapter, and list the groups that would fall within the iron triangle for that po..

  Difference between concrete variable and abstract construct

Discuss the difference between a concrete variable and an abstract construct. identify an example of a concrete varble and an example of an abstracr construct. write a survey question tht would be answered by your example of a concrete variable.a

  Examining the geology of a region

When examining the geology of a region for potential useable aquifers, what characteristics or factors would you consider? Also, taking into account certain natural and human factors, which areas would you avoid?

  A worker was electrocuted when he drilled through a wall

a worker was electrocuted when he drilled through a wall and the drill bit contacted an electrical wire inside the

  Examine the theories and practice of development

In this class we examine the theories and practice of development.You are going to write a paper on any part of childhood development that interests you. The APUS library will be a great place to start this search

  What is the ultimate check on an elected official in texas

What is the ultimate check on an elected official in Texas?

  Violation of miranda rule may be used to impeach a defendant

Statements taken in violation of the Miranda rule may be used to impeach a defendant that testifies inconsistently with his confession. However, an involuntary confession cannot be used for impeachment. What justifies the distinction between these tw..

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd