What constitutional provisions would allow congress
Course:- Business Law and Ethics
Reference No.:- EM131168297

Assignment Help
Expertsmind Rated 4.9 / 5 based on 47215 reviews.
Review Site
Assignment Help >> Business Law and Ethics

Case Study

In response to increasing medical knowledge about the genetic source of obesity, Congress enacts and the president signs the "Obesity Rights Act" (ORA). The statute reads as follows:

Section 1: Findings

The Congress hereby finds that the obese are subject to unreasonable and unfair discrimination in employment, given prejudice against and misunderstanding of the condition of obesity. The Congress also recognizes that a desire to earn a profit may require a business to consider the physical attributes of certain members of its work force, and that this is a legitimate consideration.

The Congress also finds that obesity is not a legitimate tool for determining the capability of any person to contribute to an efficient workplace.

Section 2: Discrimination

It is a violation of federal law for any employer to discriminate unreasonably against any person based on the person's weight, except where weight is a bona fide occupational requirement and where all reasonable attempts to accommodate the person have been made.

Section 3: Definitions

"Employer" means any person, partnership, corporation or other business entity, state, or subunit of state government that employs any person.

Section 4: Relief

Any person may sue to enforce the provisions of this act in any federal court where venue is proper. A court may order damages, back pay, or other relief, as appropriate.

Section 5: Regulations

(a) The U.S. Department of Labor is authorized to promulgate regulations to enforce these provisions. Violations of any valid regulation shall be considered violation of federal law.

You may assume the following:

1. During its consideration of the ORA, Congress heard evidence that, as a psychological matter, people make assumptions about people's self-control and discipline based in part on whether they are obese. Congress was also told that, in a public opinion poll, 67 percent of Americans said they would be uncomfortable working with an obese person.

2. Three individuals testified to Congress that they were fired from jobs - one from a job with the New York state government, one with a large corporation, and one with a small business - based solely on their obesity, despite achieving good performance reviews.

3. The CPOD was formed "to fight, in the legislatures, the courts, and in public opinion, all forms of discrimination and stereotypes about, and oppression of, obese persons."

1. Adams v. Baker Albert Adams, a junior auditor for the State of Baker, is fired for being obese. He sues the state and the state's head auditor under the law, requesting back pay, damages, and an injunction against the head state auditor forbidding him from firing or demoting Adams.

What constitutional provisions would allow Congress to impose ORA on the State of Baker?

2. Confederation for the Prevention of Obesity Discrimination (CPOD) v. Department of Labor Meanwhile, the Department of Labor promulgates the following regulation:

Reg A: A "bona fide occupational requirement" is any requirement that, in the eyes of a reasonable employer, is reasonably necessary to prevent a loss of business or profit, taking into account reasonable customer preferences.

The Confederation believes that this regulation is far too lenient, and contravenes the intention of the statute. On the day the regulation is promulgated, it sues the Department of Labor. Does it have standing?

Put your comment

Ask Question & Get Answers from Experts
Browse some more (Business Law and Ethics) Materials
What are some resources to cover the cost of mental health issues in the criminal justice system? Outline a budget after the resources are identified.Minimum of 250 words plea
Imagine that you are a justice of the United States Supreme Court and you have been requested to write an opinion on this case. How would you rule and why? You may cite dec
Lead File Clerk Fidora spends many hours in a large room filed with closed case files. She's very good at her job so she has hours of extra time on her hands when she must
Explain the differences between the treatment and punishment concepts. Build the case for which one you believe has the stronger position based on your research and the crim
What do you feel is the most effective way to administer probation? Your response should be 200 to 300 words in length. How can probation officers establish better relations
Explain how conflict theory is related to both criminology and sociology using appropriate terminology. Discuss how politics play a role in conflict theory using appropriate t
Studying a unit called the Sale of Goods and Consumer Protection Law. The case brief you'll be asked to create will be based upon a sale of goods judgment that you are already
Aafter every Olympics, a number of medal-winning athletes lament their lack of commercial recognition. From a branding perspective, how would you respond to the complaints o