What do you believe to be the major distinctions

Assignment Help History
Reference no: EM131707295

Assignment: HOWARD ZINN

Assumptions

"When I actually sat down to write, it took less than a year to write it. I wrote it because after the movements of the sixties people had been radicalized and people became dissatisfied with the traditional history, and wanted histories that showed working people and black people and Native Americans and women. And I was aware that no such book existed, that no such history existed. So I decided that I would try to fill that gap."

Beliefs

"I don't believe in neutrality because the world is already moving in certain directions and wars are going on and children are going hungry. Terrible things are happening. And so to be neutral in a situation like this when things are already moving is to collaborate with whatever is going on. And I don't want to collaborate with the world as it is. I want to intrude myself. I want to participate in changing the direction of things. So that's the origin of the title, You Can't Be Neutral on a Moving Train."

Values

I was just a seventeen-year-old kid, going to Times Square to participate in this left-wing demonstration. I really didn't know what was going on. But it seemed good. The signs were for peace and justice and so on. But then at this peaceful demonstration, I was attacked by police mounted on horseback and on foot. Before I knew it, I was clubbed and knocked unconscious. You might say I woke up with a new consciousness. I woke up realizing that things my radical friends had been saying to me were really true, that the police and the government were not detached bystanders that freedom of speech did not really exist for dissenters, for radicals, for troublemakers. So it gave me a radical view of the United States, a critical view of the role of the state and of the instruments of the state-the police, the Army, and so on-as not being neutral at all in political battles, but being generally against workers and against striking people, against dissenters of all kinds.

LARRY SCHWEIKART

Assumptions

Just 35 years ago, our book would have simply been called, "A History of the United States." Today, virtually all of the so-called "mainstream" texts range from moderately biased to completely and overwhelmingly biased against a free-market, limited-government perspective. Their slant is sometimes blunt, often clever and always varied to make absolutely certain that if one technique doesn't work on unsuspecting students, another will.

Beliefs

Likewise, despite 40 years' worth of regulatory attack, the American economic system still remains the most productive in the world, due to a higher degree of private property rights and competition. In our book, we celebrate those who created and cultivated these pillars, while at the same time deconstructing numerous myths of the Left. The result is that any student reading "A Patriot's History" will have a hard time suppressing pride in being an American.

Values

The history of the United States is not only inspiring; it is essentially "conservative," in that it reaffirms many of those values that conservatives (and many libertarians) today hold dear. And the best news is that one does not have to distort the evidence to tell the story of a great country.

Ultimately, learning "just the facts" of the American past leads a student to inevitably conclude that the United States is the best place on earth, and that it has acted, for the most part, far better than any other nation at any other time. If that generates a feeling of patriotism - or makes one a patriot - so be it.

After reviewing Zinn's and Schweikart's personal assumptions, beliefs, and values as well as excerpts from their historical writing, respond to the following questions:

• What do you believe to be the major distinctions in their personal assumptions, beliefs, and values?
• What do you believe to be the major distinctions in their interpretations of history?
• Do you notice any biases? If so, what are they?

Reference no: EM131707295

Questions Cloud

Identify if you seen anything new in your everyday life : Identify if you seen anything new in your everyday life because of the reading, and assess its significance for you.
Describe the audit regulation mechanisms : Briefly describe the main differences between the audit regulation mechanisms in the United States and Germany.
Individual cultures hold the environment with more respect : Which individual cultures hold the environment with more respect? Why? Which ones hold the environment with less respect. Why?
What can the pcaob do to strengthen the auditing function : What can the PCAOB do to strengthen the auditing function in the United States? Provide examples of two key steps it has taken so far to achieve this.
What do you believe to be the major distinctions : What do you believe to be the major distinctions in their personal assumptions, beliefs, and values? Do you notice any biases? If so, what are they?
Various american indian communities : In what ways have American Indians continued to be limited by poverty and powerlessness, prejudice, and discrimination?
Role performance and presentation of the self : Do people adjust their role performance and presentation of the self to affect the opinion of others? Would you say that we have different "social selves"
Explain the environmental factors for the own country : Explain the environmental factors that affect the issues concerning auditing in your own country.
Prepare the general journal entries for the january events : Use this information to prepare the General Journal entries (without explanation) for the January events

Reviews

Write a Review

 

History Questions & Answers

  Enlivened the larger mediterranean basin

The broad establishment of Greek colonies enlivened the larger Mediterranean basin. How did the Greek colonies and widespread trade effect many regions in the area that previously had undergone little economic or political development?

  A chess competition involving some men and women

A chess competition involving some men and women, every player needs to play exactly one game with every other player. It was found that in 45 games, both the players were women and in 190 games, both players were men.

  Transform the social and political history of the south

How did cotton production after 1793 transform the social and political history of the south?How did the rest of the nation benefit?In what way was it an "international phenomenon"?

  Discuss the role of the colonialists in articulating africa

Discuss the role of the colonialists in articulating africa into the world capitalist economy.

  What we are reading and discussing in class

Please write about 2/3 page for each hour you spend on the activity. Write about what you learned from the experience and how it relates to what we are reading and discussing in class.

  Searching for a cause for suffering

In searching for a cause for their suffering, who did Europeans blame for the Black Death and how did they seek revenge?

  Discuss about the americas before the european migrations

Read Section 1 from this week's Webtext titled "The Americas Before the European Migrations," then briefly summarize the early development of the indigenous population of America. Be sure to include their origin, methods of survival, domestication..

  Conservative and liberal camps embrace positivism

Why did so many Latin American intellectual and political leaders of both the Conservative and Liberal camps embrace Positivism and then allow the resulting alliance to dissolve?

  Explain the demand-side policy and supply-side policy

Describe the differences between demand-side policy and supply-side policy. Which one do you prefer and why?

  Address the role of women as army nurses what opportunities

1.address the role of women as army nurses. what opportunities did it create? did it have a greater affect on one

  Can you get a feel for the way herodotus depict the persians

How does Herodotus depict the Spartans in this section? Can you get a feel for the way Herodotus depicts the Persians? Is there a significant contrast here?

  The result of leo iii''s policy of iconoclasm was

The result of Leo III's policy of iconoclasm was

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd