The phrase ''tax rate'' is at least three ways ambiguous

Assignment Help Science
Reference no: EM13942278

You can type your answers right on this document or record them on a separate document.

1.       What is the conclusion of this argument?

If sea levels rise dramatically then some low islands are at danger of disappearing.  The Maldives are coral islands in the Indian Ocean none of which are more than six feet above sea level.  Islands whose highest points are less than three meters above sea level are low islands.  The Maldives are at danger if oceans rise, for six feet is obviously less than three meters.  

a.       If sea levels rise dramatically then some low islands are at danger of disappearing.

b.      The Maldives are coral islands in the Indian Ocean none of which are more than six feet above sea level. 

c.       Islands whose highest points are less than three meters above sea level are low islands. 

d.      The Maldives are at danger if oceans rise.

e.      Six feet is obviously less than three meters.

2.       Read or listen to Patrick Henry's 'Give Me Liberty' speech.  Identify and reconstruct at least one of Henry's arguments.  Put it into standard form, paraphrasing and adding premises if necessary.  You can find the text and audio of the speech here: https://www.history.org/almanack/life/politics/giveme.cfm

3.       Reconstruct (but don't evaluate) the arguments at the end of Supplemental Reading: Introduction to Arguments.  Put the arguments into standard form, adding premises where necessary.  The arguments are repeated here for convenience:

A.      We have an obligation to do whatever our employer tells us to do. This is clear because employees are the property of employers. Also, property is controlled by its owner and people have to do something if they are controlled to do it.

B.      We discover our moral obligations by looking at the animal kingdom. Whatever the animal kingdom does is natural. So, we have a moral obligation to do what is natural. Chemotherapy is not natural. Therefore, we have a moral obligation to avoid chemotherapy.

C.      If Keynes is right then governments should spend more in a recession. But obviously, governments should not spend more in a recession; they should spend less. So, Keynes is wrong.

D.      Shamu is a whale; so Shamu is a mammal. Since mammals bear live young, Shamu bears live young.

E.       Alberto Gonzales said that the U.S. cannot wait for another terrorist attack. If we can't wait for something then we eagerly anticipate it. So if Gonzales was right then the U.S. eagerly anticipates a terrorist attack.

F.       Karen would like nothing more than for her son to come home for Christmas. Karen's son did nothing for her for Christmas. Consequently, Karen liked what she got from her son more than she would have liked his coming home.

4.       Consider the following argument and say which sentence is a sub-conclusion (both a premise and a conclusion).

There is substantial evidence that Abner Doubleday did not invent baseball.  He made no mention of it in his many letters and papers.  He certainly would have mentioned the sport if he had invented it.  Furthermore, the first recorded attribution of the sport's invention to Doubleday-a 1908 commission report-claimed that Doubleday invented the sport in Cooperstown in 1839. However, he was enrolled at the U.S. Military Academy at West Point (>150 mi. trip) at that time and there is no evidence that he obtained leave.  The current Major League Baseball commissioner, Bud Selig, believes that Doubleday did invent the game.  Since there is evidence that Doubleday did not invent the sport and Bud Selig still believes that he did, Bud Selig is an idiot.

a.       There is evidence that Abner Doubleday did not invent baseball.

b.      He made no mention of it in his many letters and papers.

c.       He would have mentioned the sport if he had invented it.

d.      Bud Selig believes that Doubleday did invent the game.

e.      Bud Selig is an idiot.

5.       In his 2008 movie Religulous, Bill Maher argues that the U.S.'s founding fathers weren't as religious as they're taken to be.  In defense he mentions that John Adams said

(A)   This would be the best of all possible worlds if there were no religion in it. 

The quote is taken from an 1817 letter to Thomas Jefferson in which Adams says

(B)   Twenty times in the course of my late Reading, have I been upon the point of breaking out "This would be the best of all possible Worlds if there were no Religion in it"!!! But in this exclamation I should have been as fanatical as Bryant or Cleverly.  Without Religion this World would be Something not fit to mention in polite company, I mean Hell. 

The longer quotation from Adams reveals a point much different from what's implied by the shorter one.  Is it possible to criticize the evidence that Maher offers for his conclusion?  Why?

a.       No.  The movie is billed as a comedy and it is inappropriate to critically analyze a comedy since the claims are not intended to be taken seriously.

b.      No.  (A) is contained in (B) so it is not possible to say (B) without saying (A).  Since Adams said (B) it follows that Adams said (A).  So it is appropriate to say that he said (A).

c.       Yes.  It would only be evidence that Adams wasn't religious if he had used sentence (A).  Instead he mentioned sentence (A).

d.      Yes.  Maher has a history of mocking religion by employing deceptive tactics and misleading editing.  This is just another example.   

e.      Yes and no.  Maher is not a credible authority on the words of John Adams.  We have little reason to think that an entertainer like Maher would quote Adams correctly.  So we shouldn't accept his evidence but we also shouldn't hold him to too high a standard.

6.       Say whether the following words are (just) vague, (just) ambiguous, both vague and ambiguous, or neither.  Briefly justify your answer. (a) Middle class (b) Odd number (c) Gold (d) Bank (e) Opportunity (f) Socialist (g) Credit

7.       Some of the arguments you reconstructed for number 3 above equivocate.  Say which arguments are equivocations.  Also, say what the possible meanings of the ambiguous word or phrase are. 

8.       The phrase 'tax rate' is at least three ways ambiguous.  There's the rate on paper (before deductions), the effective rate (amount paid as a percentage of profits), and total amount paid as a percentage of GDP.  Watch this video (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fj10f7v1xaU) and reconstruct at least one of the arguments presented.  Then watch this one (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yXzapM9useA) and say whether Buffet (the guy in the second video) gives a criticism of the argument you found in the first video, or a different argument.  If he gives a criticism, say whether it's of a premise or the form.  If he gives a different argument, reconstruct it.  

Reference no: EM13942278

Questions Cloud

Was the code does syntactically right : Access the array 4 Java program. Code, compile, and run the program. There are four lines of code marked (1)..(4) that you must explain after analyzing the code, running the program, and examining the output.
Consumer health informatics : Consumer Health Informatics (CHI) is the field that helps to connect the gap between patients and health resources. Its focus is to provide patients with the most complete health information possible.
Write essay in which compare a short story to film version : Write an essay in which you compare a short story to the film version or to another form of visual media. You may select any short story of your choice; however, you must write the essay in the format of a comparison / contrast essay.
Best exemplifies a free trade agreement : Which of the following best exemplifies a free trade agreement?
The phrase ''tax rate'' is at least three ways ambiguous : If sea levels rise dramatically then some low islands are at danger of disappearing.  The Maldives are coral islands in the Indian Ocean none of which are more than six feet above sea level.  Islands whose highest points are less than three meters ab..
What is the role of weights in deterring portfolio return : Year-to-date, Oracle had earned a −1.34 percent return. During the same time period, Valero Energy earned 7.96 percent and McDonald's earned 0.88 percent. If you have a portfolio made up of 30 percent Oracle, 25 percent Valero Energy, and 45 percent ..
Training methods practiced by the chosen organsiation : On the basis of your work experience and any information available to you, identify any two training methods practiced by the chosen organsiation.
National city corporation and sun trust bank : Out of amsouth bank, National City Corporation and sun trust bank (STI), which seems to be growing faster and why?
Analyze the possible meanings of mouthwash or deodorant : Analyze the possible meanings of mouthwash or deodorant in terms of positive (perceived benefits) and negative (perceived risks) consequences of use. Why are both types of meaning important?

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Science Questions & Answers

  Do you realize that the vast majority of painful animal

exercise 3.1 passage a4nbspwhich of the various functions of language are exemplified by each of the following

  A majority candidate or party receives more than half of all

A majority candidate or party receives more than half of all votes cast

  Problems based on capnocytophaga bacterial infection

A patient with AIDS has a low TH cell count. Why does this patient have trouble making antibodies? How does this patient make any antibodies?

  Issues on research methodology

Most physicians don't do research and medical school provides little training in research methodology.

  The threefold system of the buddhist religion

Can you please explain the vehicles of the twofold system and the threefold system of the Buddhist religion? I am having a hard time understanding the significance of the vehicles and the difference between the twofold and threefold systems.

  Npr receives public funding from taxpayers

NPR receives public funding from taxpayers

  The component in the electron transport chain

True or False: The component in the electron transport chain with the most positive delta E is oxygen.

  What are the cultural and societal influences that have

writenbspa 700- to 1000-word paper answering the following questionsconsidering that hinduism lacks a uniting belief

  Describe one 1 of your bosses who exhibited the same types

determine the leadership style that peter vyas exhibited as he considered the groups proposal and provide examples of

  Major hydrologic components of a watershed

Using the methods in Box C-2, compute the mean, standard deviation, coefficient of variation, and skewness of the three time series of Table 2-2. Which time series is the most variable, relatively speaking? Briefly (2-3 sentences) discuss why.

  Exchanging information

This is a Healthcare Information Technology class, this assignment is about information exchange and interoporability

  The extent of the public health problem

Describing the public health problem in a way that can be easily communicated

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd