What do you do in this circumstance

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM13501785

You are an explorer within a foreign land and you have been living with a local forest tribe that you know has had problems with the enroachment of the country's government into their tribal lands. Late one night, the village you are staying in is raided by a local military unit and everyone is taken prisoner. Early the next morning, the commander of the unit comes to you and apologizes for your imprisonment. He explains that foreigners are greatly valued in this society and he would like to bestow an honor upon you. He summons a group of ten captive tribesmen before you and tells you that he will give you this choice (as an honored guest in this land): a) you may choose to shoot one tribesman for his crimes against the government and the others will be released (presumably having learned their lesson) or b) you may choose not to shoot anyone and then the soldiers will execute the men of the village.

What would a Kantian agent do here (use the Categorical Imperative, both HEI and UL formulations, to justify your answer)? What do you do in this circumstance? Why do you choose one option over the other? Do you believe that we should be held morally responsible for things we don't do as much as things that we do?

Reference no: EM13501785

Questions Cloud

How to calculate the molar mass of the unknown : A solution made from 6.50 g of an unkown compound in 27.8 g of diphenyl has a molality of 0.195 m. Calculate the molar mass of the unknown
Calculate the power spectrum of square pulse : Calculate the power spectrum of square pulse with amplitude, A and length, τ0. plot the power spectrum, shower several zero-crossings
What is the torque in unit vector notation about the origin : A particle with radius r=5i+4k+3k has a force of F=3i-8j+5k acting on it. What is the torque in unit vector notation about the origin
Explain a saturated na2co3 solution is prepared : A saturated Na2CO3 solution is prepared, and a small excess of solid is present (white pile in beaker). A seed cdrystal of Na2 14CO3 (14C is a radioactive isotope of 12C) is added (small red piece), and the radioactivity is measured over time
What do you do in this circumstance : What would a Kantian agent do here (use the Categorical Imperative, both HEI and UL formulations, to justify your answer)? What do you do in this circumstance? Why do you choose one option over the other? Do you believe that we should be held m..
Determine the minimum diameter must the wire have : A brass wire is to withstand a tensile force of 350N without breaking. What minimum diameter (in mm) must the wire have
Express analytical procedures : With reference to each one of the five ratios in turn and the other information provided explain what the results of your calculations indicate for Globe Ltd's going concern.
Evaluate the maximum bond extension in angstroms : Calculate the maximum bond extension in Angstroms past equilibrium in HCl35 in its first excited vibrational state. The fundamental absorption frequency of this molecule is 2885 cm-1.
What is the wavelength of a gamma-ray photon : Gamma rays are photons with very high energy. What is the wavelength of a gamma-ray photon with energy 605 keV

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  Social psychologist contacted by a defense attorney

You are a social psychologist contacted by a defense attorney who is convinced that her client is innocent of assault.

  Identify an ethical dilemma-either something that you have

identify an ethical dilemma-either something that you have recently faced in your life at work in school etc. or

  The netherlands had a wealthy population

The Netherlands had a wealthy population, to a great extent, for this reason:

  Analyze 15 to 20 birthday cards at a nearby store

analyze 15 to 20 birthday cards at a nearby store. categorize cards by gender and by age of intended recipient. if you

  Effective mastery of course material-text emphasizes value

For effective mastery of course material, the text emphasizes the value of

  Lighting fixtures in his living room

Fred plans a major home improvement project that involves replacing the lighting fixtures in his living room. He is considering two kinds of fixtures

  Crimes committed by college-educated people

Roberta reads in the local paper that there is an increase in white-collar crimes (crimes committed by college-educated people) in the United States. The percentage of criminals who are college educated has gone up to 32 percent in the past five y..

  Internal and inmate classification-reclassification system

Discuss inmate classification, reclassification, and internal classification systems. What do they involve? How does classification help control inmate behavior and support prison management

  Employee worked as drill-machine operator-unexcused absence

An employee worked as a drill and machine operator at a furniture manufacturer. Employees were subject to dismissal when they accumulated seven points against them for violations based on conduct. For example, an excused absence was one point, while ..

  Social media to mobilize not only its potential customers

How has Tupperware used social media to mobilize not only its potential customers of a younger generation, but also its sales force? Would you say these efforts have been successful or not? Why? Explain your rationale.

  What is the present value

What is the present value of $25,000 that you will receive at the end of two years?

  Write down a 1750- to 2100-word debate paper in which you

write a 1750- to 2100-word debate paper in which you create a debate of a current event or other controversial topic

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd