What are the pros and cons of nasas decision

Assignment Help Case Study
Reference no: EM131253126

Case Study Bio

links //// https://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2012/04/120413-nasa-viking-program-mars-life-space-science/
https://www.space.com/17963-mars-curiosity.html
https://www.space.com/28019-mars-methane-disovery-curiosity-rover.html

Instructions

1) Follow the National Geographic link about the Mars Viking mission results (Part I), read the article and answer questions from Part I

2) Follow the Space.com articles about the Curiosity mission experiments (Part II and III), read the articles and answer questions for Part II and Part III

3) Write ONLY your answers in the same word document as Case Study 1

Case Study

Part I Questions

1) If you were a NASA scientist designing the studies for finding life on Mars, what would you look for that signified life on the Red Planet? How do you differentiate between life and non-life?

2) What are all the possible characteristics that, would confirm that a material or planet or any object for that matter, contains a living organism?

3) Design an experiment that would allow you to determine whether one of the signs of life you identified above is present on Mars. Describe your hypothesis, control, experimental conditions, variables and the expected results if life is present or absent.

4) TheNatGeo article talked about the Curiosity mission, this article was published in 2012, and the Curiosity mission is already on Mars right now. When the Curiosity scientists were designing the experiments to study life on Mars. The NASA scientists categorized their experiments into three categories:

a. experiments that make no (or extremely minimal) assumptions about the chemistry and physiology of Martian organisms;

b. experiments that assume that life on Earth and on Mars evolved along similar lines and produced organisms with similar biochemical properties; and

c. experiments that assume that Martian life is based on organic compounds (i.e., life is carbon-based) but whose biochemistry differs significantly from that of Earth life (for example, Martian life is not assumed to eat sugars and exhale carbon dioxide). This is an intermediate position between the ones outlined above.

Which of these categories do your above designed experiments fall under?

5) What are the pros and cons of NASA's decision to interpret a positive signal on any one of the experiments as evidence enough to prove that they have detected life on Mars?

Part IIand Part III Questions

1) In terms of finding life on Mars, how is the Curiosity mission different from Viking?

2) Why do you think the scientists chose Methane as a marker for life on Mars? What other molecules would you look for if you were designing these experiments? Think about all you have learnt about molecules involved in making life and required by life to survive, energy being the most important.

3) After reading Part III, it seems like the scientists make a lot of assumptions without having solid evidence. To prove something thing in science, you have to test it many different ways to draw a final conclusion. List some pitfalls in the design of experiments done in Part III. Make suggestions of changes or additions you would make to these experiments.

4) Life on earth survives because of the presence of water. Wherever water is, life is. However, the conditions on Mars are very different from Earth. Do you think it is necessarily true that water would play such an important role in development and survival of life on Mars as well? From the properties of water you know, what do you think could be a replacement for water?

5) Carbon is the backbone of all biological molecules and life. Using your knowledge of the elemental properties of carbon, what do you think could be an alternative element for becoming the most important element in living things? Describe some of the properties of these elements.

Reference no: EM131253126

Questions Cloud

Why is it important to understand social hierarchies : What is a social hierarchy? Why is it important to understand social hierarchies? - Using the Chapters that we have read define social hierarchy.
Customer service focus : How did PM help IBM switch to a customer service focus in the 1980s?
What are the ethical issues involved in organ transplant : Should alcoholics be given liver transplants? Why or why not? - What are the ethical issues involved in organ transplant?
Cracking the code of change article : The exam covers the entire Managing Organization Change book, multiple articles throughout the term which were referenced in all lectures, all lectures, the Cracking the Code of Change article specifically (Beer and Nohria, Harvard Business Review..
What are the pros and cons of nasas decision : What are the pros and cons of NASA's decision to interpret a positive signal on any one of the experiments as evidence enough to prove that they have detected life on Mars?
Decision impact the chip manufacturers sales and net profit : A manufacturer of computer chips has a computer hardware company as its largest customer. The computer hardware company requires all of its chips to meet specifications of 1.2 cm. What are the elements that the production manager should consider in d..
What percentage of colleges graduates from the past 5 years : An on-campus career counselor would like to know what percentage of the college's graduates from the past 5 years is currently employed in their degree field.  - He interviews 300 graduates from the past 5 years. Define the sample.
About growing equality with income : Why is there a growing disparity between the rich and poor in the US? What are some of the reasons for this and what should the government do to bring about growing equality with income? Do we as citizens have an ethical responsibility to help the po..
What would profile look like in terms of specific content : If you had to create a talent management-type job profile for the average employee at Patagonia, what would the profile look like in terms of its specific contents?

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Case Study Questions & Answers

  Determine the various roles that host governments played

Describe the legal, cultural, and ethical challenges that confront the global business presented in your selected case study. Determine the various roles that host governments played in this particular global business operation

  Was france the best choice for the location of euro-disney

What assumptions did Disney make about the tastes and preferences of French consumers? Which of these assumptions were correct? Which were not?

  Discuss critically infosys current and future strategy

Discuss critically Infosys current and future strategy. What advice would you give Kris Gopalakrishnan and KShop has resulted in information overload among staff. What operational measures would you suggest to overcome such challenges?

  Summarize advantage of accounting electronic data processing

Summarize advantages and disadvantages of various accounting electronic data processing systems with respect to a specific industry's needs.

  Case analysis:degree appraisals case study

Case Analysis: 360 Degree Appraisals Case Study

  Discuss the dilemma that jobe now faces

Why is it even more important that project team members work well together on international projects such as Project Abu Dhabi? Discuss the dilemma that Jobe now faces

  Analyze recent trends in world trade and foreign investments

Which depicts the arrangement of the assignment - current examples related to international business - Analyze recent trends in world trade and foreign investments with specific reference to FDI in retail sector. Illustrate how it will help develop..

  Analyze internal and external business processes

ISFM-300 Case Study, Stage 1: Business Environment Analysis - analyze internal and external business processes to identify information systems requirements

  Demonstrate knowledge of the social model of health

What are the social determinants of health that are evident in the case study - select one of these social determinants and describe the best way(s) to address this issue in order to have an impact on the whole of population?

  Prepare the case study on hardware and networking components

Prepare the case study on the given topic.-  The TOPIC is: "Hardware and networking components".

  Case study-omarama mountain lodge

Case Study: Omarama Mountain Lodge

  Who then customize and distribute the products to quality

who then customize and distribute the products to quality assurance labs for their sensitive test equipment. The yearly volume of output is 15,000 units.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd