What are dr vajis ethical alternatives for resolving dilemma

Assignment Help Case Study
Reference no: EM131207005

Case Study

Rashid Vaji, Ph.D., a member of the school psychology faculty at a midsize university, serves as a faculty supervisor for students assigned to externships in schools. The department has formalized a supervision and evaluation system for the extern program. Students have weekly individual meetings with the faculty supervisor and biweekly meetings with the on-site supervisor. The on-site supervisor writes a midyear

(December) and end of academic year (May) evaluation of each student. The site evaluations are sent to Dr. Vaji, and he provides feedback based on the site and his own supervisory evaluation to each student. The final grade (fail, low pass, pass, high pass) is the responsibility of Dr. Vaji. Dr. Vaji also teaches the Spring Semester graduate class on "Health Disparities in Mental Health." One of the course requirements is for students to write weekly thought papers, in which they are required to take the perspective of therapy clients from different ethnic groups in reaction to specific session topics. Leo Watson, a second-year graduate student is one of Dr. Vaji's externship supervisees. He is also enrolled in the Health Disparities course. Leo's thought papers often present ethnic-minority adolescents as prone to violence and unable to "grasp" the insights offered by school psychologists. In a classroom role-playing exercise, Leo "plays" an ethnic-minority student client as slumping in the chair not understanding the psychologist and giving angry retorts. In written comments on these thought papers and class feedback, Dr. Vaji encourages Leo to incorporate more of the readings on racial/ethnic discrimination and multicultural competence into his papers and to provide more complex perspectives on clients. One day during his office hours, three students from the class come to Dr. Vaji's office to complain about Leo's behavior outside the classroom. They describe incidents in which Leo uses derogatory ethnic labels to describe his externship clients and brags about "putting one over" on his site supervisors by describing these clients in "glowing" terms just to satisfy his supervisors' "stupid liberal do-good" attitudes. They also report an incident at a local bar at which Leo was seen harassing attitudes. They also report an incident at a local bar at which Leo was seen harassing an African American waitress using racial slurs. After the students have left his office, Dr. Vaji reviews his midyear evaluation and supervision notes on Leo and the midyear on-site supervisor's report. In his own evaluation report Dr. Vaji had written, "Leo often articulates a strong sense of duty to help his ethnic minority students overcome past discrimination but needs additional growth and supervision in applying a multicultural perspective into his clinical work." The on-site supervisor's evaluation states that:

Leo has a wonderful attitude towards his student clients . . . Unfortunately evaluation of his treatment skills is limited because Leo has had less cases to discuss than some of his peers since a larger than usual number of students have stopped coming to their sessions with him.

It is the middle of the Spring Semester, and Dr. Vaji still has approximately 6 weeks of supervision left with Leo. The students' complaints about Leo, while more extreme, are consistent with what Dr. Vaji has observed in Leo's class papers and role-playing exercises. However, these complaints are very different from his presentation during on-site supervision. If Leo has been intentionally deceiving both supervisors, then he may be more ineffective or harmful as a therapist to his current clients than either supervisor realized. In addition, purposeful attempts to deceive the supervisors might indicate a personality disorder or lack of integrity that if left unaddressed might be harmful to adolescent clients in the future.

Ethical Dilemma

Dr. Vaji would like to meet with Leo at minimum to discuss ways to retain adolescent clients and to improve his multicultural treatment skills. He does not know to what extent his conversation with Leo and final supervisory report should be influenced by the information provided by the graduate students

Respond to the following questions in 1,250 to 1,500 words.

1. Why is this an ethical dilemma? Which APA Ethical Principles help frame the nature of the dilemma?

2. To what extent, if any, should Dr. Vaji consider Leo's ethnicity in his deliberations? Would the dilemma be addressed differently if Leo self-identified as non-Hispanic White, Hispanic, on non-Hispanic Black?

3. How are APA Ethical Standards 1.08, 3.04, 3.05, 3.09, 7.04, 7.05, and 17.05 relevant to this case? Which other standards might apply?

4. What are Dr. Vaji's ethical alternatives for resolving this dilemma? Which alternative best reflects the Ethics Code aspirational principle and enforceable standard, as well as legal standards and obligations to stakeholders?

5. What steps should Dr. Vaji take to ethically implement his decision and monitor its effects?

Reference

Fisher, C. B. (2013). Decoding the ethics code: A practical guide for psychologists. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

Reference no: EM131207005

Questions Cloud

Significant amounts of time in practice : The crew chief spends significant amounts of time in practice with the pit crew. They try to reduce valuable seconds from their work times with the car while in the pits.
Can any two mothers be evaluated with your criteria : Can any two mothers be evaluated with your criteria? Why or why not? Would this evaluation be strengthened with more or less than five criteria? Why?
Find the rms values of the following sinusoidal waveforms : Find the rms values of the following sinusoidal waveforms:
Leaders of the organization behaves ethically : If the CEO and other top leaders of the organization behaves ethically, then so does the entire organization (and if they behave unethically so too). Support your conclusions using appropriate professional sources.
What are dr vajis ethical alternatives for resolving dilemma : What are Dr. Vaji's ethical alternatives for resolving this dilemma? Which alternative best reflects the Ethics Code aspirational principle and enforceable standard, as well as legal standards and obligations to stakeholders?
Relative to the staff assigned to the engagement : Discuss the necessary preparation and planning for the Lily Company annual audit before beginning fieldwork at the client's office. In your discussion, include the sources you should consult, the type of information you should seek, the preliminary p..
List all details of all the records in the customer table : ITECH 1006 - Database Management Systems Assignment. Create a text file called nnnnnnnn_query.sql (where nnnnnnnn is your student number).  The file should include the SQL statements necessary to display the following reports: List all details of a..
Paragraphs using a book or professional source : In THREE paragraphs using a book or professional source citation answer the following question: In what ways (be specific) has the international global business environment affected the way that American organizations behave?
Estimate standard deviation and variance in annual returns : The following table lists the stock prices for Microsoft from 1989 to 1998. The company did not pay any dividends during the period.  Estimate the average annual return you would have made on your investment. Estimate the standard deviation and varia..

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Case Study Questions & Answers

  Area of collection and insurance processing

How would Michele use her practicum experience to help her concentrate on improving her skills in the area of collection and insurance processing?

  Identifies the qualities of charismatic and transformation

How would you describe the dyadic relationship between Anne Mulcahy and Ursula Burns and One of the characteristics of effective teams is the presence of a capable and competent team leader.It describes different activities of the team leader in cr..

  What would be the emphasis in your appraisal, explain

Out of the three possible assessment targets (i.e., traits, behaviors, results) what would be the emphasis in your appraisal? Explain

  Share our insights about ethical principles in psychology

Read one of the Ethics Case Studies by Specialization applicable to your future career vision in the field.- What do you see as the ethical issue or issues involved in the case study you reviewed?

  Summarize and critique smith assessment

Summarize and critique Smith's assessment. Offer evidence/arguments that major changes in IT at WestJet were essential and that Smith's governance model would enable WestJet to achieve its strategic goal

  How will you show person-centered care to loretta

"How will you show person-centered care to Loretta?" Discuss person-centered care and outline how you would work with Loretta and her family to ensure the health outcomes important to them

  Case study on famous financial corporation

As head of the Information Protection Department of Famous Corporation, you have just received a call from the Senior Vice President of Human Resources informing you that in the past four days, there have four occurrences of money transfers to una..

  How are studio and live versions performed the differently

How are the studio and live versions performed the same or differently? The lyrics - are there changes or differences between the studio and live versions?

  Why was nancy rewarded for breaking the rules

Why was Nancy rewarded for breaking the rules? Describe what type of decision Nancy had to make. What decision alternatives were available to her besides the one she chose?

  Write a review paper about the given case study

Review Case Study 10-4, ‘Possible Illegal Discrimination at Tractors, Inc.'. After proper analysis of the system described, identify and evaluate the illegal issues, present or potential, that must be addressed.

  How do you feel about the external validity

Which factors affect the internal validity of Xaviers study given the experimental design - how do you feel about the external validity of this study?

  Write a xml with database with book details book id title

write a xml with database with book details book id title author subject publisher year language vendor and

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd