Should health departments be able to isolate

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM131413939

Assignment: Discussion-Government Authority to Regulate Public Health

In Jacobson v. Massachusetts (1905), the United States Supreme Court upheld the right of states to enact compulsory vaccination laws-one of the most challenging constitutional dimensions of public health. It also provided the terms for what would eventually become a core question of public health ethics.

This case has become the precedent for many cases that have challenged vaccination laws. Both majority and dissenting opinions in numerous decisions have cited this case in reference to states' authority to constrain individual behavior. These cases have involved issues ranging from fluoridation of municipal water supplies, to abortion, to the right to die. In Buck v. Bell (1927), the Supreme Court used Jacobson v. Massachusetts (1905) to uphold a forced-sterilization law using the reasoning that society must be protected from the burdens imposed by the offspring of "imbeciles." Despite the troubling uses to which this decision has been put, public health law texts continue to cite the case as an example of the ways that public health practices must resolve the tensions between individual rights and the collective well-being.

Based on these Supreme Court decisions, respond to the following:

  • Do you believe health departments should be able to enter your house without a warrant from a judge?
  • Should health departments be able to isolate or quarantine you without a trial? Why or why not?

Give examples and reasons in support of your responses.

Respond to the question using the lessons and vocabulary found in the readings. Support your answers with examples and research. Your responses should clarify your understanding of the topic. They should be your own, original, and free from plagiarism. Follow the APA format for writing style, spelling and grammar, and citation of sources.

Buck v. Bell, 274 U.S. 200 (1927).

Jacobson v. Massachusetts, 197 U.S. 11 (1905).

Reference no: EM131413939

Questions Cloud

What numerical summaries can you use for this data : In Research project 5.2 we described a set of data that had been collected by Jan Schwartzkopf. What numerical summaries can you use for this data?
What makes his argument flawed or incomplete : How does the author persuade us that his argument is valid, or conversely, what makes his argument flawed or incomplete?
Identify a public health program : Identify a public health program in your community, city, or state. Research the factors associated with the program and provide the following: Identify a public health program
What about rfid technology for wal-mart : What has Wal-Mart done with their supply chain to gain competitive advantages? Technology? What about RFID technology for Wal-Mart,? How have they been able to leverage technology like RFID to gain competitive advantages?
Should health departments be able to isolate : Do you believe health departments should be able to enter your house without a warrant from a judge? Should health departments be able to isolate or quarantine you without a trial? Why or why not
What is the annual rate of inflation for each year : The UK government publishes several values for inflation, each of which is calculated in a different way. How do the figures above compare with other published results? Why are there differences? How do these figures compare with those from other ..
Describe bridgets communication competence : Describe Bridget's communication competence/incompetence in interpersonal situations. Critics have argued that the end of Bridget Jones's Diary feels rushed, and that the "heroic" behavior of Mark Darcy is not fully motivated in the novel. Do you ..
What will be the range of international prices for beef : Using the linear PPF, draw the host country's PPF: show an approximate level of domestic production and consumption before and after trade. What will be the range of international prices for beef.
Calculate a base-weighted index and a currentweighted index : Calculate a base-weighted index and a currentweighted index for the products.

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  Write the direct response to the complaint

Respond to Mr. Badenuf's complaint along the lines of sympathy, freebies, and reassurance that your company does not wish to lose customers. Are his requests reasonable in light of his complaint?

  Write a response that addresses the main ideas of the video

View the video about Otto Dix's "The War" triptych held in Dresden (Germany). Then submit a minimum 150 word response that addresses the main ideas and themes.

  Understand your own emotional intelligence

In your OWN words or OPINION, Why is it important to understand your own emotional intelligence or EQ? Do you believe that emotional intelligence is something that can be tested and measured accurately?

  Define the issues identified in the selected news articles

This document must clearly define the issues identified in the selected news articles and how those issues relate to and/or impact security operations. Most importantly, the document must provide proposals of solutions to the issues and the measur..

  Discuss the idea of the reliable narrator

Discuss the idea of the Reliable Narrator in one of the authors read up until this point. Use specific examples from outside sources and the text to show why it should or should not be believed that this author is reliable

  Describe a capital expenditure of the company

Describe a capital expenditure of the company. Why is this item a capital expenditure. Explain your answer. How does this capital expenditure contribute to the long-term goals of the company as described earlier. Explain your answer.

  The dietary regimen-optimal nutrition

The dietary regimen that would provide optimal nutrition for a person who is recovering from an extended illness is a diet

  Models for paying for healthcare

which of the following are models for paying for healthcare?

  What is the purpose of calibrating instruments and why is

what is the purpose of calibrating instruments and why is it important to do so prior to their use? what are the

  Example of gender socialization

A clear example of gender socialization is: Which of the following statements is true about the selection of names for newborn children? Which of the following aspects is not characteristic of the “ideal” American male? Social forces that keep women ..

  Describe the basic argument of opposing viewpoints

Describe the basic issue of your chosen topic. Describe the basic argument of opposing viewpoints. Identify the strengths and weaknesses of both views.

  What are different roles that parties play in politics

What are challenges that parties face in state and local elections? What are different roles that parties play in politics? What are different forms of participation, beyond the voting booth

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd