Should this project be evaluated using different standards

Assignment Help Financial Management

Reference no: EM131065688

Charlie Henderson, a senior manager at your company is known for taking risks. He recently proposed that the company expand its operations into a new and untried field. He put together a set of cash flow projections and calculated an IRR of 25% for the project. The firm’s cost of capital is about 10%. Charlie maintains that the favorability of the calculated IRR relative to the cost of capital makes the project an easy choice for acceptance, and urges management to move forward immediately.

Several knowledgeable people have looked at the proposal and feel Charlie’s projections represent an optimistic scenario that has about one chance in three of happening. They think the project also has about one chance in three of failing miserably. An important consideration is that the project is large enough to bankrupt the company if it fails really badly.

Charlie doesn’t want to talk about these issues, claiming the others are being “negative” and that he has a history of success with risky ventures like this. When challenged, he falls back on the 25% IRR versus the 10% cost of capital as justification for his idea.

The company president has asked you for your comments on the situation. Specifically address the issue of the 25% IRR versus the 10% cost of capital. Should this project be evaluated using different standards? How does the possibility of bankruptcy as a result of the project affect the analysis? Are capital budgeting rules still appropriate? How should Charlie’s successful record be factored into the president’s thinking?

Reference no: EM131065688

Questions Cloud

Compute the equivalent annual annuity of project : Johnson Jets is considering two mutually exclusive projects. Project A has an up-front cost of $122,000 (CF0 = -122,000), and produces positive after-tax cash inflows of $30,000 a year at the end of each of the next six years. Compute the equivalent ..

What is the bonds yield to call-yield to maturity higher : Venture Corp issued 7 year 5% bonds due 2023 at par. This bond pays interest on a semi-annual basis. However, right after Venture issued the bonds, the Company missed its first earnings and at the same time, the interest rate environment changed. Ass..

Describes residual claimants : Which of the following describes residual claimants? A) they are paid first in default. B) they cannot lose money under current US law. C) They receive what is left after all other debts are settled. D)They are generally considered to be secured cred..

Firm is considering two different capital structures : A firm is considering two different capital structures. The first option is an all-equity firm with 32,000 shares of stock. The second option is 20,000 shares of stock plus some debt. Ignoring taxes, the break-even level of earnings before interest a..

Should this project be evaluated using different standards : Charlie Henderson, a senior manager at your company is known for taking risks. He recently proposed that the company expand its operations into a new and untried field. He put together a set of cash flow projections and calculated an IRR of 25% for t..

Thinking about purchasing a new computer : You are thinking about purchasing a new computer since the machine you are using now is four years old, slow, not always reliable, and does not support the latest operating system. Part of the reason this distinction is important is that a decision s..

Percentage return on the investment for the year : You purchased 800 shares of stock on December 31, 2014 for $32.45 per share. The stock pays an annual dividend of $3.25 per share. (Assume dividends are paid at the end of the year.) On December 31, 2015, the market price is $43.59 per share. What is..

Consequences of not having done any stock split : Warrent Buffett, chairman and chief executive of Berkshire Hathaway commented in Berkshire's 1983 annual report: "We are often asked why Berkshire does not split its stock.... we want shareholders who think to themselves as business owners with the i..

Profitability-taxes-capital structure-psycological impact : Microsoft declared a dividend for the first time in 2003. a) What goes into the decision of a company to initiate a "regular" dividend? Some terms that come to my mind: profitability, taxes, capital structure, psycological impact, etc. b) And for a "..

User Account

All Pages