Stockholders fund major public corporations

Assignment Help Operation Management
Reference no: EM132234360

Marjorie Kelly and the Divine Right of Capital

Marjorie Kelly

What do shareholders contribute, to justify the extraordinary allegiance they receive? They take risk, we’re told. They put their money on the line, so corporations might grow and prosper. Let’s test the truth of this with a little quiz:

Stockholders fund major public corporations—true or false?

False. Or, actually, a tiny bit true—but for the most part, massively false. In fact, most “investment” dollars don’t go to corporations but to other speculators. Equity investments reach a public corporation only when new common stock is sold—which for major cor- porations is a rare event. Among the Dow Jones industrials, only a handful have sold any new common stock in thirty years. Many have sold none in fifty years.

The stock market works like a used car market, as former accounting professor Ralph Estes observes in Tyranny of the Bottom Line. When you buy a 1997 Ford Escort, the money goes not to Ford but to the previous owner of the car. Ford gets the buyer’s money only when it sells a new car. Similarly, companies get stockholders’ money only when they sell new common stock.

So, what do stockholders contribute to justify the extraordinary allegiance they re- ceive? Very little. Yet this tiny contribution allows them essentially to install a pipeline and dictate that the corporation’s sole purpose is to funnel wealth into it.

It’s odd. And it’s connected to a second oddity—that we believe stockholders are the corporation. When we say that a corporation did well, we mean that its shareholders did well. The company’s local community might be devastated by plant closings. Employees might be shouldering a crushing workload. Still we will say, “The corporation did well.”

One does not see rising employee incomes as a measure of corporate success. Indeed, gains to employees are losses to the corporation. And this betrays an unconscious bias: that employees are not really part of the corporation. They have no claim on the wealth they create, no say in governance, and no vote for the board of directors. They’re not citizens of corporate society, but subjects.

We think of this as the natural law of the market. It’s more accurately the result of the corporate governance structure, which violates market principles. In real markets, every- one scrambles to get what they can, and they keep what they earn. In the construct of the corporation, one group gets what another earns.

The oddity of it all is veiled by the incantation of a single magical word: ownership. Because we say stockholders own corporations, they are permitted to contribute very lit- tle, and take quite a lot.

What an extraordinary word. One is tempted to recall the comment that Lycophron, an ancient Greek philosopher, made during an early Athenian slave uprising against the aristocracy. “The splendor of noble birth is imaginary and its [prerogatives] are based upon mere word.”

The problem is not the free market, but the design of the corporation. It’s important to separate these two concepts we have been schooled to equate. In truth, the market is a relatively innocent notion. It’s about buyers and sellers bargaining on equal footing to set prices. It might be said that a free market means an unregulated one, but in today’s scheme it means a market with one primary form of regulation: that of property rights.

Shareholder primacy is a form of entitlement. And entitlement has no place in a mar- ket economy. It is a form of privilege. And privilege accruing to property ownership is a remnant of the aristocratic past. That more people own stock today has not changed the market’s essential aristocratic bias. Of the total gain in marketable wealth from 1983 to 1998, more than half went to the richest 1 percent. Others of us may have gotten a few crumbs from this feast, but in their pursuit we have too often been led to work against our own interests. Physicians applaud when their portfolios rise in value, yet wonder why insurance companies are ruthlessly holding down medical payments. Employees cheer when their 401(k) plans post gains, yet wonder why layoffs are decimating their firms. Their own portfolios hold the answer.

How do we begin to change such an entrenched and ancient system of discrimina- tion? We begin by seeing it for what it is, and naming it as illegitimate. For doing so allows us to reclaim our economic sovereignty—which means remembering that cor- porations are creations of the law, that they exist only because we the people allow them to exist, and that we create the parameters of their existence.

Listed below are some questions from this reading. Your initial post should address all of these questions.

How do the two authors (Novak and Kelly) differ on happiness?

What distinction does Kelly make about the role of corporations?

List the differences in perceptions between Novak and Kelly about corporations.

Reference no: EM132234360

Questions Cloud

How technology governance is done in organization : Describe how technology governance is done in an organization you participate in, have knowledge about, or research.
New technology or business strategy of corporation : A brief overview or introduction of the new technology or business strategy of a corporation
Demonstrates the challenges law enforcement may face : Discuss an international newsworthy event that demonstrates the challenges law enforcement may face.
Explain the importance of responsible alcohol service : Explain the importance of responsible alcohol service.
Stockholders fund major public corporations : What do shareholders contribute, to justify the extraordinary allegiance they receive? Stockholders fund major public corporations
Most effective and which were found to be less effective : Which of these strategies was found to be most effective and which were found to be less effective?
Segmenting purchasing according to supply market complexity : Segmenting purchasing according to supply market complexity and importance can make it easier for you to manage.
Part of which step in the strategic sourcing process : Supplier score cards are most likely to be part of which step in the strategic sourcing process?
Why should you create personal strategic plan : Strategic planning is important because it provides a sense of direction and outlines measurable goals. Why should you create a personal strategic plan?

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Operation Management Questions & Answers

  Examine prior government policies and legislation

One dataset related to production and business activity within the market or industry you choose to analyze.

  Reasonable accommodations to employees with disabilities

Identify at least two ways employers can provide reasonable accommodations to employees with disabilities. Provide examples.

  Several ways whether the social responsibility

This chapter has asked in several ways whether the social responsibility of the companies you patronize has ever made any difference to your purchasing decisions. Will it make any difference in the future as a result of what you have learned? Do your..

  Explain the importance of further research

Write an introductory paragraph with at least 150 words, which clearly explains the topic, the importance of further research, and ethical implications.

  Identify the different air traffic controlling agencies

Identify the different air traffic controlling agencies a commercial airline flight crew would experience while flying across the United States between two large commercial airports (from taxi out to taxi in). Include in your discussion a brief descr..

  Create a mind map or info-graphic of four potential roles

Create a mind map or info-graphic of four potential roles of humans resources representatives that summarizes 7 to 10 characteristics or responsibilities.

  The fallacy of affirming the consequent

Symbolize the following sentences using the connectives The fallacy of Affirming the Consequent,

  What is probability that the laptop will perform reliably

What is the probability that the LAPTOP will perform reliably during a 4 hour exam?

  Describe the important components of qwl programs

Explain your understanding of transformational leaders and transactional leaders. Next, do you consider the leader of your project organization to be a transformational or transactional leader? Why? Provide specific examples to support your positi..

  Darla was liable under the misappropriation theory

Discuss whether or not Darla was liable under the misappropriation theory.

  How would you expect executive performance to change

How, if at all, would you expect executive performance to change in response to the new control system?

  Collective societies affect international tourism

How does an Individualistic and collective societies affect international tourism? For instance the US is a individualistic society where as Portugal is a collective society. how would these differences affect the amount of US citizens that choose to..

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd