What are the pros and cons of this appraisal tool

Assignment Help Operation Management
Reference no: EM131114546

Consider this scenario: John Hopken is the new supervisor of a team of 12 computer programmers. He has been in his position for 10 months, after being promoted to his position from programmer (where he had been in place for 8 years). The promotion was hard-won; four others on his team also applied for the promotion, and when he got his promotion, the other four employees who didn’t get the position were rather disgruntled. One of them lashed out in a meeting early on and called him a yes-man, but otherwise most of the issues have been undercurrents and rumor based. These four employees are referred to as Competitors 1, 2, and 3 and Competitor Yes-Man for the purposes of this question. During the year, five older members of his team resigned, four through regular retirements and one after being accused of falsifying expense reports. None of the five were in the group of four who had competed against him for his position. John filled all five position openings with outside hires. Three of them had similar backgrounds to John’s—they all went to his alma mater for their computer degrees and like basketball. In fact, last week John and the three of them attended a Bulls game together. These employees will be referred to as Bulls 1, 2, and 3. The other two employees were both females he hired because HR told him he had to. (Up till now, there were no females on the team.) We’ll call them Lady 1 and 2. They don’t like basketball. Lady 1 was hired 6 months ago, and Lady 2 was hired last month. Now, it is performance appraisal time. Assume each of these employees does a similar amount of work, produces relatively similar amounts of code, and does a good job. None of them create waves, and the new people have gotten their work under way and are working hard. Other than the yes-man meeting and one comment on the men’s room wall saying that “Hopken is a jerk,” things have mostly gone smoothly. John figures that one of the Competitors wrote that. John is told by HR he has to do performance appraisals this month. He is told to rate his people on a scale of 1–4, where 1 is “not meeting expectations,” 2 is “too new to rate,” 3 is “meeting expectations,” and 4 is “exceeding expectations.” HR said that he must have no more than two 4s, no more than eight 3s, and at least two 1s or 2s. He asks an HR representative what “too new” means, and she says it applies to anyone who has not been in the position for 3 months or more. He looks at the paperwork and his list, and 20 minutes later has his ratings done with a paragraph scribbled out to provide to his workers. Here are the ratings John gives his employees, as well as his support paragraph. Bulls 1: 4: What a great guy—always comes through, works hard, fun loving, makes the day brighter for everyone Bulls 2: 4: Team player; what a help—great worker and asset to the company Bulls 3: 3: Always there for the work group—works steady and helpful to others, accurate coder Lady 1: 3: Always there for the work group—works steady and helpful to others, accurate coder Other 1: 3: Always there for the work group—works steady and helpful to others, accurate coder Other 2: 3: Always there for the work group—works steady and helpful to others, accurate coder Other 3: 3: Always there for the work group—works steady and helpful to others, accurate coder Competitor 1: 3: Accurate coding and steady performer Competitor 2: 3: Accurate coding and steady performer Competitor 3: 3: Accurate coding and steady performer Lady 2: 2: Too new to rate but next year should be great Competitor YM: 1: Not a team player and can work harder to prevent discord Please answer the following questions. The day after the PAs are delivered, HR receives appeals filed by Bulls 3, Competitor 1, and Competitor YM. After listening to the employees, HR decides to do a 360-degree appraisal of John Hopken.

(1) What is the 360-degree appraisal? What are the pros and cons of this appraisal tool?

(2) Let’s say you are told you must implement this 360-degree appraisal on John. How would you go about doing this? What kinds of questions would you include on the appraisal, and who would you give it to? What kinds of feedback might you expect, and how might you use that feedback to help John with performance appraisals?

(3) Would you have recommended the 360-degree appraisal as a way to resolve this issue? Why or why not?

Reference no: EM131114546

Questions Cloud

Likely to be an effect of workforce reduction : Which of the following is not likely to be an effect of workforce reduction?
Discussed the decision making skills of the arbitrator : Since we have discussed the decision making skills of the arbitrator, as well as the benefits of arbitration, lets explore HOW an arbitrator becomes an arbitrator. What are the qualifications of an arbitrator? Would a labor arbitrator have different ..
How many tires should rocky mountains tire order each time : Rocky Mountain Tire Center sells 14,000 go-cart tires per year. The ordering cost for each order is $35, and the holding cost is 40% of the purchace price of the tires per year. How many tires should Rocky Mountains tire order each time it time it pl..
What is the optimal size of the production rn : Radovilsky Manufacturing Company, in Hayward. California. makes flashing lights for toys. The company operates its production facility 300 days per year. It has orders fo about 11,600 flashing lights per year and hasthe capability of producing 95 per..
What are the pros and cons of this appraisal tool : Consider this scenario: John Hopken is the new supervisor of a team of 12 computer programmers. He has been in his position for 10 months, after being promoted to his position from programmer (where he had been in place for 8 years). What is the 360-..
How businesses should manage the regulatory environment : Which of the following best describes how businesses should manage the regulatory environment? Top managers must take responsibility and be accountable for assessing legal risks and developing corporate programs that promote and reward acceptable con..
Determine eoq and annual inventory cost for each warehouse : A distributor is planning to consolidate his two warehouses into a single one. He sells widgets from the warehouse. Each widget costs $100. He estimates that each seperate warehouse today faces a mean demand of 1200 per week with standard deviation o..
Benefit from an ethics training program : Which of the following is not likely to be a benefit from an ethics training program?
How many orders per year are needed with the optimal policy : M. Cotteleer Electronics supplies microcomputer circuitry to a company that incorporates microprocessors into refrigerators and other home appliances. One of the components has an annual demand of 245 units, and this is constant throughout the year. ..

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Operation Management Questions & Answers

  What is the first time yield

A water heater production facility is showing 500 water heaters entering the assembly process, 5 being scrapped, and 495 passing final inspection for a yield (Y) of 99.00 percent. As you look deeper, however, you find 20 water heaters when through a ..

  Calculate the multifactor productivity for this operation

A company offers ID theft protection using leads obtained from client banks. Three employees work 40 hours a week on the leads, at a pay rate of $15 per hour per employee. Each employee identifies an average of 4,000 potential leads a week from a lis..

  Avoiding the first mover disadvantages

avoiding the "first mover disadvantages" associated with making early commitments to alternative technologies, wider product selection, different styling, or new distribution channels.

  Discuss advantages also disadvantages of intermediaries

Discuss advantages also disadvantages of utilizing intermediaries like wholesalers, agents also brokers to distribute your organizations products or services.

  What is the optimal daily profit

Profits for regular soft drink are $3.00 per case, and profits for diet soft drink are $2.00 per case. What is the optimal daily profit?

  Recommended course of action and an implementation plan

Panera Bread Company 2010 Still Rising Fortunes? Case Study Questions Clearly Identify 6 symptoms & 3 substantial problems? 2-3 stated problems analyzed thoughtfully, SWOT Analysis & Relevant financial analysis. Recommended course of Action and an Im..

  Which ones have the most impact on your choices

Consider the diverse means of differentiating products and services. Which ones have the most impact on your choices? Why?

  You created a fictional start-up company entering a foreign

you created a fictional start-up company entering a foreign non u.s. market with a good or service. here you will

  Insight communications promotes employees with good

Insight Communications Promotes employees with good technical skills into supervisory positions and then teaches them leadership skills.

  For production combination which resource is slack

For production combination of 800 boxes of Deluxe and 600 boxes of Classic which resource is slack (not fully used).

  Define long-term commitment to employees

The process by which organizations move from their present state to some desired future state is called

  Role of money as a determinant of a persons satisfaction

What do you think is the role of money as a determinant of a person’s satisfaction at work and with life in general? Should organizations worry about this issue? Explain.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd