Theological problem of evil

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM13140067

Having a couple debates with two classmates, can you tell me what your scholarly response would be to this:

Millard Erickson posits three possible solutions to the problem of evil. The first of these is "Finitism" which concludes that God is not omnipotent. Brightman's version of this asserts that there are factors beyond God's control and inherently part of His nature. The important distinction is that God cannot cross these limitations by virtue of giving free will to humanity versus choosing not to cross them, which would be a theist's view. Erickson's summation of this view is that God is actually still uncertain that He can or will overcome evil. I agree with Erickson, that finitism makes God something less than He claims. If God can promises to have ultimate victory over evil, yet unable to have that knowledge or power for certain, how can he be trusted?

The second solution to evil in the world is espoused by Gordon C. Clark. This is a "modification of the concept of God's goodness." This idea does not view God as the author of sin, but as the ultimate cause of it. It is difficult to perceive God would be acting in accordance with His own character if He authored sin, yet difficult passages beg the question. For example, Lamentations 3:38 states, "Is it not from the mouth of the most high that both good and bad come?" This view that God is still sovereign yet not held guilty for sin or "edualistic" in nature is where Erickson finds problems with God's goodness. This is a very Reformed view of sovereignty and while it helps explain the issue of evil, it diminishes the goodness of God.

The third solution is a denial of evil. This view explains that what we perceive as â??evilâ? is simply an illusion. There is a dichotomy between anything material and anything spiritual, and only spiritual realities exist. All material things are created in the mind, including evil, sickness, and death. Erickson explains the Christian science position as a failure because those who believe it still die. This is the weakest of all three explanations. Scripture clearly refers to both spirit and body as realities, calling humanity to account for actions done â??in the body, whether good or evil. (2 Cor. 5:10) The repeated promises of God to judge evil in the world indicate that it is very real and will be judged. (Hebrews 9:27)

Erickson's view that evil is necessary to the creation of humans is closer to reality. I believe that by God giving freedom to humanity, as exercised in Gen. 3, evil is an available choice, otherwise we would be less than human. Thwarting God's master plan is not in our power, yet clearly we have the freedom to choose sin, and God is not guilty for our choice.

Erickson, Milliard. Christian Theology. 2nd edition. MI: Baker Academic, 1998.

Reference no: EM13140067

Questions Cloud

What is the ionization constant of this acid : A 0.200 M solution of a weak monoprotic acid HA is found to have a pH of 3.00 at room temperature. What is the ionization constant of this acid?
What risk calculation technique is illustrated by example : What risk calculation technique is illustrated by your example? Would you have employed a different risk assessment technique than used in your example, and why?
Common solutions to the problem of evil : What are the three common solutions to the problem of evil? Evaluate Erickson's response to these solutions.
What is the probability the game was played at night : The team wins 50 percent of their night games and 90 percent of their day games. According to today's newspaper, they won yesterday. What is the probability the game was played at night?
Theological problem of evil : Millard Erickson posits three possible solutions to the problem of evil. The first of these is "Finitism" which concludes that God is not omnipotent. Brightman's version of this asserts that there are factors beyond God's control and inherently pa..
Use of mediation, or third-party neutrality : How does a human services worker integrate the use of mediation, or third-party neutrality, when he or she also serves as an advocate for the client and is an employee of the agency?
Possible asset impairment : Which of the following would not indicate possible asset impairment?
Calculate the ph of a solution : A litre of solution containing 0.1 M of CH3COOH and 0.1 M of CH3COONa provides a buffer of pH 4.74 . calculate the pH of a solution after the addition of 0.02 M of NaOH .
Probability that selected residents are under thirty one : If a survey of 109 randomly selected united states residents is to be taken, what is the approximate probability that at least 60 will be under 31 years of age?

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  Information about definition of terrorism

How do we define terrorism and why is such a definition important to Homeland Security? Discuss why there is confusion when trying to define terrorism.

  Describe perceptual blocks and habits to hinder thinking

Describe perceptual blocks and habits which hinder your thinking when looking at opposing view and defending your own view.

  Research methods in sociology

Explain and explain the four different types of research methods in sociology when conducting research for the hypothesis or theories.

  Work of counseling professionals

I need help in comparing the work of counseling professionals who deal with the mentally ill and those who treat the chemically dependent. Does anyone live in Wisconsin or know of Wisconsin's state certification or licensure processes?

  Child personality development

How do our views on corporal punishment impact a child's personality development? How do we apply Skinner's theory and behavior modification techniques to correct children's behavior in a positive manner?

  Describe personality and its significance

What is personality and why is it important to study? What famous theorist comes to mind when we discuss personality?

  Explain ideal american

Illustrate out the "ideal American" in your own words. Describe the difference between a right and a freedom/privilege in the U.S. by providing examples of "rights" and "freedoms" American citizens have.

  Privacy protections enhancing the employee motivation

How could privacy protections enhance employee motivation and productivity based upon an employee handbook?

  Explain ruled by the body for general population

Why might information in this essay be significant for the general population? What is the most significant message in this article for personally; like, what struck you as especially significant?

  Evidence based medicine tools

What are the pros and cons of implementing clinical pathways and/or practice guidelines or other evidence based medicine tools?

  Reflection on human memory abilities

It is fascinating that what we originally thought was just our memory, has now been broken down into short-term, long-term memory, implicit and explicit memory

  Explain forces for strong team member in american culture

Write down the forces for and against being the strong team member are embedded in American culture? How would you explain them from perspective of the team leader?

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd