Should informed consent be different for different cultures

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM131056914

Case Study - Informed Consent

APA Style and Formatting.

Provide your impression by responding to the questions below and provide supporting references for your position. This commentary should be at least 3 to 5 pages, with references in APA format.

Is Informed Consent still central to medical ethics?

The Patient Self-Determination Act, a federal law that went into effect in 1991, requires health care institutions to advise patients about their right to accept or refuse medical care and to offer them an opportunity to create an advance directive indicating their medical choices, should they become incompetent. Nevertheless, there is considerable evidence that patients and their designated health care proxies are not brought into decision making at the end of life in a timely and effective way. There are also some limits on what kind of information must be provided to patients.

In the 1993 case of Arato v. Avedon, the California Supreme Court supported information sharing and patient-centered decision making, but ruled that doctors need not supply explicit statistical information about life expectancy to patients. Nonetheless, the concept of informed consent from Western political and ethical theories that place a high value on individual self-determination, remains a central principle in the U.S. Cultural groups who have different traditions may not share this value." (Levine, 2007, p. 20)

Should informed consent be different for different cultures? Why or why not? How should medical professionals and health care organizations balance cultural preferences with full disclosure?

Reference
Levine, C. (2007). Taking sides: Clashing views on bioethical issues (12th ed.). Dubuque, IA: McGraw-Hill/Dushkin Publication Group.

Reference no: EM131056914

Questions Cloud

Describe m-commerce and explain how it is different : Describe m-commerce and explain how it is different from regular EC and describe three human-based controls for safeguarding information systems. What is EC, and what different business models do companies use to compete in cyberspace?
Two asset portfolio including SPDRs and T-bills : You want to build a two asset portfolio including SPDRs and T-bills that has an expected return of 3.36%. A SPDR is a standard and Poor's Depositary Receipt. A SPDR is an exchange traded fund that is designed to generate the same return as the S&P 50..
Coupon bond-compute the exact price change : You just purchased a coupon bond with face value $1000, 6% coupons, and three years remaining to maturity. Assume that all market interest rates are 7 %. (a) What is the duration of this bond? Compute the exact price change (using the present value f..
Determinethe volume flow rate and shaft power output : the relative flow angles at the runner inlet and outlet at the hub, at the mean radius and at the tip.
Should informed consent be different for different cultures : Should informed consent be different for different cultures? Why or why not? How should medical professionals and health care organizations balance cultural preferences with full disclosure?
Australian labour migrations policies mutually advantageous : Things to consider are the Australian visas, number 457 , 476, 416, and 858. Find a specific case study talk on. and provide policy recommendations to the case study and also provide a policy brief recommendation
Ph of the solution after he adds : Zach Thomas makes a buffer composed of 25 mL of 0.20 M acetic acid and 25 mL of 0.20 M sodium acetate. If he adds 10 mL of 0.20 M HCl to the solution, what is the pH of the solution after he adds the HCl? (pKa of acetic acid = 4.76)
Discrepancy between maximizing profits and maximizing value : Actions that maximize profit may not maximize shareholder wealth. What role can the time value of money play in explaining the discrepancy between maximizing profits and maximizing value?
Compare the obtained value and the critical value : The average annual expenditure for health care by men is $1,096 with a standard deviation of $205 and women is $1,234 with a standard deviation of $310. Compare the obtained value and the critical value

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  Explain three or more historical perspectives of terrorism

Explain three or more historical perspectives of terrorism. Terrorism has sometimes been interpreted as a way of fighting between those in power and those seeking power

  Environmental genre

Select a book from the environmental genre that you would like to read a critique, while reading the book, listen to you (what you are thinking and feeling). What surprised you? What did you agree/disagree with?

  Compare and contrast natural and technological disasters

Compare and contrast natural and technological disasters, providing examples to support your answer.

  What advertising-publicity and sales promotion tools

What advertising, publicity, and sales promotion tools might be combined to market a new health care product and service? Provide examples

  Idiom-analogy-metaphor-simile-cliche-amphiboly

Define the meaning and function of each term: Idiom, Analogy, Metaphor, Simile, Cliche, Amphiboly, Flame word, Hyperbole, Euphemism, Colloquialism

  Maximum thickness of the gold layer covering the front face

What should be the maximum thickness of the gold layer covering the front face of a surface barrier detector used for the measurement of 10Mev alphas, if the energy loss of the alphas traversing the layer should be less than 0.1% of the kinetic energ..

  Aspproaches to personality theory

Explain the 6 approaches to personality theory, and describe how each approach views aggression or depression.

  What is the social problem the researchers are investigating

What is the social problem the researchers are investigating

  Series of equal paymentsinto a savings account

In a sinking fund, a firm makes a series of equal paymentsinto a savings account in order to have a certain dollar amountavailable at some point in the future. whay type of time valueproblem is this?

  Discuss why you think considerations of moral leadership

answer the following question in a paper of 500 to 800 words 2 pages.discuss why you think considerations of moral

  Describe the problems of selection of personal protective

explain the problems of selection of personal protective equipment and the comprehensive requirements that must be met

  What is the component of the net torque

What is the net torque about the origin on a flea located at coordinates (0 m,-7 m, 8 m) when forces 1 = ( 3.0 N)  and 2 = (-2.0 N)  act on the flea?

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd